97 percent of insurance denials in pediatric proton patients overturned on appeal

August 7, 2017, Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania
A treatment room in the Roberts Proton Therapy Center. Credit: Penn Medicine

Insurance companies end up covering proton therapy treatment for pediatric cancer patients in 97 percent of the cases they originally deny once those decisions are appealed. Researchers from the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania analyzed five years of coverage decisions at Penn's Roberts Proton Therapy Center. They discovered that roughly one in 10 pediatric cancer patients are initially denied coverage for the cutting edge and costly treatment - yet nearly all patients ultimately get approval. They published their findings in Pediatric Blood & Cancer today.

Proton therapy has a few key differences from traditional radiation, but the main advantage is that the radiation beam itself stops when it hits its target as opposed to going all the way through the patient's body. This means it can focus on attacking the tumor while sparing healthy tissue - something that's especially important in pediatric patients, since radiation can impact development of the brain, spine, and other areas.

"Most oncologists agree it's a better choice than traditional radiation in pediatric cases because it's so targeted," said the study's co-author Eric Ojerholm, MD, an instructor in Radiation Oncology at Penn. "However, since we don't have data from with these patients, we don't have the conclusive evidence that normally like to see before universally approving coverage."

While that lack of trial data has led to unfavorable language in many insurance policies, Ojerholm said this study shows it does not seem to be stopping insurance companies from covering proton treatment in .

The Penn team looked at five years of insurance coverage data for pediatric proton cases in the Roberts Proton Therapy Center spanning from 2010 to 2015. Of the 287 cases they evaluated, 255 (89 percent) were approved outright while 32 (11 percent) were initially denied. Following appeals, 31 of 32 initially denied cases (97 percent) were overturned and approved. "This shows that insurers are ultimately willing to accept the benefits of proton therapy for young cancer patients, however a great deal of time and resources are still wasted in appeals of coverage denials and ultimate approvals," said the study's co-author Christine Hill-Kayser, MD, an assistant professor of Radiation Oncology at Penn.

The researchers discovered two factors most associated with initial denial: age and tumor type. Some patients over age 18 develop a cancer that doctors consider pediatric because of how the tumor typically behaves. Examples include neuroblastoma, rhabdomyosarcoma, germinoma, and Ewing sarcoma. Even though someone with these diseases may be over 18 years old, doctors would typically treat the the same way they'd treat a pediatric patient. Yet patients in this group were initially denied four times as often as those 18 or younger.

The second theme that emerged was that cancers located outside the brain or spine were denied 4.5 times more frequently.

"This is probably because the strongest evidence for pediatric therapy is in brain and spine tumors," Ojerholm said. "Insurers appear willing to accept these cases but may initially be more hesitant for other disease sites."

Despite the high rate of success on appeal, researchers say the process itself can be problematic. The average appeal took about a week. It involved letters, peer-to-peer phone calls, or in some cases, both. In 28 percent of cases, it took multiple rounds of appeal before coverage was finally approved.

"These appeals mean time and resources for patients, doctors, and insurers," Hill-Kayser said. "If the ultimate outcome is overwhelmingly going to be approval anyway, we believe there should be a way to streamline this process."

The researchers suggest changing the language of insurance policies to recognize the distinction of pediatric tumors. They also propose classifying patients between the ages of 19 and 30 who have these pediatric cancers as pediatric cases, which would eliminate one of the common causes of denial.

The researchers did note potential limitations of the study, including that all data came from a single hospital. A different center in a different part of the country would have its own unique mix of insurance carriers and plans, which may produce a different result. Further, Penn has an advisory board that evaluates patients for and only recommends those most likely to benefit from the treatment. If another center skips that step, they may see more denials or less reversal on appeal.

Explore further: Proton therapy offers new, precise cancer treatment for children with high-risk neuroblastoma

More information: Eric Ojerholm et al, Insurance coverage decisions for pediatric proton therapy, Pediatric Blood & Cancer (2017). DOI: 10.1002/pbc.26729

Related Stories

Proton therapy offers new, precise cancer treatment for children with high-risk neuroblastoma

August 13, 2013
Proton therapy, using high-energy subatomic particles, may offer a precise, organ-sparing treatment option for children with high-risk forms of neuroblastoma. For patients in a new study of advanced radiation treatment, proton ...

Proton therapy cuts side effects for pediatric head and neck cancer patients

September 24, 2013
The precise targeting and limited dosing of radiation via proton therapy is proving to be an advantage in ongoing efforts to reduce treatment side effects among head and neck cancer patients, according to a new study of pediatric ...

New survey shows 36-percent increase in pediatric patients treated with proton therapy

May 24, 2015
Results from a new nationwide survey announced today indicate a steady increase in the number of pediatric patients who are being treated with proton radiation therapy for cancerous and non-cancerous tumors.

Breakthrough technology offers new treatment for patients with hard-to-reach tumors

May 4, 2016
An enormous high tech machine is providing new hope to patients across the country with inoperable tumors. Proton therapy is a precise radiation technique that reduces the side effects often accompanied by traditional treatment ...

Image guided radiation therapy is commonly used to ensure accuracy in treating pediatric tumors

October 17, 2014
Image guided radiation therapy (IGRT) is a commonly used modality to ensure treatment accuracy in the management of pediatric tumors; however, consensus recommendations are needed in order to guide clinical decisions on the ...

Proton imaging provides more accuracy, less radiation to pediatric cancer patients

April 29, 2011
Proton radiography imaging used prior to and during proton treatments for pediatric cancer patients provides for more accurate treatment delivery and a lower dose of radiation compared to standard diagnostic X-rays and cone ...

Recommended for you

Lung cancer drug could be repurposed to target 'zombie' proteins linked to leukemia

September 25, 2018
A new study by scientists at the University of Liverpool highlights how a clinically-approved lung cancer drug could potentially be 'repurposed' to design new treatments for future cancer therapies.

A protein called vaccinia-related kinase 1 may help cancer establish itself in new areas of the body during metastasis

September 25, 2018
Sometimes negative results can point researchers in the right direction.

Combo therapy of prostatectomy plus radiotherapy may improve survival in prostate cancer

September 25, 2018
High-risk prostate cancer, that which has continued to grow but not yet metastasized, is commonly treated with combination therapies. Each method has pros and cons, but there is little clarity whether one might be more effective ...

Brigatinib becomes potential new first-line option for ALK-positive non-small lung cancer

September 25, 2018
Results of a 275-patient, multi-national phase III clinical trial known as ALTA-1L published today in the New England Journal of Medicine and presented concurrently in the press program at the International Association for ...

Two studies describe improved approach to bone marrow transplant

September 25, 2018
Two recent studies in the journal Leukemia present a new approach for bone marrow donation and transplant that preclinical laboratory tests suggest could make the life-saving procedure safer and more effective for patients.

Unhealthy lifestyle responsible for 45,000 predicted cases of bowel cancer in next decade

September 25, 2018
A UNSW study shows that a large proportion of bowel cancers in Australia are preventable by adopting a healthy lifestyle – particularly for men.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.