Researchers discover an important clue to help predict disease

March 7, 2018 by Kelly Johnston, University of Calgary
Researchers discover an important clue to help predict disease
Cumming School of Medicine researchers Benedikt Hallgrimsson and Rebecca Green examine the relationship between gene mutations (genotype) and how they present in people (phenotype) to help better predict disease. Credit: Pauline Zulueta, Cumming School of Medicine

The more information you have, the better able you are to predict what will happen next. Clinicians and health researchers often look at gene mutation to predict whether a fetus is at risk for a birth defect, or a person is at risk of developing a disease, but these predictions are not always accurate. University of Calgary researchers have discovered an important factor that changes our understanding of the relationship between gene mutations (genotype) and how they present in people (phenotype) that may, one day, help to improve this accuracy.

"The significance of this work is that it helps us understand how two individuals can have the same genetic mutation, but one can have a disease and the other one can be just fine," says Rebecca Green, Ph.D., a postdoctoral fellow in the Benedikt Hallgrimsson lab and first author of the study. "It happens commonly in and palate; two kids will have the exact same mutation, but one will be born with cleft and one won't."

To better understand why, the researchers looked closely at levels. It has long been thought that changes in gene expression result in proportional changes in traits determined by those genes. Much of the variation in traits such as facial shape, height or blood pressure is determined by differences in levels of gene expression.

Using mouse embryos, they created a series of mutations to gradually decrease the expression level of a gene called Fgf8, which is important for proper development of the face. They started at 100 per cent and reduced it to 20 per cent of the typical level. Then they mapped the relationship between the two and found the relationship isn't proportional, there isn't a constant ratio, the relationship is non-linear.

"Our results showed even at 50 per cent of the normal level of gene expression you can be totally fine, but as it decreases further it doesn't mean the defect increases—you have a lot of different outcomes: from totally typical to essentially almost not even having a face," says Hallgrimsson, Ph.D., head of the Department of Cell Biology and Anatomy at the Cumming School of Medicine (CSM). "Those are the kinds of effects that result from a non-linear genotype/phenotype map. If you don't know what those maps look like you can't predict the phenotype from the genome."

The results are published in Nature Communications.

"This is a critical piece of understanding that's relevant to predicting disease from genotypes," says Hallgrimsson. "It adds to our knowledge of how genes can interact with each other and gives us one more answer for how variable outcomes can arise."

Hallgrimsson suspects if researchers looked at most really important genes they would have similar, highly non-linear genotype/phenotype map.

"The science of predicting phenotypes from is not as advanced as is commonly thought," says Hallgrimsson. "The prediction tools we've been using need to take non-linearity into account to refine and improve algorithms for using genomic data to predict variation. Those kinds of improvements will be critical for predicting disease risk."

This work also has significance for evolutionary biology. All organisms carry some amount of genetic variation. In order for a species to survive, it must be able to tolerate some amount of and still develop and reproduce successfully. This study suggests that non-linearities in development are a major cause of this phenomenon.

Explore further: Gene expression patterns may help determine time of death

More information: Rebecca M. Green et al. Developmental nonlinearity drives phenotypic robustness, Nature Communications (2017). DOI: 10.1038/s41467-017-02037-7

Related Stories

Gene expression patterns may help determine time of death

February 13, 2018
International team of scientists led by Roderic Guigó at the Centre for Genomic Regulation in Barcelona showed that changes in gene expression in different tissues triggered by death can be used to predict the time of death ...

New computational method predicts genes likely to be causal in disease

August 10, 2015
A new computational method developed by scientists from the University of Chicago improves the detection of genes that are likely to be causal for complex diseases and biological traits. The method, PrediXcan, estimates gene ...

RefEx, a web tool for a comfortable search of reference data for gene expression analysis

November 3, 2017
Currently, there are many public databases available to everyone in the field of life science, but there are many problems when you try to use them, namely you do not know which to use, how to use and even where to find a ...

Recommended for you

New methods find undiagnosed genetic diseases in electronic health records

March 15, 2018
Patients diagnosed with heart failure, stroke, infertility and kidney failure could actually be suffering from rare and undiagnosed genetic diseases.

Hundreds of genes linked to intelligence in global study

March 14, 2018
More than 500 genes linked to intelligence have been identified in the largest study of its kind. Scientists compared variation in DNA in more than 240,000 people from around the world, to discover which genes are associated ...

Study finds that genes play a role in empathy

March 12, 2018
A new study published today suggests that how empathic we are is not just a result of our upbringing and experience but also partly a result of our genes.

Large-scale genetic study provides new insight into the causes of stroke

March 12, 2018
An international research consortium studying 520,000 individuals from around the world has identified 22 new genetic risk factors for stroke, thus tripling the number of gene regions known to affect stroke risk. The results ...

Study suggests some CpGs in the genome can be hemimethylated by design

March 9, 2018
A pair of researchers at Emory University has found that some CpGs in the genome can be hemimethylated by design, rather than by chance. In their paper published in the journal Science, Chenhuan Xu and Victor Corces describe ...

Intravenous arginine benefits children after acute metabolic strokes

March 9, 2018
Children with mitochondrial diseases who suffered acute metabolic strokes benefited from rapid intravenous treatment with the amino acid arginine, experiencing no side effects from the treatment. The diseases were caused ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.