Why rates of mental illness aren't going down despite higher spending

June 28, 2018 by Graham Meadows, Joanne Enticott And Sebastian Rosenberg, The Conversation
Improving mental health depends on distributing money more fairly. Credit: shutterstock.com

Successive Australian governments have increased their spending on mental health over the last few decades, which is a good thing. But when the rate of mental illness isn't going down, we need to step back and ask why.

Our research shows there is unfairness in how Australia's care is delivered. Improving mental health will depend at least in part on fairer distribution. While this means increasing spending in regional and remote Australia, it also means getting more resources to poorer urban areas.

Higher spending, but no effects

Major funding streams into mental health care come from state and territory governments (60%), the Australian government (35%) and funds (5%). The rising blue line in the below graph represents this total dollar spend, which has been increasing. Today it is around A$150 more per person than in 1999-2000.

We might hope the proportion of the population with active mental health problems would be going down with the increase in spending. But the bottom red line shows this isn't the case. This line represents the rate of the population with higher levels of psychological distress, as quantified by the Kessler 10.

The Kessler 10 (K10) is a questionnaire answered by around 20,000 Australians in national surveys every three years. It asks about depressive and anxiety symptoms in the last 30 days. Your GP might have asked you to fill out this questionnaire if mental health has been discussed.

Credit: The Conversation

People with increased scores are likely to have clinical anxiety or depressive problems, so the rate of very high K10 (30 or more) is a useful measure of mental illness in the population.

The slug-like creep of an essentially flat (red) line shows that the percentage of Australians with very high K10 scores has stayed steady at a bit over 4% since 1999-2000.

Funding isn't getting to the right people

So why is increased spending not affecting the very high K10 rate? Perhaps it needs to reach some higher dollar threshold to make a difference. Maybe other cultural changes are pushing up the underlying rate, or money needs to be spent differently – perhaps more on, say, effective prevention.

However, we suggest a major reason is that the increased spending is not getting care to people in the areas that need it most.

Medicare data reveal something of how this is happening. The left axis of the second graph has a blue line showing the annual use for each 100 people of Medicare item 80010 – a session of about an hour with a clinical psychologist – over four years, across various regions. Once you leave the major urban areas, this rate just about falls off a cliff.

Credit: The Conversation

It's important to note the rate of very high K10 (represented by the red line) isn't appreciably higher outside the big cities. While there will be specific remote areas with higher rates, overall living in regional and remote Australia doesn't seem to mean you're more likely to have clinical anxiety or depression.

But, as the graph shows, you are much less likely to get to consult with a clinical psychologist to help you with the condition if you live in a regional or remote area.

Socioeconomic disadvantage

Another big problem is socioeconomic disadvantage. This is measured with the Index of Relative Socioeconomic Disadvantage (IRSD), which the next graph groups into five bands: from most deprived (poorest, left) to least (richest, right).

The left axis and blue line show how people living in deprived areas – and there's a lot of them, mostly in cities – are much less likely to be seeing clinical psychologists. On the right axis and the red line we see the rate of very high K10 scores getting higher with more disadvantage.

The X shape of the graph shows that, paradoxically, as the rate of disorders goes down in better-off areas, the rate of use of these goes up. Use of these services may be as much as nine times less proportionally to the number of people with in the worst-off areas, compared with people in the best-off fifth of the country.

Credit: The Conversation

For example, we find double the specialist services in Melbourne's City of Bayside (IRSD band five) compared to Dandenong (IRSD band one) or in North Sydney (IRSD band five) compared with Blacktown (low in IRSD band three).

There are similar disparities, though differing in degree, for other Medicare-supported specialist psychological treatment services provided by different disciplines. GP mental health services, it is worth saying, are delivered somewhat more evenly.

Continued funding growth for is needed and welcome. However, we suggest more be done to ensure care gets to where it is needed most. This will not be simple: delivery models, mental literacy, gap fees, funding and planning models all need urgent attention or reform.

This will require new levels of leadership and cooperation between governments, professional bodies and communities.

Explore further: Money can't buy happiness, but poverty harms mental health

Related Stories

Money can't buy happiness, but poverty harms mental health

April 27, 2018
People often say that money can't buy happiness; however a new collection of scientific studies published this week (Friday 27 April 2018) highlights how living in poverty can significantly harm people's mental health.

World-first research into injury rates among people released from prison

April 18, 2018
Centre for Mental Health Research Fellow Mr Jesse Young led a study that identified hospital records for 1307 people released from seven Queensland prisons from 1 August 2008 to 31 July 2010.

Self-rating mental health as 'good' predicts positive future mental health

April 2, 2018
Researchers have found that when a person rates their current mental health as 'positive' despite meeting criteria for a mental health problem such as depression, it can predict good mental health in the future, even without ...

The failure of the Medicare principle of universality

March 2, 2015
Monash University researchers have revealed for the first time clear and detailed evidence of the inequitable delivery of mental health care services for disadvantaged Australians.

Whistleblowers often suffer from severe psychological problems

February 19, 2018
Whistleblowers play a very important and indispensable role in society. However the effects of blowing the whistle on whistleblowers are dramatic, according to a new empirical study of Tilburg University. About 80% report ...

Gender minorities have greater mental illness, disability

March 6, 2018
(HealthDay)—Gender minority Medicare beneficiaries have larger disability and mental health burdens than the general Medicare population, according to a study published online March 4 in Health Affairs.

Recommended for you

MDMA makes people cooperative, but not gullible

November 19, 2018
New research from King's College London has found that MDMA, the main ingredient in ecstasy, causes people to cooperate better—but only with trustworthy people. In the first study to look in detail at how MDMA impacts cooperative ...

Exploring the genetic contribution to suicide risk

November 19, 2018
Researchers at University of Utah Health identified four gene changes that occur more frequently in people who died by suicide that may point to increased risk in vulnerable individuals.

'Boomeranging' back to a parents' home negatively affects young adults' mental health

November 19, 2018
The number of young adults living in their own household has dropped dramatically in the last decades in the United States for a number of economic and social reasons. In a study that will soon be published in the peer-reviewed ...

In-person, but not online, social contact may protect against psychiatric disorders

November 19, 2018
In-person social contact seems to offer some protection against depression and PTSD symptoms, but the same is not true of contact on Facebook, suggests a study by Veterans Affairs Portland Health Care System and Oregon Health ...

College students choose smartphones over food

November 16, 2018
University at Buffalo researchers have found that college students prefer food deprivation over smartphone deprivation, according to results from a paper in Addictive Behaviors.

Study finds mindfulness apps can improve mental health

November 15, 2018
A University of Otago study has found that using mindfulness meditation applications (apps) on phones is associated with improvements in people's mental health.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 29, 2018
a case study by http://realpsychicreadings.online/tarot-cards-meaning/eight-of-pentacles/ shows that a lot of issues with mental health come from not seeing a point in treating them as something important. a lot of people think that depression is not serious, and that sucks.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.