Inquiry calls for moratorium on the use of genetics test results for life insurance

March 28, 2018, Monash University
Inquiry calls for moratorium on the use of genetics test results for life insurance
Credit: Monash University

Australian Life Insurers will no longer be able to use predictive genetic test results in underwriting, if recommendations tabled yesterday by a Parliamentary Inquiry into Life Insurance are adopted. The recommendations would bring Australia into line with much of the developed world, who have banned the practice, and are being welcomed by Monash Public Health and Preventive Medicine's Head of Genomics, Dr. Paul Lacaze.

Dr. Lacaze says, "This represents an important step forward for Australia. The ban, if implemented, will enable progress in healthcare and medical research by removing a significant 'black-cloud' over the Australian system. The benefits of genomics, of which there are many, can only be achieved if public trust and willingness to participate is maintained, not deterred by insurance fears. We applaud the Inquiry for its in-depth consideration of the issues and recommendations. The government now need to follow this with action to implement the proposed ban and a new regulatory regime."

Dr. Lacaze and colleague Ms Jane Tiller presented to the inquiry conducted by the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Corporations and Financial Services in May and December 2017, arguing that the current self-regulated use of by the industry has negative consequences for consumers and for research. The Inquiry's findings reflect concerns reported by the genetics community that some people forego potentially life-saving tests, or decide not to participate in involving genetic testing, because of fears of genetic discrimination by insurers.

Ms Tiller says, "We welcome the Inquiry's recommendation of an urgent moratorium, which will protect the rights of Australians seeking to proactively manage their genetic health risks, and of research participants who contribute so much to society. We strongly urge the Australian government to ensure implementation of the Inquiry's recommendations as a matter of urgency."

Those bearing the brunt of current practices include Australians at increased risk of cancers due to inherited genetic mutations, including breast and colon , as well as other genetic conditions. The recommendations make allowances for people willingly supplying genetic information to show they are not at risk; for example, a woman with a family history of breast cancer and whose family is known to harbour a BRCA mutation, who can show she does not carry the family mutation.

Some people with inherited cancer mutations can reduce their overall risk of cancer to that of the general population, via mitigating actions such as surgery or increased frequency of cancer surveillance. In a number of Australian cases brought to the Inquiry's attention, individuals who achieved this were still denied coverage.

The current practice is also a serious concern for Australian medical researchers, in this critical period of evidence generation for genomics. All genetic testing results, including research results, must be disclosed to life insurers by applicants, which has led to some people declining to participate in genetic research. The Inquiry's findings recognise the dangers this poses to the success of Australian genomics initiatives.

The Inquiry calls for the Financial Services Council to urgently update its code to prohibit the practice, and that until the Code is updated, a ban be implemented. It further recommends the government should monitor the FSC's implementation of these changes and implement legislation if life insurers fail to implement or abide by them.

Explore further: Balancing rights and responsibilities in insurers' access to genetic test results

Related Stories

Balancing rights and responsibilities in insurers' access to genetic test results

May 26, 2017
Genetic testing is widely used across the developed world in order to diagnose and predict disease. However, along with its usefulness comes concern about how others, such as employers and insurers, can have access to and ...

The implications of genetic testing

August 5, 2015
In the past decade major developments have been made in cancer genetics with the identification of inherited mutations, along with advances in cancer screening, surveillance and prevention. However with these advances come ...

Whole-population testing for breast and ovarian cancer gene mutations is cost effective

January 17, 2018
Screening the entire population for breast and ovarian cancer gene mutations, as opposed to just those at high-risk of carrying this mutation, is cost effective and could prevent more ovarian and breast cancers than the current ...

One in five young colon cancer patients have genetic link

December 13, 2017
As doctors grapple with increasing rates of colorectal cancers in young people, new research from the University of Michigan may offer some insight into how the disease developed and how to prevent further cancers. Researchers ...

Canada catches up with ban on genetic discrimination

May 3, 2016
Canadian lawmakers were a legislative step closer Tuesday to banning genetic discrimination including in the workplace or by health insurers.

Recommended for you

Researchers identify new genetic disorder

September 21, 2018
Researchers from Michigan State University College of Human Medicine and physicians from Spectrum Health have identified for the first time in a human patient a genetic disorder only previously described in animal models.

Test could detect patients at risk from lethal fungal spores

September 20, 2018
Scientists at The University of Manchester have discovered a genetic mutation in humans linked to a 17-fold increase in the amount of dangerous fungal spores in the lungs.

Researchers identify a new cause of childhood mitochondrial disease

September 20, 2018
A rapid genetic test developed by Newcastle researchers has identified the first patients with inherited mutations in a new disease gene.

Why some human genes are more popular with researchers than others

September 18, 2018
Historical bias is a key reason why biomedical researchers continue to study the same 10 percent of all human genes while ignoring many genes known to play roles in disease, according to a study publishing September 18 in ...

Class of neurological disorders share 3-D genome folding pattern, study finds

September 18, 2018
In a class of roughly 30 neurological disorders that includes ALS, Huntington's Disease and Fragile X Syndrome, the relevant mutant gene features sections of repeating base pair sequences known as short tandem repeats, or ...

Researchers resolve decades-old mystery about the most commonly mutated gene in cancer

September 18, 2018
The most commonly mutated gene in cancer has tantalized scientists for decades about the message of its mutations. Although mutations can occur at more than 1,100 sites within the TP53 gene, they arise with greatest frequency ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.