This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:


peer-reviewed publication

trusted source


New economic model finds fracture liaison services are highly effective

New economic model finds Fracture Liaison Services are highly effective
The bars in the figure indicate the excess total cost (ie, health and social care costs as well as those required for fracture liaison service [FLS] operation) in local currency of FLSs above the total cost under current practice per year. The orange line tracks the number of additional quality-adjusted lifeyears (QALY) gained by implementing FLSs (ie, above those expected to be achieved without them) per year. Credit: Journal of Bone and Mineral Research (2023). DOI: 10.1002/jbmr.4775

New research reveals that widespread fracture liaison service (FLS) implementation would benefit patient outcomes, manifested in a significant reduction in subsequent fragility fractures and gains in quality of life, while at the same time reducing hospital bed days, surgeries, need for institutional social care, and their associated costs.

With populations aging, the burden of fragility fractures on healthcare systems around the world is on the rise, resulting in a spiral of increased patient disability, loss of independence, and early mortality within the older population. Given that patients with a fragility fracture are at substantially high risk of subsequent fractures, effective secondary fracture prevention is of critical importance.

In this regard, FLS have been shown to be an optimal way to systematically identify, assess, treat, and monitor patients who have recently sustained a fragility fracture, and they have been proven to reduce the risk of subsequent fractures in numerous studies and reviews.

Associate Professor Kassim Javaid, Lecturer in Metabolic Bone Disease and Honorary Consultant Rheumatologist, NDORMS, University of Oxford, UK, co-author of the study, stated:

"Although FLSs are highly effective in reducing the risk of subsequent fragility fractures and improving , the majority of healthcare settings that manage adult fracture patients do not have an FLS in place. In the European Union for example, 50% of countries reported FLS coverage in less than 10% of hospitals. We know that a major barrier to sustainable effective FLS implementation is a lack of national, regional, and local policy prioritization and reimbursement."

"This new model makes visible both the invisible costs of fragility fracture and the expected net benefits from systematic FLS provision to patients and their families, clinicians, healthcare systems, and wider society. The flexibility of the model allows its implementation across different types of healthcare systems and populations and provides clear outputs tailored to a wide audience, giving critical information based on their local data to appropriately prioritize local implementation of FLS for patient benefit."

The microsimulation model estimates the impact of FLSs compared to for men and women 50 years of age or older with a fragility fracture. It provides estimates for that include subsequent fractures avoided and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs), as well as resource use, and health and social care costs, including those necessary for FLSs to operate, over five years.

Based on an exemplar country the size of the United Kingdom, FLSs were estimated to lead to a reduction of 13,149 subsequent fractures and a gain of 11,709 QALYs over the first five years of FLS implementation. Hospital bed days would be reduced by 120,989 and surgeries by 6,455, while 3,556 person-years of institutional social care would be avoided. Expected costs per QALY gained placed FLSs as highly cost-effective at £8,258 per QALY gained over the first five years alone.

Associate Professor Rafael Pinedo-Villanueva, Senior Health Economist, NDORMS, University of Oxford, first author of the study, explains:

"With healthcare budgets being limited and increased pressures on healthcare providers, policy makers need to make informed decisions based not only on necessary investments but also on expected benefit to patients, impact on healthcare resource use, and cost impacts before they can prioritize secondary fracture prevention in relation to other health priorities."

"This model acts as a calculator for all these relevant outcomes and can be run for any country or region. When run with values for a country the size of the United Kingdom, it shows that the initial investment in FLS implementation, where extra costs are concentrated in the first year, is worthwhile. The costs then drop significantly thereafter as we see gains in QALYs over time as more and more fractures are avoided."

"Further work to develop country-specific models is currently underway, and we expect that this will deliver crucial national-level data that can then be used to inform policy makers at the country level."

The development of the model was carried out by experts from the University of Oxford and supported by the International Osteoporosis Foundation (IOF) Capture the Fracture initiative, a program which works to drive the implementation and sustainability of FLS worldwide, and which offers best-practice guidance and recognition to more than 800 FLS in all regions of the world.

Professor Cyrus Cooper, IOF President and co-author, concluded, "This important model, essentially an 'FLS cost and benefit' calculator, provides significant evidence that secondary fracture prevention through FLS service provision is highly cost effective, with significant benefits for patients, their families, the healthcare system, and society as a whole."

The study is published in the Journal of Bone and Mineral Research.

More information: Rafael Pinedo‐Villanueva et al, Expected Benefits and Budget Impact From a Microsimulation Model Support the Prioritization and Implementation of Fracture Liaison Services, Journal of Bone and Mineral Research (2023). DOI: 10.1002/jbmr.4775

Citation: New economic model finds fracture liaison services are highly effective (2023, February 8) retrieved 31 May 2023 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Report: More than 1.1 million Spanish women at high risk of fracture remain untreated for osteoporosis


Feedback to editors