'Fuzzy thinking' in depression and bipolar disorder: New research finds effect is real

May 4, 2015, University of Michigan Health System
White matter fiber architecture of the brain. Credit: Human Connectome Project.

People with depression or bipolar disorder often feel their thinking ability has gotten "fuzzy", or less sharp than before their symptoms began. Now, researchers have shown in a very large study that effect is indeed real - and rooted in brain activity differences that show up on advanced brain scans.

What's more, the results add to the mounting evidence that these conditions both fall on a spectrum of , rather than being completely unrelated. That could transform the way doctors and patients think about, diagnose and treat them.

In a new paper in the journal Brain, researchers from the University of Michigan Medical School and Depression Center and their colleagues report the results of tests they gave to 612 - more than two-thirds of whom had experienced either major depression or bipolar disorder. The researchers also present data from detailed brain scans of 52 of the women, who took tests while brain scans were conducted.

The number of patients involved is large for this kind of study - which makes the findings more meaningful. The researchers pooled data from several U-M studies, including the Prechter Longitudinal Study of Bipolar Disorder. They focused on results from women to take gender differences out of the mix.

Seen as groups, women with depression or bipolar disorder did equally badly on the test, which required sustained concentration. The test asked them to react rapidly when certain letters flashed briefly on a screen, amid a random sequence of other letters. Compared with the group with no , the groups with either diagnosis lagged noticeably on this standard test of cognitive control.

And while many individual women with depression or bipolar scored as well on the test as healthy participants, nearly all the test-takers in the bottom 5 percent of performers had one of the two mood disorders.

On the brain scans, the researchers found that the women with depression or bipolar disorder had different levels of activity than healthy women in a particular area of the brain called the right posterior parietal cortex. In those with depression, the activity in this area was higher than in healthy individuals, while in those with bipolar disorder it was lower. The area where the differences were seen helps control "executive function"—activities such as working memory, problem solving and reasoning.

"In all, we show a shared cognitive dysfunction in women with mood disorders, which were pronounced in the cognitive control tests and more nuanced in scans," says Kelly Ryan, Ph.D., a U-M neuropsychologist and lead author of the study.

"These findings support the idea of seeing mood disorders dimensionally, as a continuum of function to dysfunction across illnesses that are more alike than distinct," adds Ryan, who sees patients as a clinical assistant professor in the U-M Department of Psychiatry. "Traditionally in psychiatry we look at a specific diagnosis, or category. But the neurobiology is not categorical—we're not finding huge differences between what clinicians see as categories of disease. This raises questions about traditional diagnoses."

Ryan and her colleagues note that this view of mood disorders is growing in favor, and even the National Institute of Mental Health has put it forth as an area of research focus under the name Research Domain Criteria. But they do not suggest that mental health clinicians should use the test or given to the study participants to spot risks for or diagnose a mood disorder.

Under RDoC, NIMH is working with researchers to develop new ways of classifying , independent of the clinical diagnostic codes found in the guidebook that clinicians use, called the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.

Senior author Scott Langenecker, Ph.D., formerly at U-M and now at the University of Illinois, Chicago, adds, "The RDoC initiative is not meant to replace this clinical diagnostic system. It is designed to extend ways of understanding neurobiology, performance, and genetics at natures' seams, rather than at groupings of clinical symptoms based on a patient's current memory of recent symptoms and clinician observations of signs. The RDoC initiative is a recognition that we need to rely more heavily on what these neurobiological results are telling us - mental diseases have more overlap in the basic brain and genetic signatures."

The researchers hope that their findings will help other researchers, who could use these tests as a way to divide participants up for further study - an "intermediate phenotype" for mood disorders.

For example, researchers could focus on studying people with and without classical mood disorders by first giving them the test, and then using the expensive brain-scanning option only on those with poor performance. This could influence strategies future clinical screening, diagnosis and treatment.

More about the study

The research involved 150 healthy women, 266 women with that was either active or inactive at the time of testing, and 202 women with who were not in a manic state when tested.

All participants took a test that measures the ability to sustain attention and respond quickly - to focus one's brain, in essence. Then, 17 of the healthy women, 19 of the depressed women and 16 of the bipolar women took the same test again while inside the scanner at U-M's Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging laboratory. Ryan notes that because of the expense of such scans and limits on finding participants, the fMRI group is still too small to make strong conclusions. She hopes others will be able to carry out further imaging studies of this issue.

Explore further: Borderline personality disorder as debilitating as bipolar disorder

More information: Brain, May 2015, DOI: dx.doi.org/10.1093/brain/awv070 brain.oxfordjournals.org/conte … /138/5/1424.full.pdf (free online access)

Related Stories

Borderline personality disorder as debilitating as bipolar disorder

April 23, 2015
The deterioration of psychiatric and physical health caused by borderline personality disorder (BPD) rivals that of bipolar disorder, according to Mark Zimmerman, M.D., a researcher at Rhode Island Hospital. His research ...

Brain scans reveal differences in depression and bipolar disorder, study finds

August 22, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—Brain scans measuring blood flow can help diagnose bipolar disorder at an early stage and distinguish the condition from depression, according to a study conducted by a University of Pittsburgh research ...

Study explores bipolar in postpartum period

November 8, 2013
Researchers have long connected mood disorders and pregnancy. But a study coming out of Western is boiling down some of the specifics, suggesting women who suffered from depression prior to pregnancy should be monitored for ...

Study offers clues to early detection of bipolar disorders in high-risk children

March 3, 2015
New research published today in the American Journal of Psychiatry indicates a strong link between subthreshold manic episodes and likelihood of developing bipolar disorder in children of parents with bipolar disorder. The ...

Women who experience postpartum depression before giving birth may face greater risk

January 15, 2015
When it comes to postpartum depression, one size does not fit all, according to a new study led by University of North Carolina School of Medicine researchers.

Is left-handedness higher among those suffering from psychosis?

October 30, 2013
Researchers have long studied the connections between hand dominance and different aspects of the human brain. A new study out today in SAGE Open finds that among those with mental illnesses, left-handers are more likely ...

Recommended for you

Trying to get people to agree? Skip the French restaurant and go out for Chinese food

December 11, 2018
Here's a new negotiating tactic: enjoy a family-style meal with your counterpart before making your opening bid.

What social stress in monkeys can tell us about human health

December 11, 2018
Research in recent years has linked a person's physical or social environment to their well-being. Stress wears down the body and compromises the immune system, leaving a person more vulnerable to illnesses and other conditions. ...

The richer the reward, the faster you'll likely move to reach it, study shows

December 11, 2018
If you are wondering how long you personally are willing to stand in line to buy that hot new holiday gift, scientists at Johns Hopkins Medicine say the answer may be found in the biological rules governing how animals typically ...

Receiving genetic information can change risk

December 11, 2018
Millions of people in the United States alone have submitted their DNA for analysis and received information that not only predicts their risk for disease but, it turns out, in some cases might also have influenced that risk, ...

Using neurofeedback to prevent PTSD in soldiers

December 11, 2018
A team of researchers from Israel, the U.S. and the U.K. has found that using neurofeedback could prevent soldiers from experiencing PTSD after engaging in emotionally difficult situations. In their paper published in the ...

You make decisions quicker and based on less information than you think

December 11, 2018
We live in an age of information. In theory, we can learn everything about anyone or anything at the touch of a button. All this information should allow us to make super-informed, data-driven decisions all the time.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) May 05, 2015
I agree, I could have told them that, and lots more, but it would be anecdotal evidence. Meaning you can't just take someone's word for it without some sort of backup. The brain scans establish a basis in fact for faulting mental wiring, and better still, they offer a hint toward the direction of research they need to pursue in the future. This isn't a useless study to see if water is wet, or I would be the 2nd snark right out the door behind you. ;)
3 / 5 (2) May 05, 2015
I suffered terribly with anxiety and depression since I was 13 and have blogged a bit about it here http://controlyou...et.com/1 I lost my best years. It was only last year I finally got a hold on my issues.....I was 49.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.