People who lack compassion for the environment are also less emotional in general

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

People who respond less emotionally to images of damage to the environment are also less emotional and empathic in general, according to a new University of Michigan study.

Differences in can limit policy adjustments that address climate change. Researchers and practitioners often raise concern by appealing to people's empathy.

However, some people appear less emotionally impacted by —particularly those who are more ideologically conservative and less pro-environmental, the study showed.

In a series of online experiments in the U.S., U-M graduate student Logan Bickel and psychology professor Stephanie Preston examined the of more than 600 people in a variety of contexts.

People not concerned when viewing pictures of damage to the —such as on fire in a gulf—also did not feel bad about other images including crying babies, officers in distress, injured athletes, wounded soldiers and even moldy food.

Consistent with this lack of contagious distress, more "impassive" people said that they felt less empathy for those in daily life and were less pro-environmental and less awed by nature. This group also responded less to positive images such as happy babies, and stacks of money, the research showed.

The study's results suggest that some people's lack of concern for the environment may not be particularly political or reflect a specific disinterest in the environment. It is instead a characteristic of their broader emotional palette, Preston said.

"Given that our sense of risk and decisions are strongly guided by emotions, more impassive people are less inclined to dedicate resources to this slowly building crisis," she said.

Appeals to help the environment must consider variation in people's emotional make-up and devise new tactics for those who are unpersuaded by appeals to emotion, Logan said.

The study appeared in the recent journal Emotion.

More information: Logan A. Bickel et al, Environmental impassivity: Blunted emotionality undermines concern for the environment., Emotion (2022). DOI: 10.1037/emo0001072

Journal information: Emotion

Citation: People who lack compassion for the environment are also less emotional in general (2022, September 5) retrieved 11 December 2023 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Study provides evidence of biological roots of partisan views


Feedback to editors