Why fears over smartphone 'addiction' are based on flawed evidence

Why fears over smartphone 'addiction' are based on flawed evidence
High smartphone usage has been previously linked to anxiety and depression but Dr Ellis said there is insufficient evidence to support these conclusions. Credit: Lancaster University

Most studies into the impact of technology use on psychological wellbeing rely on flawed measures say researchers.

Surveys are often used to understand how people use their smartphone, but these are poorly related to actual smartphone use when measured with an app.

This means that existing evidence suggesting that is "addictive" cannot be used to justify any change of policy.

The UK Parliament's Science and Technology Committee recently held an inquiry into including the effects of screen time on the health of young people.

But Dr. David Ellis of Lancaster University and Brittany Davidson from The University of Bath say official policy should not solely rely on existing studies using self reports.

Dr. Ellis said "Knowing how much someone thinks or worries about their smartphone use leaves many questions unanswered"

The team examined 10 "addiction" surveys for measuring people's technology use such as the Smartphone Addiction Scale and the Mobile Phone Problem Use Scale, which generate scores that determine use.

They then compared these self-reports with data from Apple Screen Time which provides an objective measurement of:

  • How many minutes people used their phones
  • How often they picked it up
  • How many notifications they received

The researchers discovered weak relationships between how much people think they use their smartphones and how much they actually do.

Miss Davidson added "Our results suggest that the majority of these self-report smartphone assessments perform poorly when attempting to predict real-world behaviour. We need to revisit and improve these measurements moving forward."

High usage has been previously linked to anxiety and depression but Dr. Ellis said there is to support these conclusions.

"Scales that focus on the notion of 'addiction' performed very poorly and were unable to classify people into (e.g, high vs low use) based on their behaviour."

Explore further

Why we fail to understand our smartphone use

More information: David A. Ellis et al, Do smartphone usage scales predict behavior?, International Journal of Human-Computer Studies (2019). DOI: 10.1016/j.ijhcs.2019.05.004
Citation: Why fears over smartphone 'addiction' are based on flawed evidence (2019, June 12) retrieved 27 February 2021 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2019-06-smartphone-addiction-based-flawed-evidence.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments