Voluntary admissions do not reduce coercion among psychiatric patients

June 4, 2018 by Marie Barse, ScienceNordic
Voluntary admissions do not reduce coercion among psychiatric patients
An empty bed at the Glostrop Psychiatric Centre in Denmark awaiting a patient to admit themselves. Credit: Marie Barse

Since 2013, severely ill psychiatric patients in Denmark have been able to decide when to admit themselves to hospital without having to first go to the emergency department for evaluation.

Now, scientists in Denmark have assessed whether or not the scheme works.

Pervious pilot studies have suggested that patient-controlled admissions, as they are called, reduced coercion—whereby patients are forcibly treated or committed.

But this does not seem to be the case, according to lead author Dr. Christoffer Torgaard Thomsen, consultant at the Psychiatric Center Glostrup, Denmark.

"Nothing suggests that it successfully reduces coercion," says Thomsen, who has conducted the largest study on patient-controlled admissions to date, together with Professor Merete Nordentoft and Michael Eriksen Benros, two of Denmark's leading experts in treating psychiatric diseases.

"If the goal of introducing patient-controlled admissions is to reduce coercion in psychiatry, then you probably need to do something else," says Thomsen.

The results are published in the scientific journal Acta Psychiatry.

Longer admissions than the control group

The study examined the use of coercion, medicine, incidences of suicide and self-harm, and the number of days spent in hospital, among two groups of patients.

One group of 422 had a contract where they could decide when to admit themselves to hospital. The of 2,110 patients were of a similar age, sex, diagnosis, and disease history.

They found that patient-controlled admissions did not decrease the incidences of coercion or the risk of suicide and self-harm. Patients responsible for admitting themselves to hospital took, on average, more medicine than the control group, and were admitted more often and for longer – almost one month more.

"The concept is sympathetic and recovery-orientated, but we don't have any evidence-based reason to recommend introducing the scheme," says Nordentoft, professor at the University of Copenhagen and head of the research group at Psychiatric Center Copenhagen.

A small Norwegian study from 2017 reached similar conclusions.

Professor Torleif Ruud from the department of Clinical Medicine at the University of Oslo calls the new study "the best study" on this topic, methodologically speaking.

"Previous studies were small and did not compare with a control group. It's an important study because it questions what we thought," says Ruud.

He studies patient-controlled hospital admissions and is familiar with the new study. Though he points out that this is a new field of research and further research is needed.

Scheme already implemented in Denmark

Patient-controlled admissions were found to be no more effective than normal treatment in terms of reducing coercion. So has the scheme been scrapped?

No. The capital region authorities decided to make the program permanent in 2016, after the trial period had ended. This was before they knew whether or not it had the desired effect.

Since then, the scheme has been expanded and all psychiatric centres in Denmark are now able to offer patient-controlled admissions.

And while patients are as likely to experience coercion during patient-controlled , there might still be some other positive effects that help their recovery, says Anne Lindhardt, chair of The Mental Health Foundation, Denmark.

"It's about much more than and medicine – it's about empowerment, better ethics, and better collaboration with patients," says Lindhardt.

A culture change in psychiatry

Both the Danish Psychiatric Association and the Better Psychiatry support group for relatives think that the patient controlled admission program has value.

"It's about creating a culture change in psychiatry, so we give more power to the users and focus on recovery," says Thorstein Theilgaard, general secretary at the Better Psychiatry support group for relatives.

According to Professor Ruud, a good next step would be to assess whether some groups in particular benefit from the scheme.

"For example, it could be interesting to look at the diagnosis groups. Are there groups of for whom it makes more sense to offer [the scheme] than others?" he says.

Explore further: Study on perceptions of coercion during admission to psychiatric hospitals

Related Stories

Study on perceptions of coercion during admission to psychiatric hospitals

August 10, 2015
New research on the perception of coercion during admission to Irish psychiatric hospitals has found that there is a significant difference in how service users and their caregivers perceive the admission process.

Hospitals often missing dementia despite prior diagnosis

April 24, 2018
Hospitals in the UK are increasingly likely to recognise that a patient has dementia after they've been admitted for a different reason, finds a new UCL-led study, but it is still only recognised in under two-thirds of people.

Patient navigators tied to shorter hospital stays

August 21, 2015
(HealthDay)—Use of patient navigators (PNs) as inpatient care facilitators shortens hospital length of stay, according to a study published online Aug. 10 in the Journal of Hospital Medicine.

Improving assessment of acute abdominal pain

October 6, 2017
Surgical admissions for people with abdominal pain to Wellington Hospital's department of general surgery have nearly doubled over the past decade, a University of Otago, Wellington (UOW) study has found.

Suicide re-attempt risk substantially reduced after a novel psychiatric intervention

March 1, 2016
Trial shows risk of suicide re-attempt substantially reduced after a novel psychiatric intervention

This GI test could help patients avoid a hospital stay

December 16, 2016
Symptoms of possible upper GI bleeding (UGIB) are a leading cause of hospital admissions through emergency departments. But according to a new study, use of capsule endoscopy can avoid many unnecessary hospital admissions ...

Recommended for you

Self-perception and reality seem to line-up when it comes to judging our own personality

December 14, 2018
When it comes to self-assessment, new U of T research suggests that maybe we do have a pretty good handle on our own personalities after all.

Levels of gene-expression-regulating enzyme altered in brains of people with schizophrenia

December 14, 2018
A study using a PET scan tracer developed at the Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) has identified, for the first time, epigenetic differences between the brains of individuals ...

Researchers discover abundant source for neuronal cells

December 13, 2018
USC researchers seeking a way to study genetic activity associated with psychiatric disorders have discovered an abundant source of human cells—the nose.

Video game players frequently exposed to graphic content may see world differently

December 13, 2018
People who frequently play violent video games are more immune to disturbing images than non-players, a UNSW-led study into the phenomenon of emotion-induced blindness has shown.

New genetic clues to early-onset form of dementia

December 13, 2018
Unlike the more common Alzheimer's disease, frontotemporal dementia tends to afflict young people. It accounts for an estimated 20 percent of all cases of early-onset dementia. Patients with the illness typically begin to ...

How teens deal with stress may affect their blood pressure, immune system

December 13, 2018
Most teens get stressed out by their families from time to time, but whether they bottle those emotions up or put a positive spin on things may affect certain processes in the body, including blood pressure and how immune ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.