Do images of the brain make us more likely to believe what we read?

September 20, 2018, University of Minnesota
Ironic accompanying photo of brain scans. Credit: University of Minnesota

Whether in a newspaper or online, news articles can be supported with an image of a brain scan or statement to explain the way our brain works. Often, readers use these scientific explanations to help separate fact from fiction. However in the age of fake news, what happens when extraneous brain images or claims are included in an article? Do these make us more likely to believe what we read?

According to a recent University of Minnesota study published in the British Journal of Educational Psychology, the general public is more likely to believe articles about educational topics when they are accompanied by extraneous images and verbal descriptions of neuroscience findings.

"Educational practices, like commercial brain games, are increasingly being justified by neuroscience findings," said Soo-hyun Im, the study's lead author and Ph.D. student in the University of Minnesota's Department of Educational Psychology in the College of Education and Human Development. "In many cases, these 'justifications' are unwarranted, and educational stakeholders must be able to recognize when this is so."

"The lack of evidence that continues to plague many neuroeducation programs has been the subject of intense media attention in recent years," adds the study's co-author Sashank Varma, associate professor in the Department of Educational Psychology, "In fact, a group of nearly 70 researchers recently authored a joint letter warning of the brain training hype, as reported in the journal Science."

Researchers from the Department of Educational Psychology recruited 320 participants from the U.S. using Amazon's Mechanical Turk crowdsourcing service. Participants read articles that were written in an accessible, popular science style. Each article contained a sound argument for applying a psychological finding to improve educational practice. Some articles also included descriptions of neuroscience findings that were irrelevant to the argument.

When these extraneous findings were described verbally and/or depicted by a bar graph, participants correctly judged that they did not increase the scientific credibility of articles. However, when they were described verbally and accompanied by a colorful brain image, participants rated the articles as more scientifically credible. This effect persisted even after controlling for participants' familiarity with education, attitude towards and knowledge of neuroscience.

According to Varma, further research should be done to investigate whether the 'seductive allure' of brain images also holds for educational professionals such as teachers, administrators and policymakers.

"Educational professionals must make evidence-based decisions about the adoption of new curricula, and these are being increasingly justified by erroneous appeal to findings," Varma said.

Explore further: Reading on electronic devices may interfere with science reading comprehension

More information: Soo-hyun Im et al. Extending the seductive allure of neuroscience explanations effect to popular articles about educational topics, British Journal of Educational Psychology (2017). DOI: 10.1111/bjep.12162 … inst-brain-game-hype

Related Stories

Reading on electronic devices may interfere with science reading comprehension

December 6, 2017
People who often read on electronic devices may have a difficult time understanding scientific concepts, according to a team of researchers. They suggest that this finding, among others in the study, could also offer insights ...

People who don't read the news better at predicting which articles will go viral

August 27, 2018
Figuring out how to make articles and videos go viral is the holy grail for any content creator. Although a magic formula remains elusive, in recent years, neuroscientists have forecasted which content will go viral by showing ...

Is educational neuroscience a waste of money?

March 9, 2016
Educational neuroscience has little to offer schools or children's education, according to new research from the University of Bristol, UK.

Large-scale replication study challenges key evidence for the pro-active reading brain

April 10, 2018
When people read or listen to a conversation, their pro-active brains sometimes predict which word comes next. But a scientific team led by the MPI for Psycholinguistics now demonstrates that the predictive function of the ...

Belief in neuromyths is extremely common

August 10, 2017
Researchers have surveyed educators, the public and people who have completed neuroscience courses, to assess their belief in neuromyths. Neuromyths are common misconceptions about brain research, many of which relate to ...

Recommended for you

New research has revealed we are actually better at remembering names than faces

November 14, 2018
With the Christmas party season fast approaching, there will be plenty of opportunity to re-live the familiar, and excruciatingly-awkward, social situation of not being able to remember an acquaintance's name.

Older adults' abstract reasoning ability predicts depressive symptoms over time

November 14, 2018
Age-related declines in abstract reasoning ability predict increasing depressive symptoms in subsequent years, according to data from a longitudinal study of older adults in Scotland. The research is published in Psychological ...

The illusion of multitasking boosts performance

November 13, 2018
Our ability to do things well suffers when we try to complete several tasks at once, but a series of experiments suggests that merely believing that we're multitasking may boost our performance by making us more engaged in ...

Brain changes found in self-injuring teen girls

November 13, 2018
The brains of teenage girls who engage in serious forms of self-harm, including cutting, show features similar to those seen in adults with borderline personality disorder, a severe and hard-to-treat mental illness, a new ...

Major traumatic injury increases risk of mental health diagnoses, suicide

November 12, 2018
People who experience major injuries requiring hospital admission, such as car crashes and falls, are at substantially increased risk of being admitted to hospital for mental health disorders, found a study in CMAJ (Canadian ...

Nearly one in ten Americans struggles to control sexual urges

November 9, 2018
(HealthDay)—The #MeToo movement has given many Americans a glimpse into an unfamiliar world that may have left many wondering, "What were they thinking?"


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.