Assessing India's health with a single question

December 5, 2018, University of Geneva

A country can estimate its population's health status by using national survey questionnaires. A country like India, however, requires substantial, costly resources to monitor the health of its citizens, due to its size and its geographical and demographic diversity. Researchers at the University of Geneva (UNIGE), Switzerland, began wondering whether it was possible to use the single question—What would you say about your health status?—that is widely used in Europe and the USA. Working in collaboration with economists from the Institute of Development Studies Kolkata, the team at UNIGE compared Indian and Swiss databases. Their conclusions were two-fold: they found that the question provided a sound understanding of the health status of the Indian population and that the Indian data was more reliable than the Swiss. You can read all about the research in BMJ Global Health.

Is it possible, using a single question, to evaluate the general health status of a rich country like Switzerland as well as that of a middle-income country such as India? "In Europe and other high-income countries, surveys ask a general question about an individual's health: 'What would you say about your health status?'", explains Stéphane Cullati, a researcher at UNIGE's Institute of Sociological Research. "And the possible answers are: 'Very good', 'Good', 'Average', 'Bad', or 'Very bad'. We wanted to know whether this same question would be suitable for a country as socially diverse as India. Initially at least, our Indian colleagues were sceptical."

This question, simple as it is, is based on the self-evaluative capacity of populations regarding their health status. But is this self-evaluating capacity sufficient within the Indian population which is hit by poverty and suffers not just from infectious diseases due to nutritional and hygienic deficiencies but also from , which are on the rise? "In some of the poorest states in India, people are sometimes inclined to think that diseases are 'normal', even though they are actually preventable", says Claudine Burton-Jeangros, a full professor in UNIGE's Faculty of Science. "This is because diseases can be common and medical facilities rare. Likewise, illiteracy restricts the access of a certain section of the population to medical expertise, sometimes preventing them from establishing that their pains are due to chronic diseases, such as diabetes."

High-income countries versus middle-income countries

The World Health Organization (WHO) conducted a major survey of Indian citizens in 2003, which included health. In Switzerland, the Federal Statistics Office has been carrying out a health survey every five years since 1992. The UNIGE researchers compared the 2003 Indian data with the 2007 Swiss data, using about 20 comparable indicators between the two databases and measuring four key health factors: physical (heart problems, breathing difficulties and chronic diseases), mental (depression, anxiety, etc.), functional (walking, self-care, etc.) and health behaviours (physical activity, vegetable consumption, etc.). "We then evaluated the statistical association between the responses given for each indicator and the replies concerning the general state of health", continues Cullati.

The Geneva sociologists soon noticed that this simple question proved more effective with the Indian data. While in Switzerland about 80% of the population consider to be in good or very and fewer than 1% 'in very bad health', in India each category has its share of responses, with around 15% 'very poors' for 21% 'very goods'. The variance in the general state of health is captured better in India than in Switzerland. "That's why, in high-income countries, we include the 'excellent' category in addition to the 'good' and 'very good' categories, so people can better situate their general state of health and we can distribute the population into the various categories more effectively," explains Burton-Jeangros.

Why should we want to know the population's state of health?

Thanks to the study by the researchers in Geneva and Calcutta, the Indian authorities now have good reasons to believe that the simple question: "What would you say about your health status?" gives a reliable overview of the general of the population and thus can be used in survey questionnaires. "This is important information when devising these questionnaires, because if they are too long, people don't reply," points out Cullati.

Moreover, if politicians are sure that this question gives them reliable and ready-to-use data, they can rely on this type of survey with the general population to modify the provision of health care—and especially to observe the development of various diseases. "In fact, India is facing what we call a double burden: that have not yet been eradicated and a rise in chronic diseases, such as diabetes, as the middle class expands", continues Burton-Jeangros. However, differences in health are not limited to differences in access to healthcare. "An individual's position in society also has a considerable influence on health". And that is precisely the objective of the second part of the project (which is underway): to compare the social determinants of in India and Switzerland.

Explore further: Children who grew up in disadvantaged households will age in poorer health, even if their socio-economic status improves

More information: BMJ Global Health. DOI: 10.1136/bmjgh-2018-00856

Related Stories

Children who grew up in disadvantaged households will age in poorer health, even if their socio-economic status improves

February 20, 2018
Although socio-economic status is known to influence health, strong evidence of the association between economic vulnerability in childhood and the health of older adults was still missing. Researchers at the University of ...

High rates of diabetes, hypertension found in India

January 29, 2018
Rates of diabetes and hypertension are high among middle-aged and elderly people across all geographic measures and sociodemographic groups in India, according to the first nationally representative study of those conditions ...

India reports 80 Zika cases, 22 pregnant women

October 17, 2018
India has reported an outbreak of the Zika virus with 80 confirmed cases since last month including 22 pregnant women in the western state of Rajasthan, officials said Wednesday.

Infectious diseases and chronic illnesses are becoming more alike

May 5, 2016
Australia and India's leading infectious disease and chronic illness experts are meeting in Melbourne this week to discuss emerging similarities between the two fields of medical science. 

Zika virus detected in second Indian state

October 28, 2018
India's Zika outbreak is spreading, with officials saying Sunday that the mosquito-borne virus has been detected in the western state of Gujarat after nearly 150 cases were reported this year in neighbouring Rajasthan.

Undocumented immigrants least likely to see a doctor, but still healthier than other populations

September 14, 2018
Undocumented Latino immigrants have some of the lowest rates of health care use—and signs point to it getting worse.

Recommended for you

A co-worker's rudeness can affect your sleep—and your partner's, study finds

December 14, 2018
Rudeness. Sarcastic comments. Demeaning language. Interrupting or talking over someone in a meeting. Workplace incivilities such as these are becoming increasingly common, and a new study from Portland State University and ...

A holiday gift to primary care doctors: Proof of their time crunch

December 14, 2018
The average primary care doctor needs to work six more hours a day than they already do, in order to make sure their patients get all the preventive and early-detection care they want and deserve, a new study finds.

Teens get more sleep with later school start time, researchers find

December 12, 2018
When Seattle Public Schools announced that it would reorganize school start times across the district for the fall of 2016, the massive undertaking took more than a year to deploy. Elementary schools started earlier, while ...

Large restaurant portions a global problem, study finds

December 12, 2018
A new multi-country study finds that large, high-calorie portion sizes in fast food and full service restaurants is not a problem unique to the United States. An international team of researchers found that 94 percent of ...

Receiving genetic information can change risk

December 11, 2018
Millions of people in the United States alone have submitted their DNA for analysis and received information that not only predicts their risk for disease but, it turns out, in some cases might also have influenced that risk, ...

Yes please to yoghurt and cheese: The new improved Mediterranean diet

December 11, 2018
Thousands of Australians can take heart as new research from the University of South Australia shows a dairy-enhanced Mediterranean diet will significantly increase health outcomes for those at risk of cardiovascular disease ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.