Predicting repeat offenders with brain scans: You be the judge

March 26, 2013 by John Hewitt report
Predicting repeat offenders with brain scans: You be the judge
Credit: Washington Irvine, Wikimedia Commons

(Medical Xpress)—Despite the well known inaccuracies of polygraph lie detectors, they remain in widespread, if selective, use by the criminal justice system. While they are far from truth machines, if the person who is interviewed believes that they have caught in a lie, the prosecutorial sector can turn the thumbscrews so to speak. Predicting future arrest, however, is not something a polygraph can address—if the parolee doesn't even know if he or she might re-offend, how can a yes/no classifier? A study published yesterday in PNAS is the latest in a series of efforts to use fMRI to assign risk to the possibility of repeat offense. They do not claim to have found the repeat offense area of the brain, but rather determine this risk by proxy, namely a measure of impulsivity.

To measure , the researchers focused on the (ACC), a region that when lesioned by stroke, or in animal studies has been associated with an increase in inappropriate behaviors. The test was to press a button when a common was presented, and refrain from pressing the button when a rare cue was presented. The researchers were able to show that those (N=96) who had reduced ACC activity, as inferred from the , were associated with double the risk of repeat offense within four years of their release.

One of the concerns here is that, as we have seen, the MRI is far from quantitative. Right there in the abstract on this paper, the authors directly associate a relatively low ACC activity with an approximately double rearrest rate. For many, matching an adjective to a number, at least for measures of , is still a tough sell. Part of the problem here is that the ACC cannot be cast only as region of . We have just seen a study where DBS () electrodes have been placed in the ACC to treat anorexia. This follows on the heels of other studies putting electrodes (in the associated fornix) to improve memory in Alzheimer's, which was a side effect of having the in there to treat, of all things, obesity.

One implication of these observations is that, however far-fetched it may sound today, having a DBS unit in your ACC would have to absolve you from repeat offender status. Even if you turned the device off, you could argue that your ACC activity was depressed only because it had been acclimatized to the constant stimulation. Looking at images of the actual electrode placement for the study shows that they were in a part of the ACC called the subcallosal anterior cingulate. This is at least a centimeter or so below the region used in the rearrest study, but still continuous with it in form and function. One thing that has not escaped us here, is that the "control" area used for the fMRI is exactly this subcallosal cingulate area. Furthermore the subcallosal cingulate, at least to the accuracy of the MRI image is not just a cortical region, but an interconnection nexus where white matter tracts criss-cross in age old neural phylogeny which varies considerably across individuals.

We mention these comparisons only to show some of difficulties involved with making these kinds of interpretations Fortunately, or unfortunately depending on your position, brain scans are rapidly improving. The video here of the zebrafish mentating upon the tastier points of a nearby paramecium tells nothing of its impulse or intention to eat it—at least yet. This kind of detail would be quite invasive to reproduce in humans. Spying on ones inner thoughts is however less invasive than some of the other efforts to assign risk to repeat offenders.

Penile plethysmography is a very real technology which can assign a number to potential child abusers. It can be argued that it only gives an indicator of perception or attention as opposed to actual intent to do something. When considering what little else parole officers have to go on to asses risk, it is clear that these kinds of studies, however flawed, have a very real value. The temptation to use them in a proactive prosecutorial fashion should, as we have seen, be highly cautioned against.

Explore further: Study examines decision-making brain activity in patients with hoarding disorder

More information: Eyal Aharoni, Gina M. Vincent, Carla L. Harenski, Vince D. Calhoun, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, Michael S. Gazzaniga, Kent A. Kiehl, Neuroprediction of future rearrest, PNAS, 2013. Wil be available at

Identification of factors that predict recurrent antisocial behavior is integral to the social sciences, criminal justice procedures, and the effective treatment of high-risk individuals. Here we show that error-related brain activity elicited during performance of an inhibitory task prospectively predicted subsequent rearrest among adult offenders within 4 y of release (N = 96). The odds that an offender with relatively low anterior cingulate activity would be rearrested were approximately double that of an offender with high activity in this region, holding constant other observed risk factors. These results suggest a potential neurocognitive biomarker for persistent antisocial behavior.

Via NatureNews

Related Stories

Study examines decision-making brain activity in patients with hoarding disorder

August 6, 2012
Patients with hoarding disorder exhibited abnormal activity in regions of the brain that was stimulus dependent when deciding what to do with objects that did or did not belong to them, according to a report in the August ...

MRI images show what the brain looks like when you lose self-control

June 18, 2012
New pictures from the University of Iowa show what it looks like when a person runs out of patience and loses self-control.

Deciding to stay or go is a deep-seated brain function

June 6, 2011
Birds do it. Bees do it. Even little kids picking strawberries do it.

Recommended for you

Theory: Flexibility is at the heart of human intelligence

November 19, 2017
Centuries of study have yielded many theories about how the brain gives rise to human intelligence. Some neuroscientists think intelligence springs from a single region or neural network. Others argue that metabolism or the ...

Investigating patterns of degeneration in Alzheimer's disease

November 17, 2017
Alzheimer's disease (AD) is known to cause memory loss and cognitive decline, but other functions of the brain can remain intact. The reasons cells in some brain regions degenerate while others are protected is largely unknown. ...

Study may point to new treatment approach for ASD

November 17, 2017
Using sophisticated genome mining and gene manipulation techniques, researchers at Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) have solved a mystery that could lead to a new treatment approach for autism spectrum disorder ...

Paraplegic rats walk and regain feeling after stem cell treatment

November 16, 2017
Engineered tissue containing human stem cells has allowed paraplegic rats to walk independently and regain sensory perception. The implanted rats also show some degree of healing in their spinal cords. The research, published ...

Brain implant tested in human patients found to improve memory recall

November 15, 2017
(Medical Xpress)—A team of researchers with the University of Southern California and the Wake Forest School of Medicine has conducted experiments involving implanting electrodes into the brains of human volunteers to see ...

Researchers identify potential mediator for social memory formation

November 15, 2017
Research by a group of scientists at the Department of Physiology, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore (NUS Medicine) have discovered that a tiny brain region plays a critical role in the formation ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) Mar 26, 2013
Why do you need this to predict?

Scammers, con artists, ID thieves, rapists, child molesters, regular thieves and drug users will all repeat offend at the first opportunity. Murderers are extremely likely to repeat offend. They all need to be put away forever or not at all, prison only makes them worse.
4.2 / 5 (5) Mar 26, 2013
Penile plethysmography is a very dangerous technology which has lead to false arrests and convictions of innocent people, including some minors. Polygraphs are also dangerous since those prosecutors, who turn the screws on someone who is worried that the tester claims they are lying, can often get false confessions. False confessions are *a lot* easier to get than people think. People can't imagine ever confessing to something they didn't do until they find themselves interogated for hours and hours being told that no one will ever believe them and they can choose confession or really hard time.

The irony is that if they treated impulsivity as a disorder to be treated as part of their rehabilitation (even a falsely accused person would benefit from impulsivity control training--who wouldn't?) and ignored it as a means of determining guilt or sentencing, they'd be further ahead.
3.7 / 5 (3) Mar 26, 2013
What if an insufficient amount of DSB became a measure for cognitive motivated behavioral health?


A future potential diagnostic indicator that 'learning' has occurred.

5 / 5 (1) Mar 26, 2013
CQT That is certainly an interesting new story. (just to confirm I was talking here about DBS not DSB) I think most neurobiologists would be hard pressed to find a direct mechanism from behaviors to DSBs, though that is not to deny one really exists. The fact that Fred Gage has been drawn into the mix with positive oversight is telling perhaps.
1 / 5 (1) Mar 26, 2013
Correction noted. We are on the same page.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 27, 2013
can we use this on politicians and wall street criminals too?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.