Major shortfalls in medical best practice: Australian study

July 16, 2012

(Medical Xpress) -- Australians receive “appropriate” health care in only 57 per cent of consultations, according the first ever national snapshot of the quality of clinical care in Australia.

The landmark CareTrack study, published in today’s Medical Journal of Australia (MJA), found that although there were pockets of excellence in Australian delivery there were also shortfalls in treatment for some common conditions and disparities in the standards of care provided by different medical practices.

Research teams from the University of New South Wales and the University of South Australia spent two years tracking levels of “appropriate care” – that is care in line with best practice based on the latest medical evidence – in a representative sample of the Australian population.

For some conditions, such as coronary artery disease, patients received very high levels of appropriate care but there was poor compliance with appropriate care standards in some others areas, such as responding to very high blood pressure, administering prophylactic antibiotics at the correct time before surgery, and treating sinusitis.

Discrepancies between healthcare providers were also significant, with some offering best practice care in 86% of encounters and some in only 32% of encounters. The study focused on 22 common conditions responsible for over 40 per cent of the total national disease burden.

With health budgets under growing pressure from the ageing population and costly chronic diseases, the study provides a road map for more efficient and cost-effective care delivery.

“Healthcare is likely to become unaffordable unless more appropriate care is provided,” said one of the study’s Chief Investigators, Professor Jeffrey Braithwaite of the University of New South Wales.

“To plan for a sustainable healthcare system into the future, it’s important to maximise the rate at which patients receive appropriate care so we can address the gaps in care that have been identified.”

The study identified a number of barriers to providing appropriate care into the future. Plans to overcome these limitations include a Wiki-type process to develop national clinical standards and tools to guide treatment, and to document whether care is appropriate.

The proposed up-to-date, simple standards can be embedded as tools in both patient and healthcare provider-held medical records, paving the way for automatic electronic monitoring and feedback. “Seventeen years after the landmark Quality in Australian Health Care Study, our research provides an opportunity to establish a healthcare baseline from which to move forward, and has identified some gaps in care which should be addressed,” says lead researcher at the University of South Australia, Professor Bill Runciman.

This is the second study of its kind to be conducted in the world. The first, conducted in the United States 10 years ago, found 55% of US healthcare encounters provided appropriate care.

CareTrack Australia assessed the appropriateness of the healthcare received by 1,150 in 2009/10 in 35,573 healthcare encounters for conditions ranging from coronary heart disease and low back pain, through to stroke, asthma and depression.

Among the study’s key findings were:

  • Appropriate care was provided in 57% of healthcare encounters in Australia
  • Nearly 90% of patients with sinusitis were prescribed antibiotics, care known to be ineffective
  • 18% of patients with asthma had a documented action plan for when they had an attack.
  • Less than 30% of patients over 50 had a documented bowel cancer screening test.
  • 73% of 50 to 69 year old women had a mammogram every two years
  • Almost 90% of people over 18 years old had two yearly blood pressure checks
The $2 million CareTrack research project was undertaken as one part of an $8.4 million National Health and Medical Research Council program grant, Patient safety; enabling and supporting change for a safer more effective health system, awarded in 2009.

Explore further: Ongoing relationship with care provider key for patients with a chronic condition: study

Related Stories

At the edge of a cliff, health care must evolve quickly

February 10, 2012

To reverse America’s unsustainable health-care costs, Congress must adopt more refined, nimble strategies and get tough in the face of those pushing to keep the status quo, according to Dr. Donald M. Berwick, a leader ...

Coordinating cancer care remains a challenge

July 13, 2012

People with cancer often receive fragmented and uncoordinated care, as their treatments frequently require help from multiple clinicians. However, a new review by The Cochrane Library finds no evidence that three main strategies ...

From pen to paper to better healthcare

April 11, 2012

A digital pen equipped with a small camera that can automatically transfer patient information to a computer database will radically improve the way hospital staff care for their patients.

Recommended for you

Faster is better when it comes to sepsis care

May 22, 2017

Following the tragic and widely publicized death of Rory Staunton, 12, from undiagnosed sepsis in 2012, New York became the first state to require that hospitals follow a protocol to quickly identify and treat the condition.

Moderate drinking may not ward off heart disease

May 22, 2017

Many people believe that having a glass of wine with dinner—or moderately drinking any kind of alcohol—will protect them from heart disease. But a hard look at the evidence finds little support for that.

Which countries have the best healthcare?

May 19, 2017

Neither Canada nor Japan cracked the top 10, and the United States finished a dismal 35th, according to a much anticipated ranking of healthcare quality in 195 countries, released Friday.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.