Epidemiologist aims to sort fact from fiction on dietary supplements

March 22, 2018, Harvard University
Harvard epidemiologist JoAnn Manson is working on two trials aimed at measuring the effectiveness of dietary supplements. Credit: Rose Lincoln/Harvard

The world of dietary supplements can seem like the Wild West, with the dizzying vitamin alphabet lumped with a lineup of minerals that sound as if they belong in an industrial vat rather than our bodies.

JoAnn Manson, Harvard Medical School's Michael and Lee Bell Professor of Women's Health, professor of epidemiology at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, and chief of the Division of Preventive Medicine at Brigham and Women's Hospital, has made a career of studying population health.

Manson recently co-authored a Viewpoint article in the Journal of the American Medical Association highlighting what scientists do and don't know about supplements, and providing guidance to doctors on what to recommend to patients. In addition, she is in the middle of two exploring the health effects of some of the most widely used supplements, including D, fish oil, multivitamins, and cocoa.

GAZETTE: What makes the landscape of vitamins and supplements so confusing that even doctors need guidance?

MANSON: Vitamins are big business—more than $30 billion a year. Anytime you go to a supermarket or drug store, you're going to see aisles and aisles of vitamins, minerals, and other dietary supplements. There's also a lot of talk about vitamins in the media.

Research studies on vitamins have often had discrepant findings. That's partly because some studies are while others are observational. Observational studies look at people who choose to take supplements, and examine their risk of heart disease, cancer, or other outcomes. In contrast, in a , people agree to be assigned at random to take vitamins versus a placebo. The different studies tend to provide different results for dietary supplements, but often the media does not make a distinction between the two. Observational studies tend to show that people who choose to take supplements are healthier, but that may be because they are more health-conscious and also have healthier diets and healthier lifestyles.

GAZETTE: So because of the design of the research, it might be a self-selected healthier population that is being studied?

MANSON: Exactly. There can be selection for more health-conscious people who are also compliant with taking supplements long-term, as well as confounding by other lifestyle practices, such as physical activity and diet.

The randomized clinical trials avoid bias from selection and confounding factors, and they tend to show little, if any, benefit of these supplements in healthy individuals. And the randomized trials have also identified risks. Randomized trials of beta-carotene show increased risk of lung cancer in smokers, randomized trials of vitamin E show increased risk of heart failure, bleeding-related strokes, prostate cancer, and even all-cause mortality in some studies. There's also some concern about selenium in high doses.

So it's a very confusing literature because the observational studies and randomized trials have provided some discrepant results while the public is bombarded with hype about supplements in the media and advertising. That said, the do have the advantage of being able to assess long-term use—over decades—while randomized trials tend to be shorter, often less than five years, due to their higher cost.

GAZETTE: Is the industry regulated?

MANSON: It is not regulated the way prescription drugs are. If clear risks are identified, supplements can be taken off the market, but generally makers don't have to prove their products are effective—or safe—when they're put on the market as over-the-counter supplements. That's why we also recommend that people look on the labels for signs of quality control and external, independent audits, such as the U.S. Pharmacopeia or NSF International, or for some indication that the products have been tested for quality—that they actually have the content that it says on the label, that they're free of microbes and heavy metals.

GAZETTE: Let's talk about your own work. This is an area in which you have a couple of trials going on, right?

MANSON: Right. We're now analyzing the data and finishing up the vitamin D and omega-3 trial VITAL. That's a large-scale, randomized trial of vitamin D with and without omega-3 fatty acids, or fish oil. There are four treatment groups, more than 25,000 participants nationwide, and we're looking at each of these interventions for prevention of cancer and cardiovascular disease. We're also looking at cognitive function, diabetes, autoimmune diseases, and a number of other disorders. So we're testing these very commonly used dietary supplements for their efficacy and safety over an average of five years.

We're also doing a large-scale, randomized trial of multivitamins and cocoa flavonol supplements, the COSMOS trial. Even though multivitamins are used by half of the population, we have very little data on their efficacy or safety. There's been only one previous large-scale, randomized trial of multivitamins. That was in men, the Physicians' Health Study II, and we're now testing it in both men and women.

GAZETTE: How do you pick your trial topics? Are you looking to debunk or confirm information that might be in front of the public?

MANSON: The goal isn't to refute previous findings. We're looking at what we think are promising supplements. We're trying to identify that are effective and have a favorable benefit/risk profile.

GAZETTE: What is the evidence so far for healthy adults?

MANSON: It's very limited. Pregnant women should take folic acid and prenatal vitamins to avoid neural tube defects and related birth defects. That includes women of reproductive age who are planning to become pregnant or may become pregnant, including those who are not taking reliable birth control. Some of these risks can occur in the very early weeks of pregnancy, often before women know they're pregnant.

There are guidelines for infants, especially infants who are breastfed, and . Aside from those groups, there is minimal evidence that routine vitamin or mineral supplementation will benefit healthy individuals. Targeted supplementation in high-risk individuals, such as those with osteoporosis, malabsorption, or those taking certain medications, is a separate question.

People are generally encouraged to get vitamins and minerals from a healthy, well-balanced diet. Micronutrients are better absorbed through the diet and a person will receive many other beneficial components besides these micronutrients. And through the diet, you get the optimal biological ratio of vitamins and minerals as opposed to a mega-dose of a particular supplement that can cause harm and may interfere with the absorption or bioavailability of other vitamins and minerals.

GAZETTE: What about people who are on the go and don't really eat healthy diets?

MANSON: If someone is really concerned about their diet, they're not having fruits and vegetables for whatever reason, they're eating a lot of processed foods—which actually can strip foods of vitamins and minerals and healthful micronutrients—and they don't think they can improve or modify their diet, then it's reasonable to take a multivitamin or other vitamin-mineral supplement as a form of insurance. However, it's still not a substitute for a healthy diet. It's not going to be as good as having whole foods, avoiding processed foods, getting benefits like fiber, polyphenols, and phytochemicals from fruits and vegetables and whole grains. It's really important to have a healthful diet regardless.

GAZETTE: Why don't we speak briefly about two subgroups. For infants and children, is vitamin D is important?

MANSON: The American Academy of Pediatrics says to use vitamin D supplementation in a breastfed infant until weaning. This is because there's very little vitamin D in breast milk unless the mother has a very high intake of vitamin D. We want to encourage women to breastfeed, because there are so many advantages to the baby, but the vitamin D does need to be supplemented. Also, iron at 4-6 months.

GAZETTE: And for older adults, are there specific recommendations?

MANSON: Older adults often have a poorer diet. They may also have a problem with absorption of some vitamins and minerals. The main ones to think about are B12, calcium, and vitamin D. B12 deficiency can be a problem, especially with pernicious anemia. With calcium and vitamin D, we encourage food sources, but supplements may be necessary—some people are lactose-intolerant or don't eat dairy products. Avoid excess amounts of calcium supplements because they've been linked to an increased risk of kidney stones.

GAZETTE: For the calcium and vitamin D, are we talking about avoiding osteoporosis?

MANSON: It's mostly bone health for the calcium and vitamin D. That's been well established. But vitamin D has also been implicated in heart health, cognitive health, and reducing risk of cancer and diabetes. There's no definitive evidence yet. That's why we're doing the VITAL trial, and other trials of vitamin D are ongoing throughout the world.

Vitamin and mineral supplementation is a complicated subject. I hope we can make it a little clearer to the public because the messages have been so confusing. It's very difficult for the public to separate fact from fiction, and understand what is just hype and marketing and promotion as opposed to actual evidence and facts.

Explore further: Calcium supplements may boost risk of abnormal bowel growths

More information: JoAnn E. Manson et al. Vitamin and Mineral Supplements, JAMA (2018). DOI: 10.1001/jama.2017.21012

Related Stories

Calcium supplements may boost risk of abnormal bowel growths

March 2, 2018
Calcium supplements, taken with or without vitamin D, may increase the risk of small growths in the large bowel (colon) called polyps, suggest results from a large US trial published online in the journal Gut.

Calcium, vitamin D don't seem to reduce fracture risk in seniors

December 27, 2017
(HealthDay)—For community-dwelling older adults, supplementation with calcium, vitamin D, or both does not reduce the incidence of fractures, according to a review published in the Dec. 26 issue of the Journal of the American ...

Do you take calcium and vitamin D to protect your bones? A new study says it doesn't help

December 28, 2017
If taking more vitamin and mineral supplements is part of your plan for a healthier new year, a new study may prompt you to reconsider.

Insufficient evidence to guide recommendations on vitamin D in pregnancy

November 29, 2017
There is currently insufficient evidence to guide recommendations on the use of vitamin D supplements in pregnancy, conclude researchers in The BMJ today.

Multivitamin and mineral supplements for mums-to-be are needless expense

July 11, 2016
Multivitamin and mineral supplements, often promoted to pregnant women as a means of giving their child the best possible start in life, are unlikely to be needed by most mums- to-be and are an unnecessary expense, concludes ...

Multivitamins on the outs, but these supplements are in

October 26, 2016
Watch out multivitamins, here comes vitamin D, fish oil and probiotics.

Recommended for you

Eating breakfast burns more carbs during exercise and accelerates metabolism for next meal

August 15, 2018
Eating breakfast before exercise may "prime" the body to burn carbohydrates during exercise and more rapidly digest food after working out, University of Bath researchers have found.

Mixing energy drinks with alcohol could enhance the negative effects of binge drinking

August 14, 2018
A key ingredient of energy drinks could be exacerbating some of the negative effects of binge drinking according to a new study.

New study finds fake, low-quality medicines prevalent in the developing world

August 10, 2018
A new study from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill found that substandard and falsified medicines, including medicines to treat malaria, are a serious problem in much of the world. In low- and middle-income ...

Insurance status tied to higher self-perceived poor/fair health

August 9, 2018
(HealthDay)—Underinsured and never insured adults are more likely than adequately insured adults to report poor/fair health and frequent mental distress (FMD), according to a study published online July 19 in the U.S. Centers ...

Carbon dioxide levels on flight deck affect airline pilot performance

August 8, 2018
Commercial airline pilots were significantly better at performing advanced maneuvers in a flight simulator when carbon dioxide (CO2) levels on the flight deck (cockpit) were 700 parts per million (ppm) and 1500 ppm than when ...

Giving kids plates with segments and pictures caused them to eat more vegetables

August 8, 2018
A pair of researchers at the University of Colorado has found that preschool kids ate more vegetables when presented with segmented plates with pictures of fruits and vegetables on them. In their paper published in JAMA Pediatrics, ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.