Safety concerns over new female sterilization device

October 13, 2015, British Medical Journal

Women who undergo implant based female sterilization have a significantly heightened risk of reoperation following complications, suggests a large study published in The BMJ this week.

Female sterilization is one of the most common contraception methods worldwide. Laparoscopic sterilization has been the primary method for decades. It is a surgical procedure that clips, stitches or burns the to prevent pregnancy.

Hysteroscopic sterilization was developed more recently and involves implanting the "Essure" to block the fallopian tubes. It does not require general anaesthetic or surgery unlike laparoscopic sterilization.

The "Essure" device received approval in Europe in 2001 and was approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 2002. Since its approval, thousands of concerns have been received by the FDA, and device failure became a subject of litigation in 2014.

So a team of researchers carried out the first study to compare the performance, safety and other outcomes of these two widely used forms of female sterilization.

They analysed data from 8,048 women who underwent hysteroscopic sterilization, and 44,278 who underwent laparoscopic sterilization in outpatient settings between 2005 and 2013 in the New York State.

They looked at complications within 30 days of the initial sterilization procedure, and investigated unintended pregnancies and reoperation up to three years after the initial sterilization procedure.

Hysteroscopic sterilization was associated with over 10-fold higher risk of reoperation, equivalent to around 21 additional reoperations per 1,000 patients undergoing surgery. The authors warn that this is a "serious safety concern."

Women were eight times more likely to undergo a reoperation at two years and six times more likely at three years following the initial sterilization procedure.

Women who underwent hysteroscopic sterilization were more likely to be older (more than 40 years), have a history of and cesarean section. Nevertheless, the higher risk of reoperation persisted in the various age groups and women with history of pelvic inflammatory disease.

The risk of unintended pregnancy was comparable in the "Essure' and laparoscopic sterilization groups, and the overall chance of unintended pregnancy was found to be approximately one in 100 after use of the "Essure" device; higher than reported in previous studies.

The authors also found that the use of laparoscopic sterilization decreased from 7,852 cases in 2005 to 3517 cases in 2013. Meanwhile, the use of hysteroscopic sterilization significantly increased from 45 cases in 2005 to 1,231 cases in 2013.

"With an estimated 600,000 sterilization procedures performed in the US every year, the device based hysteroscopic has a major public health impact" write the authors. They conclude that the "benefits and risks of both procedures should be discussed with patients for informed decisions making."

This was an observational study which means that some unmeasured factors may have influenced the relationship between use of the "Essure" device and the increased risk of reoperation.

Explore further: Pregnancy risk may be higher with newer method of female sterilization

More information: Safety and efficacy of hysteroscopic sterilization compared with laparoscopic sterilization: an observational cohort study, The BMJ, www.bmj.com/cgi/doi/10.1136/bmj.h5162

Related Stories

Pregnancy risk may be higher with newer method of female sterilization

April 22, 2014
(Medical Xpress)—Women who used a new method of sterilization called hysteroscopic sterilization had a 10 times greater risk of pregnancy after one year than those who used the older laparoscopic sterilization method. This ...

FDA petitioned to stop sales of essure implant

May 5, 2015
(HealthDay)—Bayer's contraceptive implant Essure can cause serious complications and should be taken off the market, says a citizen's petition filed with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

Tubouterine implantation can undo hysteroscopic sterilization

November 13, 2014
(HealthDay)—Tubouterine implantation is feasible for hysteroscopic sterilization reversal and results in promising rates of pregnancy and live birth, according to a study published online Nov. 5 in Obstetrics & Gynecology.

More data sought on birth control device Essure

October 13, 2015
Drastic as it may sound, sterilization is the second-most-popular birth control method among U.S. women, and more than 10 million have opted for it.

Officials: Bad drugs likely killed 13 Indian women

November 15, 2014
Tainted drugs apparently killed 13 women who underwent sterilization procedures in central India after autopsies ruled out any surgery faults, officials said Saturday.

Revised Medicaid policy could reduce unintended pregnancies, save millions in health costs

September 12, 2013
A revised Medicaid sterilization policy that removes logistical barriers, including a mandatory 30-day waiting period, could potentially honor women's reproductive decisions, reduce the number of unintended pregnancies and ...

Recommended for you

Male depression may lower pregnancy chances among infertile couples, study suggests

May 17, 2018
Among couples being treated for infertility, depression in the male partner was linked to lower pregnancy chances, while depression in the female partner was not found to influence the rate of live birth, according to a study ...

Fertility study finds acupuncture ineffective for IVF birth rates

May 15, 2018
A study of over 800 Australian and New Zealand women undergoing acupuncture treatment during their IVF (in vitro fertilization) cycle has confirmed no significant difference in live birth rates. The findings published today ...

More than one day of first-trimester bleeding ups odds for smaller baby

May 10, 2018
(HealthDay)—Some first-trimester bleeding occurs in up to 1 in every 4 pregnancies. Now, new research suggests that if bleeding extends beyond a day there could be implications for baby's birth weight.

For women with history of pregnancy loss, walking may aid chance of becoming pregnant

May 8, 2018
Results of a recent study to better understand modifiable factors such as physical activity that may affect a woman's ability to conceive a child suggest that walking may help women to improve their chances of becoming pregnant.

Women who eat fast food take longer to become pregnant

May 3, 2018
Women who eat less fruit and more fast food take longer to get pregnant and are less likely to conceive within a year, according to a study by researchers at the University of Adelaide's Robinson Research Institute.

Review finds more effective drugs to stop bleeding after childbirth

April 26, 2018
New evidence from a Cochrane review published today, led by a University of Birmingham scientist, suggests that alternative drugs may be more effective than the standard drug currently used to stop women bleeding after childbirth.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.