3 popular supplements fall short in preventing prostate cancer: study

May 6, 2011 by Deborah Braconnier in Cancer report

(PhysOrg.com) -- For some time it has been believed that vitamin E, selenium and soy were natural ways to prevent prostate cancer. However, a new study published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology shows that these supplements do not provide any additional benefit when it comes to prostate cancer prevention.

Dr. Neil Fleshner, head of the urology department at the University Health Network in Toronto led the study on 303 men. All the men chosen for the study were at high risk for prostate cancer as they already showed pre-cancerous cells.

The researchers randomly chose men to receive the supplements while the others received a . These men were required to take these supplements every day for three years. The supplements contained a combination of 40g of soy, 800U of , and 0.2 milligrams .

After three years, the results of both groups came back the same. Within each group, 26 of every 100 developed prostate cancer. These results are similar to a study that was done in 2008 on vitamin E and selenium, where no benefit was found.

Researchers had hoped that the addition of soy in this study would show promise. In countries like China and Japan, where soy is eaten in large amounts, the rates of prostate cancer are much lower than those in the United States and Canada. Fleshner says that this does not rule out the benefits of a soy based diet for decades, but that three years of soy was not enough to show a change.

With 156 out of 10,000 men developing each year, Fleshner believes that this study provides enough proof that continued research into the benefits of these supplements should be abandoned and research funds turned to other possible ideas.

More information: Progression From High-Grade Prostatic Intraepithelial Neoplasia to Cancer: A Randomized Trial of Combination Vitamin-E, Soy, and Selenium, Journal of Clinical Oncology Published online before print May 2, 2011, doi:10.1200/JCO.2010.32.0994

Abstract
Purpose High-grade prostatic intraepithelial neoplasia (HGPIN) is a putative precursor of invasive prostate cancer (PCa). Preclinical evidence suggests vitamin E, selenium, and soy protein may prevent progression of HGPIN to PCa. This hypothesis was tested in a randomized phase III double-blind study of daily soy (40 g), vitamin E (800 U), and selenium (200 μg) versus placebo.
Patients and Methods Three hundred three men in 12 Canadian centers were analyzed. The main eligibility criterion was confirmed HGPIN in at least one of two biopsies within 18 months of random assignment. Treatment was administered daily for 3 years. Follow-up prostate biopsies occurred at 6, 12, 24, and 36 months postrandomization. The primary end point was time to development of invasive PCa. Kaplan-Meier plots and log-rank tests were used to compare two treatment groups for this end point.
Results For all patients, the median age was 62.8 years. The median baseline prostate-specific antigen (PSA; n = 302) was 5.41 ug/L; total testosterone (n = 291) was 13.4 nmol/L. Invasive PCa developed among 26.4% of patients. The hazard ratio for the nutritional supplement to prevent PCa was 1.03 (95% CI, 0.67 to 1.60; P = .88). Gleason score distribution was similar in both groups with 83.5% of cancers graded Gleason sum of 6. Baseline age, weight, PSA, and testosterone did not predict for development of PCa. The supplement was well tolerated with flatulence reported more frequently (27% v 17%) among men receiving micronutrients.
Conclusion This trial does not support the hypothesis that combination vitamin E, selenium, and soy prevents progression from HGPIN to PCa.

© 2010 PhysOrg.com

3 /5 (2 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

Mauricio
May 06, 2011

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
the title of this unbiased paper should be "vitamin E, selenium and soy fall short in preventing prostate cancer". Otherwise you people should use general labels to report all research. For example, "pharmaceuticals failed to stop infections" because three pharmaceuticals drugs failed containing a disease....
dutchman
May 10, 2011

Rank: not rated yet

I think vitamin D would have a better chance. It has been shown to prevent several other types of cancer, in various studies, performed at University of California Medical Centers, as well as those of other universities.
Rank 3 /5 (2 votes)
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • A question about drug tolerance
    created13 hours ago
  • Poor nutrition leading to overeating?
    createdMay 23, 2012
  • Math and dyslexia?
    createdMay 21, 2012
  • portable metabolism meter?
    createdMay 21, 2012
  • Rare medical conditions on 20/20 tonight
    createdMay 18, 2012
  • "Good" Cholesterol in Doubt
    createdMay 17, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - Medical Sciences

More news stories

Study links mental health problems to poor prognosis in male cancer patients

Men suffering from psychiatric problems when diagnosed with cancer are more likely to die from the disease, according to a new study part-funded by the Wellcome Trust. The findings also reveal that those with ...

Cancer created 4 minutes ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Cancer docs often deal with own grief, doubts when patients die

(HealthDay) -- Some cancer doctors may build up emotional walls -- distancing themselves from the patients they can't save -- to avoid grief, sadness and even despair, new research shows.

Cancer created 18 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Regorafenib active in metastatic GI stromal tumors

(HealthDay) -- Regorafenib, an inhibitor of multiple cancer-associated kinases, is active in patients with metastatic gastrointestinal stromal tumors (GIST) who have failed to respond to imatinib and sunitinib, ...

Cancer created 18 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Robotic-assisted prostate cancer surgery drives up costs

In one of the most comprehensive analyses to date of the cost of robotic-assisted, laparoscopic surgery for prostate cancer, researchers at UPMC found that this now-dominant surgical approach is significantly more costly ...

Cancer created 20 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Cardio fitness levels of breast cancer patients may affect survival

Women receiving care for breast cancer have significantly impaired cardio-pulmonary function that can persist for years after they have completed treatment, according to a study led by scientists at Duke University Medical ...

Cancer created 20 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0 | with audio podcast


Research team uncovers mechanism behind drugs that cause altered immunity

(Medical Xpress) -- An Australian research team has opened the door to understanding why certain drugs cause a so called altered immunity response when offered as treatment for certain specific ailments. In their paper published ...

Long-term meditation leads to different brain organization

(Medical Xpress) -- People who practice mindfulness meditation learn to accept their feelings, emotions, and states of mind without judging or resisting them. They simply live in the moment.

The auditory cortex adapts agilely with concentration

The birth of sensory perception on the human cerebral cortex is yet to be fully explained. The different areas on the cortex function in cooperation, and no perception is the outcome of only one area working alone. In his ...

No new neurons in the human olfactory bulb

(Medical Xpress) -- Research from Karolinska Institutet shows that the human olfactory bulb - a structure in the brain that processes sensory input from the nose - differs from that of other mammals in that no new neurons ...

New genetic method pinpoints geographic origin

(Medical Xpress) -- Understanding the genetic diversity within and between populations has important implications for studies of human disease and evolution. This includes identifying associations between genetic variants ...

Spatial configuration can spark deja vu, psychology study reveals

(Medical Xpress) -- Déjà vu - that strange feeling of having experienced something before - is more likely to occur when a scene's spatial layout resembles one in memory, according to groundbreaking new research ...