Iowa court: Medicaid can cover sex reassignment surgery

Iowa court: Medicaid can cover sex reassignment surgery
This undated photo provided by ACLU of Iowa shows Carol Ann Beal. The Iowa Supreme Court on Friday, March 8, 2019 upheld a judge's earlier ruling that found the state cannot deny two transgender women Medicaid coverage for sex reassignment surgery. The ruling comes in the consolidated cases of Beal, 43, and EerieAnna Good, 29,both were born male but have identified as female since childhood and applied to have surgery to their medical providers under the state's Medicaid program. They were denied by the providers, appealed to the state agency, which oversees the program, and were again denied. (ACLU of Iowa via AP)

The Iowa Supreme Court on Friday upheld a lower court's ruling that the state cannot deny two transgender women Medicaid coverage for sex reassignment surgery.

The state's high court agreed with Judge Arthur Gamble's ruling in June that a 1995 Iowa Department of Human Services policy denying Medicaid coverage for sex reassignment violates the state's 2007 Civil Rights Act, which added gender identity to the state's list of protected classes.

Gamble also deemed state's 1995 policy unconstitutional, but the high court did not address that finding.

Friday's ruling comes in the consolidated cases of 43-year-old Carol Ann Beal, who lives in northwestern Iowa, and 29-year-old EerieAnna Good, who lives in the east of the state. Both were born male but have identified as female since childhood. They sought to have surgery under the state's Medicaid program, which provides care for the poor and disabled, but were denied. They appealed to the state agency, which oversees the program, and were again denied.

They sued in 2017, and the agency appealed following Gamble's ruling.

In its appeal, the agency argued, among other things, that its policy wasn't discriminatory because neither transgender nor non-transgender Medicaid beneficiaries would be entitled to gender-reassignment surgery, which it said is performed "primarily for psychological purposes." It also argued the policy's explicit exclusion of gender-reassignment surgeries was merely a specified example within the broader category of "cosmetic, reconstructive, and plastic surgeries" that were excluded from coverage.

The state Supreme Court said Friday that the record doesn't support that assertion.

Iowa court: Medicaid can cover sex reassignment surgery
This undated photo provided by ACLU of Iowa shows EerieAnna Good. The Iowa Supreme Court on Friday, March 8, 2019 upheld a judge's earlier ruling that found the state cannot deny two transgender women Medicaid coverage for sex reassignment surgery. The ruling comes in the consolidated cases of 29 and Carol Ann Beal, 43, both were born male but have identified as female since childhood and applied to have surgery to their medical providers under the state's Medicaid program. They were denied by the providers, appealed to the state agency, which oversees the program, and were again denied. (ACLU of Iowa via AP)
"The (department) expressly denied Good and Beal coverage for their surgical procedures because they were 'related to transsexualism ... (or) disorders' and 'for the purpose of sex reassignment,'" Justice Susan Christensen wrote, citing segments of the policy.

Moreover, she wrote, the policy authorizes payment for some cosmetic, reconstructive and plastic surgeries that serve psychological purposes, such as to correct disfiguring and extensive scarring and congenital anomalies, but "it prohibits coverage for this same procedure if (it's) a transgender individual."

Iowa Department of Human Services spokesman Matt Highland said the agency would not comment on the ruling.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Iowa, which filed the lawsuit on the behalf of Beal and Good, called Friday's ruling "a landmark win."

"Denying health care coverage to someone because they are transgender is wrong and extremely harmful to those who need this care," said John Knight of the ACLU's LGBT & HIV Project.

Beal and Good also expressed elation over the ruling, with Beal saying she's "extremely happy for those people who will come after me, that we've made a path for them so that they can get the and surgery they need."

Good said the decision has been a long time coming.

"So many people still don't understand that this is not something we need for trivial or cosmetic reasons," she said. "It's medical care a doctor is recommending for someone who has a medical need for it. And it can save lives. Transgender people are at such risk for suicide, and I've lost friends to suicide. I hope this decision helps change that."


Explore further

AMA joins brief seeking VA coverage of sex reassignment Sx

© 2019 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

Citation: Iowa court: Medicaid can cover sex reassignment surgery (2019, March 8) retrieved 19 June 2019 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2019-03-iowa-court-medicaid-sex-reassignment.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 09, 2019
The fact is, "transgendewrism" is the result of massive mental instability.
All the sex deviances have clinical qualities of mental disorder, such as depression lasting longer than a year and extreme anxiety disorder; they have self loathing large than other groups; that comes from the fact that they engage in sexual practices that even they find foul, but they have no control to keep themselves from engaging in them; this leads them to use drugs at higher rates than other groups; and an inability to live with it leads them to have rates of suicide higher than any other groups.
If someone had a mental; problem that led them to "body dysmorphic syndrome" so, for example, they wanted to cut their legs off, would Medicaid be called on to pay for that? If someone had mental problems leading them to say they couldn't live unless they had constant dosing with cocaine, heroin, meth, would Medicaid pay for that?

Mar 10, 2019
Well, this is just CRAP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Medicaid will cover this BS but when I had cancer they turned me away because I didn't have the "right kind of breast cancer". Oh, I'm sorry I didn't know there was a RIGHT kind of stage 3 breast cancer to DIE FROM!?! But please spend my hard EARNED money (yes I have to work while I die of cancer because no one will help a 37-year-old white female there are no programs) on giving them the proper gender, I would hate for them to walk around all butt hurt and stuff.... :(

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more