Genetic testing IVF embryos doesn't improve the chance of a baby
If you're going through IVF, you may be offered a test to look at your embryos' chromosomes.
Pre-implantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (chromosome abnormalities), known as PGT-A, is an "add on" used to help choose embryos with the right number of chromosomes. It's promoted by IVF clinics as a way to increase the chance of success, especially for women over 35.
But the evidence shows that in most cases, PGT-A doesn't improve the chance of a baby.
What is aneuploidy?
In human embryos, most aneuploidies are lethal, resulting in miscarriage, or do not result in pregnancy at all.
The chance of aneuploidy increases with the age of the woman; by the time a woman reaches age 40, approximately 80% of her embryos are aneuploid.
What is PGT-A?
All couples produce some aneuploid embryos, whether they conceive naturally or with IVF. The idea behind PGT-A is that if the aneuploid embryos can be identified they can be discarded, so that only embryos capable of producing a healthy pregnancy are used.
PGT-A involves the woman having fertility drugs to produce several eggs. When they are mature, they are retrieved and mixed with sperm to create embryos.
Embryos are grown in the laboratory for five to six days. At this time, two types of cells are distinguishable: the cells that will develop into the placenta and the cells that will become the baby.
A few cells are removed from the future placenta for testing and the embryos are frozen until test results are available.
If the test shows there are normal embryos, one is thawed and transferred to the woman's uterus. Any remaining normal embryos will be kept frozen for transfer later if the first transfer is unsuccessful.
Importantly, PGT-A doesn't "correct" chromosomally abnormal embryos, it simply allows couples to avoid transferring them.
Who might be offered PGT-A?
Many clinics recommend PGT-A for women over 35 (more than half of women who have IVF) and those who have had repeated miscarriages or failed IVF treatments. This is because women over 35 and women with previous losses are more likely to produce aneuploid embryos.
Does PGT-A work?
While the theory behind PFT-A makes sense, randomized controlled trials (the gold standard evidence to tell us if an intervention makes a difference) have not demonstrated a clear benefit.
The pitfalls of PGT-A
PGT-A actually has the potential to reduce the chance of a baby. It can do this in two ways.
First, PGT-A is not 100% accurate. This means that inevitably, some embryos that have the capacity to form a healthy baby will be discarded.
The most common reason for these "false positive" results is that a proportion of embryos are "mosaic"—they have a mix of normal and abnormal cells. Surprisingly, mosaic chromosome abnormalities are quite common in early human embryos, and do not seem to prevent the embryo developing into a healthy baby.
However, if abnormal cells are removed and tested, the embryo will be misclassified as abnormal and discarded—a lost opportunity for a healthy pregnancy.
Many healthy babies have been born to people who have elected to have mosaic embryos transferred because they were the only embryos they had.
Second, while the risk is small, embryos can be damaged in the biopsy procedure and some embryos don't survive the freezing and thawing process.
To have or not to have PGT-A?
PGT-A costs around A$700 per embryo which adds up to A$2,800 if there are four embryos to test.
While doctors likely offer their patients detailed and individualized information about different treatment options, information about the possible benefits of PGT-A on clinic websites can be difficult to interpret.
That's why independent information about the pros and cons of PGT-A is needed to help people make informed decisions. The Victorian Assisted Reproductive Treatment Authority (VARTA) has developed a downloadable resource about the current state of knowledge about PGT-A.
Some clinics are now offering a less invasive technique where, rather than removing cells from the embryo, they test the fluid that the embryo is grown in to determine if the embryo has the right number of chromosomes. Time will tell of this will improve the chance of having a baby with IVF.
In the meantime, it may help to ask the five questions recommended by Choosing Wisely:
- do I really need this test?
- what are the risks?
- are there safer, simpler options?
- what happens if I don't do anything?
- what are the costs?
And in the case of IVF: how will this improve my chance of a live birth?