Exploring the science of inspiration

December 7, 2018, Carnegie Mellon University Mechanical Engineering
Exploring the science of inspiration
We knew that stimuli can inspire problem solving. Now we know why. Credit: CC0 Creative Commons

Have you ever struggled with a problem that appeared to have no solution, and after turning your attention elsewhere, suddenly received a spark of inspiration?

This nearly universal experience caught the attention of Carnegie Mellon University's Kosa Goucher-Lambert and Jonathan Cagan. The idea that outside stimuli can provide problem solvers with the inspiration necessary for creating new solutions has been around for decades, but the researchers are specifically interested in investigating the creative potential inspirational stimuli have on assisting designers in developing novel solutions to challenging design problems.

Postdoctoral researcher Goucher-Lambert and Cagan, a professor of mechanical engineering, collaborated with Jarrod Moss, an associate professor of psychology at Mississippi State University. The team used imaging (fMRI) to explore while designers developed solutions with and without inspirational stimuli.

In doing so, they could actively map out which areas of the brain were engaged during design ideation, and thereby demonstrate exactly why stimuli can be a powerful tool for inspiring design. Their findings were published in the journal Design Studies.

For their investigation, the researchers placed participants in an fMRI and asked them to develop solutions to 12 different open-ended design problems. In order to indicate that they had created a new solution, participants would press a button, thereby allowing the researchers to later associate the fMRI images with periods of successful idea generation. For example, a participant might be asked to develop a measuring cup for the blind. At the same time, participants were provided with varying types of inspirational stimuli meant to facilitate retrieval of useful concepts from memory that might help to generate new design solutions.

Three types of inspirational stimuli were used: those similar to more expected problem solutions (near stimuli), those that seemed totally foreign from the problem (far stimuli), and control stimuli which added no new information to the problem and simply recycled from the problem prompt. All three types were presented textually, with a collection of words displayed on a screen in front of the participant along with the design problem prompt.

After receiving the prompt, participants were presented with one collection of words, dependent on the stimuli type assigned to them. For the measuring cup example, the words presented were: braille, touch, beep, sound, sensor (near); preprogram, recognize, pressure, holes, cover (far); and measuring, cup, for, the, blind (control). In this way, Goucher-Lambert and Cagan could begin to observe the impact that these varying types of inspirational stimuli had on problem-solving.

Overall, Goucher-Lambert and Cagan found that inspirational stimuli allowed participants to maintain a productive level of idea generation for a longer period of time, thereby helping them to generate more solutions to the design . Both near and far stimuli allowed participants to formulate more solutions than when no stimuli were provided, likely because these words helped direct the designer's internal attention to their memory. These stimuli encouraged semantic processing and analogical reasoning, a type of logic in which individuals apply concepts from the stimuli to a problem, through a series of associations between the two.

Perhaps most interestingly, neurological evaluation of the results revealed the activation of different brain networks depending on whether or not inspirational stimuli were given, suggesting a fundamental difference between how we think with and without outside inspiration. What's more, near stimuli activated different neurological processes than far stimuli, thereby providing additional insight into what defines a stimulus as near or far to a problem statement.

When provided with near inspirational stimuli, fMRI images showed a form of reasoning termed by Goucher-Lambert and Cagan as 'inspired internal search,' during which significant areas of activation were observed in regions of the brain associated with insight and directing attention internally towards concepts retrieved from memory. In contrast, fMRI images associated with control stimuli demonstrated 'unsuccessful external search,' during which there was increased activation in brain regions associated with visual processing and directing attention outward. Rather than finding solutions through insight, participants were more likely to look actively for another solution by analyzing their external environment.

Curiously, far inspirational stimuli showed results of both near and control stimuli. While they shared the positive characteristics of near stimuli in that they allowed participants to produce more solutions through inspired internal search, far stimuli also activated regions associated with the unsuccessful external search similar to the control stimuli. This is likely because the far stimuli, being less associated with the problem statement, required the participants to create more connections before arriving at another .

Ultimately, this work has numerous applications in design research. In addition to aiding in the development of a design tool which might provide the right at the right time, allowing the designer to come up with the most novel and productive solutions, this research also reveals how we can better teach design and problem-solving. With this work accomplished, we are one step closer to creating approaches that empower designers to develop better solutions.

Explore further: Your brain considers other people's personal space as your own

More information: Goucher-Lambert, K., Moss, J., & Cagan, J. (2018). A neuroimaging investigation of design ideation with and without inspirational stimuli—understanding the meaning of near and far stimuli. Design Studies. doi.org/10.1016/j.destud.2018.07.001

Related Stories

Your brain considers other people's personal space as your own

June 8, 2018
Peripersonal space (PPS) is a mental space defined by the brain immediately around body parts used when interacting with people and objects. Recently, researchers have shown that some neurons in the primate brain respond ...

Single 'clock' syncs action and perception

May 21, 2018
A difficult task that requires participants to determine which of two stimuli appears first demonstrates how varying rhythms of brain activity may be synchronized to achieve a stable sense of time. The research is published ...

Don't sweat the sweet stuff

October 15, 2018
Sweet and bitter flavors are identified as soon as they are tasted, according to human neural and behavioral data published in eNeuro. The study provides new insight into how the brain rapidly detects and discriminates between ...

Neuroimaging technology reveals why we choose sustainable products

March 13, 2017
Many of your everyday purchases might seem like no-brainers, but according to a new study from Carnegie Mellon University's Department of Mechanical Engineering, your choices are more complex than you might think.

Carving memories at their joints

November 6, 2014
How the brain decides when to modify old memories and when to carve new memories is revealed in a study published this week in PLOS Computational Biology.

Structural and functional abnormalities found in brains of relapsed alcohol-dependent patients

September 20, 2012
Scientists at Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin have succeeded in coming closer to determining the risk of relapse in detoxified alcohol-dependent patients. Using an imaging process (magnetic resonance tomography) ...

Recommended for you

Attention, please! Anticipation of touch takes focus, executive skills

December 12, 2018
Anticipation is often viewed as an emotional experience, an eager wait for something to happen.

Study highlights potential benefits of continuous EEG monitoring for infant patients

December 12, 2018
A recent retrospective study evaluating continuous electroencephalography (cEEG) of children in intensive care units (ICUs) found a higher than anticipated number of seizures. The work also identified several conditions closely ...

The importins of anxiety

December 11, 2018
According to some estimates, up to one in three people around the world may experience severe anxiety in their lifetime. In a study described today in Cell Reports, researchers at the Weizmann Institute of Science have revealed ...

How returning to a prior context briefly heightens memory recall

December 11, 2018
Whether it's the pleasant experience of returning to one's childhood home over the holidays or the unease of revisiting a site that proved unpleasant, we often find that when we return to a context where an episode first ...

Neurons in the brain work as a team to guide movement of arms, hands

December 11, 2018
The apparent simplicity of picking up a cup of coffee or turning a doorknob belies the complex sequence of calculations and processes that the brain must undergo to identify the location of an item in space, move the arm ...

Using neurofeedback to prevent PTSD in soldiers

December 11, 2018
A team of researchers from Israel, the U.S. and the U.K. has found that using neurofeedback could prevent soldiers from experiencing PTSD after engaging in emotionally difficult situations. In their paper published in the ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.