CDC study suggests inmates should have been tested in mass

CDC study suggests inmates should have been tested in mass
This April 20, 2020, file photo, shows the Marion Correctional Institution in Marion, Ohio. Mass coronavirus testing for jail and prison inmates, resisted by many correctional facilities at the beginning of the pandemic, provides a more accurate picture of the disease's spread and can potentially help prevent further transmission, according to a government study. More than 20 Ohio death row inmates have tested positive for COVID-19 in Marion. (Fred Squillante/The Columbus Dispatch via AP, File)

Correctional facilities that resisted mass coronavirus testing for inmates erred in their decision to only test inmates with symptoms, leading to large initial undercounts, a recent study by the Center for Disease Control and Prevention suggested.

The study released this week examined 13 prisons and jails in California, Colorado, Ohio and Texas, and three federal prisons in states that weren't identified.

Most of the institutions waited several days or weeks before the first identified case of COVID-19 and the beginning of mass testing, the study found.

Mass testing was expensive and ate up staff time, and rearranging living space for inmates based on the results wasn't always possible, corrections officials told researchers.

Yet only testing inmates with symptoms "likely underestimated" the number of infected prisoners, the study found. Symptom-based testing also runs the risk of inmates hiding symptoms out of fear of being removed from the regular population and being shunned by other inmates.

"Broad-based testing can provide a more accurate assessment of prevalence and generate data to help control transmission," researchers said.

In one unidentified federal prison where mass testing was delayed nearly six weeks after the first coronavirus case was identified, mass testing found 77% of inmates were positive.

In an Ohio prison where mass testing was delayed almost two weeks after the first case, mass testing found 87% of inmates tested positive.

The study also suggested that multiple re-testing of inmates after initial negative tests could help curb transmission rates.

Mass testing "irrespective of symptoms, combined with periodic retesting, can identify infections and support prevention of widespread transmission in correctional and detention environments," the study concluded.

In a second CDC study focused on Puerto Rico, only two cases of COVID-19 and no deaths have been reported in .

Puerto Rico restricted admission of all new inmates to a single facility, mass tested everyone regardless of symptoms, and adopted strict quarantining until tests results were available, the study found.

Puerto Rico's efforts should serve as a case study to protecting imprisoned people from the coronavirus, researchers concluded.

As of mid-August, more than 95,000 people in prison had tested positive for the illness, a 10% increase from the week before, according to data compiled by the Marshall Project, a nonprofit news organization focusing on , and The Associated Press.

New cases among prisoners reached an all-time high as of Aug. 14 after slowing down in June. The growth in recent weeks was driven by big jumps in prisoners testing positive in California, Florida and Texas and the federal Bureau of Prisons, along with outbreaks in Idaho, Iowa, Oregon and South Carolina.

Of prisoners testing positive, more than 62,000 have recovered, and at least 803 inmates have died, the Marshall Project/AP data showed.

Among prison staff, more than 21,000 cases of coronavirus have been reported, including 65 deaths.

© 2020 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.

Citation: CDC study suggests inmates should have been tested in mass (2020, August 21) retrieved 9 February 2023 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Follow the latest news on the coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak


Feedback to editors