Influential Leapfrog Group jumps in to rate 5,600 surgery centers

October 17, 2018 by Christina Jewett
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

The influential Leapfrog Group, which grades nearly 2,000 U.S. hospitals, is launching a national survey to evaluate the safety and quality of up to 5,600 surgery centers that perform millions of outpatient procedures every year.

The group now issues hospitals an overall letter grade and evaluates how hospitals handle myriad problems, from infections to collapsed lungs to dangerous blood clots—helping decide where to seek care.

The new effort will focus on staffing, surgical outcomes and patient experience in facilities that are performing increasingly complex procedures and seeing more aging patients. The grades will also cover surgery centers' closest competitor, hospital outpatient departments.

Leah Binder, Leapfrog Group's chief executive, said she wants to fill gaps in information about same-day surgery, which employers and have embraced for its lower costs.

Employers, she said, "don't have enough information on quality and safety of that care."

Binder said a recent Kaiser Health News/USA Today Network investigation highlighted the need for independent information about surgery centers. The investigation found that since 2013, more than 260 patients died after care at centers that lacked appropriate lifesaving equipment, operated on very fragile patients or sent people home before they fully recovered.

"Your reporting did highlight the real lack of information from the federal government and the need for us to have an independent means of reporting," Binder said. "People are going in for surgery, and our federal government doesn't think it's important to tell us how it's going. Maybe that was OK 30 years ago, but now it's not OK."

The news report was based on inspection reports, lawsuits and data from many states that tally patient deaths but which refuse to note where they occurred. Seventeen other states collect no data on deaths at all.

The new Leapfrog plan will start with a survey of 250 centers in 2019 and include up to 5,600 surgery centers in 2020. At that point, it will publish data on the outcomes of specific procedures, such as total knee replacements, across the hospital outpatient departments and surgery centers nationwide.

The Leapfrog Group is funded by employers and health plans that cover the of the half of Americans who get health benefits through their job, Binder said. The organization was founded to shed light on and safety to help consumers pick high-value providers. It plans to disseminate the new surveys through its 40 business group members that steer millions in health spending.

Bill Prentice, chief executive of the Ambulatory Surgery Center Association, an industry trade group, said he supports the move toward greater transparency. However, he said the work to determine the specific measures is still underway, and "the devil is in the details."

Ty Tippets, administrator of St. George Surgical Center in Utah, said he welcomes what Leapfrog is doing.

"Anytime (data) is gathered and provided in a transparent, easily accessed forum—it helps empower patients," said Tippets, who recently testified before Congress about transparency in health care.

The Leapfrog Group announcement comes as Medicare is reviewing the data it will collect to gauge the quality of surgery centers.

The agency previously asked each surgery center to report its emergency transfer rate, or how often a patient 65 or older was sent from a center to the hospital. Yet the agency only required the centers to send data for half or more of its Medicare patients.

In the current rule-making period, Medicare declared the resulting data of little value, given the minimal differences among centers' scores. The agency proposed dropping the measure, but has not yet finalized the proposal.

Going forward, Medicare has said it will use its own billing data to report the percent of surgery center patients who seek care at a hospital in the week after a procedure.

Medicare recently announced plans to shine more light on the performance of accreditors, which play a key role in granting or denying health facilities approvals to operate. A recent KHN investigation into accreditor performance in California—the only state where the private bodies' inspection reports are public—showed repeated lapses in oversight.

A Medicare spokesman said new reports will show how well accreditors fare when state health officials inspect the same facilities. In recent years, Medicare has found that accreditors overlooked the majority of problems that government officials uncovered.

In September, the White House Office of Management and Budget approved another agency's proposal to collect and report data about the "culture of safety" in surgery centers. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality will ask surgery staff about issues such as whether staff feel comfortable speaking up about patient care concerns.

The plan says summary data—not facility-by-facility data—on the survey's results will be reported publicly.

That effort would add to the overall information the public has about surgery centers, said Dr. Ashish Jha, a patient safety expert at Harvard's School of Public Health.

"Places that do badly on safety culture surveys tend to have worse outcomes," Jha said. "But you can't bank on it."

He said the most useful data for the public would cover actual events—such as deaths after surgery, admissions to the hospital or functional status and pain three months after .

"Those are the things that actually matter," he said.

Explore further: Increased use of ambulatory surgery centers for cataract surgery

Related Stories

Increased use of ambulatory surgery centers for cataract surgery

November 22, 2017
National data shows a major shift in eye surgeries from hospitals to less expensive ambulatory surgery centers where care may be delivered faster and closer to home for some patients.

Surgery at high-quality hospitals costs Medicare less than at low-quality hospitals

September 7, 2016
Patients who had major surgery at high-quality hospitals in the U.S. cost Medicare less than those who had surgery at low-quality hospitals according to a new study led by Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. The difference ...

Surgical price transparency tied to improved volume, revenue

August 6, 2018
(HealthDay)—Ambulatory surgery centers experience increases in patient volume, patient satisfaction, and revenue after adopting price transparency, according to a study published recently in The American Surgeon.

Medicare Center of Excellence Policy may limit minority access to weight-loss surgery

September 12, 2013
Safety measures intended to improve bariatric surgery outcomes may impede obese minorities' access to care. This is according to a new research letter published online in the September 12 issue of JAMA which compares rates ...

Outpatient urological surgery costs significantly less when performed in physician offices, ACCs

October 22, 2012
More and more outpatient surgical procedures are being done at nonhospital-based facilities such as freestanding ambulatory surgical centers and physician offices, instead of at hospital-based outpatient departments. A new ...

Probing problems with bariatric surgery: Reoperations, variation are common

May 23, 2017
Every year, nearly 200,000 Americans turn to surgeons for help with their obesity, seeking bariatric surgery to lose weight and prevent life-threatening health problems.

Recommended for you

Patients' experiences with misdiagnosis inform patient safety improvement efforts

November 6, 2018
Diagnostic errors affect an estimated 12 million U.S. adult outpatients annually; however, patients' experiences of these errors are underexplored. To gain insight into the patient perspective, researchers from Baylor College ...

Funder involved in all aspects of most industry-funded clinical trials

October 3, 2018
In most industry funded trials reported in high impact medical journals, all aspects of the trial involved the industry funder, finds a study published by The BMJ today.

Educating the next generation of medical professionals with machine learning is essential

September 27, 2018
Artificial intelligence (AI) driven by machine learning (ML) algorithms is a branch in the field of computer science that is rapidly gaining popularity within the healthcare sector. However, graduate medical education and ...

Here's one reason why US healthcare costs so much

September 11, 2018
There is substantial waste in U.S. healthcare, but little consensus on how to identify or combat it.

New study examines predictors of patient-reported experiences at dialysis facilities

September 11, 2018
For patients with end-stage renal disease, dialysis treatments are vital and often are payed for by Medicare. In 2012, Medicare implemented a Quality Incentive Program scoring system, and in 2016, patient-reported experiences ...

Burnout in doctors has shocking impact on care, review finds

September 5, 2018
Burnout in doctors has devastating consequences on the quality of care they deliver, according to a large-scale systematic review and meta-analysis.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.