Childhood leukemias forged by different evolutionary forces than in older adults

January 11, 2016
A Wright's stained bone marrow aspirate smear from a patient with precursor B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Credit: VashiDonsk/Wikipedia

For half a century, cancer researchers have struggled with a confusing paradox: If cancer is caused by the occurrence and accumulation of cancer-causing (oncogenic) mutations over time, young children should get less cancer as they have fewer mutations. Why then do young children have a higher incidence of leukemia than teenagers and young adults?

A University of Colorado Cancer Center paper published today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences proposes a solution. Using a computational model describing the population dynamics of that give rise to leukemias, Drs. Andrii Rozhok, Jennifer Salstrom and James DeGregori provide evidence that the evolutionary force of contributes to the ability of cancerous to overtake populations of healthy cells in . In contrast, genetic drift contributes almost not at all to leukemia formation in adults.

"Basically, leukemia risk early in life may be more dictated by chance than by the typical 'survival of the fittest' that characterizes leukemia formation in ," says James DeGregori, PhD, associate director for basic research at CU Cancer Center and the paper's senior author.

In previous work, the DeGregori lab has shown that the inevitable tissue declines associated with aging benefit blood stem cells (HSCs) with mutations that allow them to better adapt to the new ecosystem. (Very similar to how organisms have adapted to changes in earth's climate and landscape over time.) In contrast, the ecosystem of young tissue favors healthy cells - optimized by millions of years of co-evolution, most mutations make cells less fit for the ecosystem of young, healthy tissue and lead to purging of mutant cells from the tissue.

However, Rozhok and colleagues made a surprising discovery: Despite the ability of young tissue to select against cells with cancer-causing mutations, the computational model showed increased proportions of specific, mutation-bearing HSCs in the first few years after birth. Strikingly, they showed that these populations of mutated cells were not dependent on the effect of the mutation on cell fitness - these mutation-bearing cells were not more fit than healthy cells without these mutations. Instead of the survival-of-the-fittest form of natural selection that drives the evolution of cancer in older adults, there was another force at work.

In fact, they discovered two factors that influence the development of early-life leukemia: the small HSC pool size at birth and the high rate of cell division necessary for body growth early in life.

It's easy to understand how more cell divisions early in life create greater risk; mutations largely happen during cell divisions, so more cell divisions will mean more mutations. This in turn increases the risk that some of these mutations could contribute to leukemia development.

But what about the small HSC pool size? Thus far, we've talked about two evolutionary forces: mutation and selection. But there is a third factor, often overlooked, that is critical in evolution. It is drift. Drift is the role of chance - the possibility that despite being less fit, an animal, organism or blood stem cell with cancer-causing mutation will survive to shift the genetic makeup of the population.

Importantly, the influence of drift is greater in small populations.

"Imagine if you flip a coin 10 times. You would not be surprised if 7 or more out of 10 flips gave you heads (in fact, the odds are about 1 in 6). But if you flipped the same coin 1,000 times, the odds of getting 700 or greater heads would be much smaller (less than 1 in a million)," DeGregori says. "Basically, the more trials we do, the less chance plays a role."

The same is true in stem cell pools. In small stem cell pools, such as for HSC pools very early in life, drift (chance) becomes much more important as a lucky genotype may end up with a larger share of the total HSC pool than warranted by its fitness status. If this lucky cell clone happens to have a mutation that can start the HSC down the path towards being leukemic, then this drift-driven expansion should increase the risk of leukemia by increasing the number of HSCs with this mutation.

"Thus, early somatic evolution in HSC pools is significantly impacted by drift, with selection playing a lesser role," the paper writes.

Now consider the impact of drift as the HSC pool grows along with an infant's body to reach adult size. Just as more coin flips decrease the role of chance, so does the larger HSC pool size decrease the role of drift in the success of particular cells in the tissue. In addition, as the pool size reaches its maximum, the HSC division rate slows to a crawl (as these stem cells enter the maintenance rather than growth phase). With a landscape of healthy, youthful tissues and low rates of mutation due to low cell division rates, the odds of leukemia diminish.

"With a large population of optimized to young, healthy tissue, the ability of mutations, including cancerous mutations, to drive uncontrolled cell proliferation is reduced," DeGregori says.

However, we did not evolve to live forever. The model shows that in old age, tissue decline promotes selection for adaptive mutations, leading to the expansion of potentially oncogenic HSC clones that will again increase the risk of leukemia. Thus this paper shows that in early life, leukemias are driven by mutation and drift whereas in later life, leukemias are driven by mutation and selection.

"We show that leukemias of children and older adults are different diseases, forged by different evolutionary forces, and propagated under different circumstances," DeGregori says.

Importantly, this understanding raises the possibility of a new approach to cancer treatment: Could we manipulate the parameters of evolution for cells within our bodies? Could we manipulate the tissue ecosystem to decrease cancer risk? Considering our bodies as ecosystems that select against or allow the development of cancer offers a new avenue for combatting the disease.

Explore further: Mutations need help from aging tissue to cause leukemia

More information: Stochastic modeling reveals an evolutionary mechanism underlying elevated rates of childhood leukemia, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,

Related Stories

Mutations need help from aging tissue to cause leukemia

December 18, 2014
Why are older people at higher risk for developing cancer? Prevailing opinion holds that, over time, your body's cells accumulate DNA damage and that eventually this damage catches up with the body in a way that causes cancer. ...

Natural selection and inflammation may hold key to age-associated cancer risk

November 11, 2015
The incidence of cancer increases with age. Conventional wisdom blames this on age-dependent accumulation of cancer-causing mutations. A University of Colorado Cancer Center study published in the Journal of Clinical Investigation ...

Evolution not just mutation drives development of cancer

July 21, 2015
A paper published today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences argues against the commonly held "accumulation of mutations" model of oncogenesis in favor of a model that depends on evolutionary pressures acting ...

Reprogramming stem cells may prevent cancer after radiation

December 29, 2014
The body has evolved ways to get rid of faulty stem cells. A University of Colorado Cancer Center study published today in the journal Stem Cells shows that one of these ways is a "program" that makes stem cells damaged by ...

Why cancer rate increases with age (it's not what you think)

July 2, 2012
Cancers are age-related, much more frequent in the old than in the young. A University of Colorado Cancer Center review published today in the journal Oncogene argues against the conventional wisdom that the accumulation ...

Identified an 'alarm clock' of a leukemia-causing oncogene

October 8, 2015
In the last thirty years it has been described in the field of oncology a large number of mutations in genes involved in multiple cellular pathways. The current ability to sequence all the genetic material of a tumor implies ...

Recommended for you

How a non-coding RNA encourages cancer growth and metastasis

August 21, 2017
A mechanism that pushes a certain gene to produce a non-coding form of RNA instead of its protein-coding alternative can promote the growth of cancer, report researchers at the Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) ...

Spaser can detect, kill circulating tumor cells to prevent cancer metastases, study finds

August 21, 2017
A nanolaser known as the spaser can serve as a super-bright, water-soluble, biocompatible probe capable of finding metastasized cancer cells in the blood stream and then killing these cells, according to a new research study.

Comprehensive genomic analysis offers insights into causes of Wilms tumor development

August 21, 2017
A comprehensive genomic analysis of Wilms tumor - the most common kidney cancer in children - found genetic mutations involving a large number of genes that fall into two major categories. These categories involve cellular ...

Comparison of screening recommendations indicates annual mammography

August 21, 2017
When to initiate screening for breast cancer, how often to screen, and how long to screen are questions that continue to spark emotional debates. A new study compares the number of deaths that might be prevented as a result ...

Vitamin C may encourage blood cancer stem cells to die

August 17, 2017
Vitamin C may "tell" faulty stem cells in the bone marrow to mature and die normally, instead of multiplying to cause blood cancers. This is the finding of a study led by researchers from Perlmutter Cancer Center at NYU Langone ...

Outdoor light at night linked with increased breast cancer risk in women

August 17, 2017
Women who live in areas with higher levels of outdoor light at night may be at higher risk for breast cancer than those living in areas with lower levels, according to a large long-term study from Harvard T.H. Chan School ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.