Do price spikes on some generic drugs indicate problems in the market?

October 1, 2018, University of Southern California
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

A new USC study reports that sudden price spikes for some generic drugs—such as the recently reported increases of a decades-old generic heart medication and an antibiotic—are becoming more common.

The study from the USC Schaeffer Center for Health Policy & Economics, published in the October issue of Health Affairs, shows that the portion of that at least doubled in price year-over-year represents a small but growing share of the market: from 1 percent of all generic drugs in 2007 to 4.39 percent in 2013.

"In most cases, this reflects an emerging strategy by generic manufacturers to identify and enter therapeutic areas with limited competition and raise substantially," said Geoffrey Joyce, the study's lead author and Schaeffer Center director of health policy. Joyce is also an associate professor at the USC School of Pharmacy and chair of the school's pharmaceutical and health economics department.

For consumers, this can mean soaring costs to purchase some drugs that are life-savers, sparking public outrage and leading many to question whether the market—which has historically functioned well—is still working.

The generic drug market, which comprises about 90 percent of the prescriptions filled nationwide, has historically produced drug prices that typically decrease over time and tend to be lower than other countries.

Small share of drugs had big price hikes

The researchers measured annual price changes between 2007 and 2013 using data from Medicare Part D. They assessed both the distribution of annual price changes across all generic products as well as price changes for the top 20 generics that had dramatic increases.

In aggregate, prices for most generic drugs declined over the years analyzed. Yet the fraction of drugs with prices that at least doubled grew by more than 400 percent: from just 1 percent in 2007 to over 4.39 percent in 2013. And of the 20 most widely used generic drugs that at least doubled in price between 2010 and 2011, three had price changes of over 500 percent, including one drug with a price increase of 2,573 percent.

Characteristics of the drugs with large price increases were varied. In general, they are not commonly prescribed, they are used to treat a mix of both chronic and acute conditions and they were relatively low-cost generics before the price increase.

The authors assert that in a majority of cases, large price increases are due to a lack of competition within that class of drug rather than supply shortages. They found that once prices increased, they persisted for the next three to five years, which points to issues in market competition rather than supply shortages that would be resolved on a more compressed timeline.

"Generic drugs are by definition homogenous products so there isn't a lot of room in the industry for innovation or differentiation," Joyce said. "Buying competitors or going into a therapeutic class with no competitors probably makes good business sense in terms of increasing profits, but it points to weaknesses in the market overall that should be corrected by policy or regulatory oversight."

Patients' out-of-pocket spending increased minimally on drugs affected

The researchers also looked at how these price increases affected patient out-of-pocket spending. They found that patients' cost-sharing tended to be low and increased much more minimally than the price increases for the drug, even when the price hikes persisted for more than one year.

For example, the most widely used drug experiencing a large price increase was a steroid used to treat inflammation. Though the price increased by over 350 percent between 2010 and 2011, patient out-of-pocket spending increased just 3 percent in 2011 and 23 percent over a three-year period.

This does not mean patients were unaffected by the price hikes. While copayments increased only modestly, the researchers noted that insurers might respond to sustained price increases by raising premiums or excluding the drug from the formulary. Patients may also be affected if pharmacies decide to stop carrying some generic drugs if reimbursements do not readily adjust to higher acquisition costs.

Policy changes and oversight required to combat rising prices

Joyce and his colleagues pointed to a number of legislative and regulatory changes aimed at introducing more competition that should be considered by policymakers. The authors suggest that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) should more rigorously analyze mergers and takeovers by drug companies, and what these mergers mean for specific classes of drugs rather than the market overall.

Another approach would be to allow temporary importation from countries that follow safety standards comparable to the United States. This would be a short-term policy only for off-patent drugs until a new generic had been approved.

In addition, while the FTC oversees market competition issues, the researchers suggest the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) could take action to improve the generic . The researchers pointed to signs of positive change in this regard: The FDA has initiated new rules that require prioritized review, including action within eight months for drugs used to treat conditions in which there are no more than three approved products.

Explore further: As competition goes down, generic drug prices rise, study finds

Related Stories

As competition goes down, generic drug prices rise, study finds

July 3, 2017
If the cost of your generic prescription drug has risen, it may be due to a lack of competition among drug manufacturers, according to a University of Florida College of Pharmacy study.

FDA takes steps to boost generic competition, limit prices

June 27, 2017
The Food and Drug Administration is taking steps to boost the number of generic prescription drugs in an effort to make medicines more affordable and to prevent price gouging.

Generic options provide limited savings for expensive drugs

May 7, 2018
Generic drug options did not reduce prices paid for the cancer therapy imatinib (Gleevec), according to a Health Affairs study released today in its May issue.

Potential solutions to drug shortages and the lack of competition in generic medicines

August 9, 2018
Drug shortages and price hikes have become a critical issue in the health care industry. A recent example of this occurred when a shortage of intravenous fluids and injectable opioids ensued due to manufacturing delays in ...

Drug prices increased twice as quickly than expected during shortage

September 18, 2018
Prices for drugs under shortage between 2015 and 2016 increased more than twice as quickly as they were expected to in the absence of a shortage. While researchers could not assess reasons for the increases, manufacturers ...

Savings less than expected for generic oral chemotherapy

September 11, 2017
A study by researchers at the University of North Carolina Eshelman School of Pharmacy and Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center determined the cost savings for a generic version of an orally administered cancer treatment ...

Recommended for you

Shortcut strategy for screening compounds with clinical potentials for drug development

December 4, 2018
Developing a new drug often takes years and costs hundreds of millions of dollars. A shortcut has now been reported in a study led by City University of Hong Kong (CityU), which can potentially reduce the time and costs of ...

Drug wholesalers drove fentanyl's deadly rise, report concludes

December 4, 2018
Fentanyl, a powerful synthetic opioid implicated in nearly 29,000 overdose deaths in the United States last year, most likely spread because of heroin and prescription pill shortages, and also because it was cheaper for drug ...

Global review reports on administration of children's antibiotics

December 4, 2018
Researchers analyzing the sales of oral antibiotics for children in 70 high- and middle-income countries found that consumption varies widely from country to country with little correlation between countries' wealth and the ...

Opioid prescriptions from dentists linked to youth addiction risk

December 3, 2018
Teens and young adults who receive their initial opioid prescriptions from their dentists or oral surgeons are at increased risk for opioid addiction in the following year, a study from the Stanford University School of Medicine ...

Rise in meth and opioid use during pregnancy

November 29, 2018
Amphetamine and opioid use in pregnancy increased substantially over the last decade in the United States, a new Michigan Medicine-led study finds. And a disproportionate rise occurred in rural counties.

Mouse model aids study of immunomodulation

November 19, 2018
Because mice do not respond to immunomodulatory drugs (IMiDs), preclinical therapeutic and safety studies of the effects of IMiDs have not been possible in existing types of mice. This has led to an inability to accurately ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.