Forced separation can cause long-term mental health problems for children

May 23, 2018 by Jaana Juvonen And Jennifer Silvers, University of California, Los Angeles

In two speeches [recently] in the border states of Arizona and California, Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that as a matter of enforcement, if an unauthorized migrant brings a child across the United States-Mexico border without documentation, "we will prosecute you, and that child will be separated from you as required by law. If you don't like that, then don't smuggle children over our border."

This means undocumented children and parents will be separated—a tactic meant to deter migrant parents, including many asylum seekers, such as those who've traveled through Central America in a caravan in recent weeks, from crossing the in the first place. Human rights organizations such as Amnesty International have argued that this policy change is inhumane, and it is. But evidence from developmental neuroscience suggests it is more than inhumane.

It's also, by definition, torture.

Under federal law, which adopts the United Nations definition, torture is: "any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as … punishing him or her for an act he or she or a third person … has committed or is suspected of having committed." And though in theory any action inflicting such suffering is banned, that is what is inflicted by separating parents and children in border detention.

Children arriving at the U.S. border in search of asylum are frequently a particularly vulnerable population. In many cases fleeing violence and persecution, they also encounter hunger, illness and threats of physical harm along their hazardous journey to the border. This combination of experiences puts migrant children at high risk for and depression. Such anxiety and mood disorders can be debilitating and intractable, particularly when they start in childhood. By the time many migrant children arrive in the United States, they have already faced harrowing events, increasing the likelihood that they'll be traumatized by parental separation.

Parenting is, after all, a crucial ingredient in our species' recipe for survival. It is so crucial that children's brains have evolved to need it the same way that their bodies require nutrition and rest. Various studies demonstrate that being close to parents can buffer children against feelings of stress and threat. While children are remarkably flexible about who parents them—biological or adopted parents, other family members or even significant nonfamily members—they are inflexible about their need for caretaking.

The strongest evidence for the importance of close caregivers comes from children who have experienced caregiver deprivation. Even when their physical needs are met, children raised in institutional orphanages commonly exhibit stunted growth, cognitive impairments, heightened anxiety and stress-related that often persist even after being adopted into highly nurturing homes. Even mere instability of caregivers early in life is disruptive to children's development. For example, youth in foster care who experience multiple transient placements are significantly more likely to drop out of high school, be unemployed as adults and develop mental and physical illnesses.

The science leads to the conclusion that the deprivation of caregiving produces a form of extreme suffering in children. Separating migrant children from parents, then, increases the likelihood that their experience in immigration detention will cause lasting mental and possibly physical health problems.

Yet last year, citing cost, the Trump administration defunded a family detention program that catered to mothers with young children and pregnant women. Absent these family detention centers, there's a risk that once they're separated, children could wind up in facilities incapable of adequately safeguarding them while simultaneously depriving them of their most vital coping resource—their parent. That's one reason a Texas judge held in 2016 that the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services could not license an immigration detention center as a child-care facility.

By contrast, safe and healthy alternatives to separating asylum-seeking parents and children not only are practiced in other Western industrialized countries, but they're also meant to take child welfare into account. The European Commission's 2016 proposal for standards for the reception of applicants for international protection calls for conditions "adapted to the specific situation of minors, whether unaccompanied or within families, with due regard to their security, physical and emotional care and are provided in a manner that encourages their general development." Moreover, research findings clearly support that families need to be kept together. One study in Belgium concluded that "refugee adolescents separated from both experienced the highest number of traumatic events compared to accompanied refugee adolescents."

If the United States won't meet this standard, the effect will be punitive and will place the burden of a complex international challenge on the most vulnerable migrants—children. In any context, exhibiting this kind of cruelty is un-American, but particularly so in this situation. The practice of separating families at the border is morally reprehensible and—based on the science—goes against international and U.S. law, because the suffering it inflicts constitutes torture of .

Explore further: Refugees deserve health care, compassion, U.S. pediatricians say

Related Stories

Refugees deserve health care, compassion, U.S. pediatricians say

March 13, 2017
(HealthDay)—The U.S. government should treat immigrant and refugee children with compassion and provide them with appropriate health care, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) says in a new policy statement.

Parental sexual orientation and children's psychological well-being

November 8, 2017
In a Child Development study of 21,103 children aged 4-17 years, those with lesbian and gay parents did not differ from children of heterosexual parents in terms of emotional and mental health difficulties, as assessed on ...

Fifty-fifty split best for children of divorce

September 7, 2017
Preschool children in joint physical custody have less psychological symptoms than those who live mostly or only with one parent after a separation. In a new study of 3,656 children in Sweden, researchers from Uppsala University, ...

Afghan children seeking asylum in the UK: PTSD symptoms minimized for those children placed in foster care

October 19, 2012
(Medical Xpress)—A new study indicates that about one-third of asylum-seeking Afghan children who arrive in the UK without their parents or a guardian are likely to be experience symptoms associated with post-traumatic ...

Researcher presents case against child detention and family separation

November 27, 2012
A University of Huddersfield researcher attended an important event at the United Nations, Switzerland, to make the case for global policy changes so that children subject to immigration processes are never locked up by immigration ...

Detained children risk life-long physical and mental harm

February 19, 2015
Many refugees and asylum seekers, including children, have experienced conflict, family separation and significant human rights violations, including torture, physical and sexual violence in their countries of origin and ...

Recommended for you

FDA approves brain stimulation device for OCD

August 17, 2018
(HealthDay)—A brain stimulation device to treat obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) has received approval for marketing Friday by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

Research eyes role of stress in mental illnesses

August 17, 2018
We all face stress in our lives. Even researchers seeking to understand why some people shrug it off while others face battles against disorders like depression or PTSD.

16 going on 66: Will you be the same person 50 years from now?

August 17, 2018
How much do you change between high school and retirement? The answer depends on whether you're comparing yourself to others or to your younger self.

Men and women show surprising differences in seeing motion

August 16, 2018
Researchers reporting in the journal Current Biology on August 16 have found an unexpected difference between men and women. On average, their studies show, men pick up on visual motion significantly faster than women do.

It's okay when you're not okay: Study re-evaluates resilience in adults

August 16, 2018
Adversity is part of life: Loved ones die. Soldiers deploy to war. Patients receive terminal diagnoses.

Expecting to learn: Language acquisition in toddlers improved by predictable situations

August 16, 2018
The first few years of a child's life are crucial for learning language, and though scientists know the "when," the "how" is still up for debate. The sheer number of words a child hears is important; that number predicts ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet May 23, 2018
That is why the USA does it, because it is a sadictic culture and is trying to destroy itself.

That is why the have the weapon's issue, the opiod's issues, the demonization of marijuana, and the other situations that they are not willing to negotiate and that from most people perspective are clearly destroying that nation and the world at large.
not rated yet May 23, 2018
"we will prosecute you, and that child will be separated from you as required by law.

That's right, they'll punish the children for the parents misbehaviour, just like in the Dark Ages...
not rated yet Jun 19, 2018
My Hearts go out to these children and Parents that have been separated from each other. When I was young my parents went through a divorce and I was placed in Foster care while the long divorce lingered on and missed my brother and sister so much. I developed twitches and other uncontrollable ticks that I was reprimanded for! This separation changed the young happy little girl I was, never to fully trust again. It proved to be the one heartache that had ever lasting effects to my personality for the rest of my life. Not only do we need to help the innocent at the borders we need to be made aware of how the Children Services That take children from their parents THEN ask questions and make parents jump through all type of hoops when most of the time children would fair much better while staying with the ones who love them and would be willing to do what is asked of them without children being dragged out of their safe place.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.