Limiting the problem of missing data urged for clinical trials

October 4, 2012
Limiting the problem of missing data urged for clinical trials
Missing data compromise inferences from clinical trials, and due to the problematic nature of compensation with analysis methods, the importance of avoiding missing data in clinical trials is paramount, according to a special report published in the Oct. 4 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

(HealthDay)—Data missing from clinical trials can undermine the credibility of those trials, and little attention has been focused on this issue until recently, experts say.

Even regulatory guidelines that direct how clinical trials should be run offer little advice on dealing with missing information, according to a new report from an expert panel commissioned by the National Research Council.

And, while statisticians may be able to control for the missing data, they can end up making "assumptions about what the outcomes would've been, and when you're doing a phase 3 clinical trial [that could lead to a drug's regulatory approval or denial], people don't want to make assumptions. They want to assure balance, which argues for trying to limit the amount of missing data," said the panel chairman, Rod Little, a biostatistics professor at the University of Michigan School of Public Health in Ann Arbor.

Another panel member, Kay Dickersin, who directs the Center for Clinical Trials and the U.S. Cochrane Center at the John's Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health in Baltimore, agreed. "When data are missing from clinical trials, the findings become questionable or of no use. Why are the data missing? Is it because the people with data missing all got better? All got worse? We don't know why the data are missing, and so we cannot even guesstimate what the true findings of the study would be would be if no data were missing," Dickersin said.
"The main point is that it is far better to prevent missing data than to try to 'fix' the problem in the analysis," she added.

Findings from the panel are published as a special report in the Oct. 4 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

In May, a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association also took clinical trials to task, finding that many are small and of poor quality. That study found that cancer treatment trials often failed to follow the highest standards.

To address the potential problems stemming from missing data in clinical trials, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration requested that the National Research Council convene an expert panel in 2008. The current report focuses primarily on phase 3 clinical trials assessing the safety and efficacy of drugs, biologic products and some medical devices.

Missing data was defined by the panel as information that would have been meaningful to the results of the trial.

The panel found that a major cause of missing data is participants who stop taking their assigned treatment because it's not working, the side effects are troubling or the drug regimen is too inconvenient.

But the panel suggested that researchers should continue to gather follow-up information on them anyway.

"People have the right to discontinue any treatment, but often people don't follow-up. The panel is making the point that in a lot of situations, it's useful to get that information," said Little.

Dickersin said another issue is missing data even when follow-up visits were kept. "Sometimes patients may attend their follow-up visits, but not answer all the questions they were asked. So if, for example, some people in a study about pain fail to fill in their diaries about daily pain, then we may not know that pain relief is only for a short time with the test drug when long-term pain relief is what patients are seeking," she said.

The panelists outlined a number of steps that could be taken to limit the amount of missing data in clinical trials. They include:

  • Conducting a brief run-in period in which all participants are assigned an active drug to see who can tolerate it.
  • Allowing the use of rescue medications as part of the treatment regimen, so these drugs are accounted for in the analysis.
  • Targeting a group that doesn't have enough current treatment options, because they have more incentive to stay in the trial.
  • Shortening the follow-up period.
The panel also recommended changes in the statistical analysis of missing data at the end of the study. Little said some of the current methods used may be too simplistic.

The bottom line, he said, is that "we want to make the best possible decisions about which drugs are effective and safe."

Dickersin added, "Study participants are making an incredibly important contribution to current and future health care by participating in clinical trials. They can contribute to the impact of the findings by ensuring that they follow the protocol as asked.
"And, even when they have to change treatments or stop the treatment to which they were assigned—say, because of side effects—they still can help the study's success by returning for visits and completing all study forms and questionnaires," she added.

Explore further: Missing trial data threatens the integrity of medicine

More information: Full Text (subscription or payment may be required)

Related Stories

Missing trial data threatens the integrity of medicine

January 4, 2012
Missing clinical trial data can harm patients and lead to futile costs to health systems, warn experts in the British Medical Journal today as part of an in-depth BMJ review of the matter.

Clinical trials need to better protect participants and research integrity as data accumulate

June 12, 2012
An Essay by Susan Ellenberg from the University of Pennsylvania describes alternative approaches to the evaluation of clinical trials, with the objectives both of preventing undue risks to participants and protecting the ...

UK experts: Missing drug info could hurt patients

January 4, 2012
(AP) -- A British medical journal says a worrying number of drug studies are being suppressed by researchers and that the lack of public data could threaten patient safety.

Clinical study of epilepsy drug may have been purely promotional

June 27, 2011
Yale School of Medicine researchers have found that a clinical trial of the epilepsy drug gabapentin may have been a "seeding trial" used by a pharmaceutical company to promote the drug and increase prescriptions, according ...

FBI launches phone app to help find missing children

August 5, 2011
The FBI joined the booming mobile phone app market on Friday with the launch of a tool to help parents find missing kids.

Recommended for you

Post-stroke patients reach terra firma with new exosuit technology

July 26, 2017
Upright walking on two legs is a defining trait in humans, enabling them to move very efficiently throughout their environment. This can all change in the blink of an eye when a stroke occurs. In about 80% of patients post-stroke, ...

Molecular hitchhiker on human protein signals tumors to self-destruct

July 24, 2017
Powerful molecules can hitch rides on a plentiful human protein and signal tumors to self-destruct, a team of Vanderbilt University engineers found.

Researchers develop new method to generate human antibodies

July 24, 2017
An international team of scientists has developed a method to rapidly produce specific human antibodies in the laboratory. The technique, which will be described in a paper to be published July 24 in The Journal of Experimental ...

New vaccine production could improve flu shot accuracy

July 24, 2017
A new way of producing the seasonal flu vaccine could speed up the process and provide better protection against infection.

A sodium surprise: Engineers find unexpected result during cardiac research

July 20, 2017
Irregular heartbeat—or arrhythmia—can have sudden and often fatal consequences. A biomedical engineering team at Washington University in St. Louis examining molecular behavior in cardiac tissue recently made a surprising ...

Want to win at sports? Take a cue from these mighty mice

July 20, 2017
As student athletes hit training fields this summer to gain the competitive edge, a new study shows how the experiences of a tiny mouse can put them on the path to winning.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.