A new wrinkle for botox: Research reveals how botulinum toxins affect neuron survival

March 27, 2013, Harvard Medical School
A new wrinkle for botox: Research reveals how botulinum toxins affect neuron survival
At left, a normal neuron. At right, neuron death induced by Botulinum type C toxin. Botox is type A. Credit: Dong Lab.

(Medical Xpress)—Botulinum toxins are feared as a food poison and bioterror threat, and for good reason. It takes only minute amounts of these bacterial toxins to block signals from nerve cells that control muscles. People die when the toxin paralyzes the muscles they need to breathe.

That is the deadly side of botulinum toxins and botulism disease, whose incidence has ebbed with the advent of safer and processing. But one of the seven major types, better known by its brand name Botox, is famously successful as a wrinkle remover.

Outside the cosmetic spa, botulinum toxins are now used to treat a growing list of medical conditions. Injected into target regions of the body in extremely small quantities, they attenuate overactive and relieve muscle spasms in and arm tremors in multiple sclerosis. They can even halt excessive sweating and reduce . Type A—Botox—and type B are the only two types approved by the U.S. for therapeutic and cosmetic uses, but other types are being explored as potential therapeutic toxins.

The effects of botulinum toxins usually last for up to a couple of months, so repeated injections are needed to maintain therapeutic effectiveness. This long-term exposure raises a critical question: In addition to producing temporary relief from overactive neurons, do botulinum toxins have the potential to cause irreversible ?

Now researchers from Harvard Medical School have investigated the effect that all seven botulinum toxins have on neuron survival. They have discovered that not all botulinum toxins are equally safe for neurons. Writing recently in Nature Communications, they reported that two of the seven botulinum toxins, type C and type E, induce degeneration of both cultured rodent neurons and human motor neurons derived from .

"Botulinum toxins are not expected to cause death of neurons if they just block signals between neurons and muscles, which is the well-established mode of action for this class of toxins," said Min Dong, HMS independent instructor in the Department of Microbiology and Immunobiology and the Division of Neuroscience at the New England Primate Research Center, and senior author of the paper. "It has been observed since as early as the 1980s that neurons die after exposure to type C toxin. The mechanism remains a mystery, but it raises a red flag as to whether botulinum toxins may affect additional neuronal functions."

Dong has been studying botulinum toxins for more than a decade, developing methods to detect the toxins in 2004 and identifying receptors for Botox in 2006, prior to establishing his lab at the New England Primate Research Center in 2009. Intrigued by the earlier observations on type C toxin, Dong and his postdoctoral fellow Lisheng Peng, first author of the study, designed assays to examine the effect of all seven botulinum toxins on neuron survival. Their study not only confirmed the previous observation on type C toxin, but it also revealed type E as the second toxin that can cause neuron death.

What could the mechanism be for the neuron death and why would it work only in types C and E, but not other botulinum toxins? Dong and his colleagues found that the answer lies in which host proteins are being attacked by each toxin type.

All botulinum toxins shut down signals from neurons to muscles by attacking a complex composed of three proteins inside neurons. It turns out that two of these three proteins, known as syntaxin 1 and SNAP-25, not only release signals from neurons, but also perform the essential housekeeping process of recycling the neuron's plasma membranes. Type C toxin attacks syntaxin 1, while type E toxin attacks SNAP-25. The resulting blockage of plasma membrane recycling leads to death of neurons.

In contrast to syntaxin 1 and SNAP-25, the third protein in the complex, known as synaptobrevin, is not involved in the recycling process. This explains why type B, D, F and G toxins, all of which attack synaptobrevin, do not cause neuron death.

The findings on Botox, or type A, are more complicated. Botox attacks SNAP-25, but it does not induce death of neurons. Clinical data have also demonstrated that Botox is safe for neuron survival in patients. Dong and his colleagues found out why: Type E cleaves a larger fragment from SNAP-25 than type A, causing more extensive damage to the function of SNAP-25. In contrast, SNAP-25 cleaved by type A can still support the neuron's essential recycling of plasma membranes.

But the safety of type A toxin is not absolute, the scientists found. Once SNAP-25 has been cleaved by type A, its ability to tolerate additional mutations and defects in neurons is reduced.

"Botox is safe in general," Dong said, "but it can cause the death of neurons when we introduce mutations in SNAP-25 in our experiments. Whether this can occur in rare cases in patients needs to be studied further."

The discovery that syntaxin 1 and SNAP-25 are essential for neuron survival may also have implications for better understanding the neuron death process in neurodegenerative diseases, Dong said.

"Syntaxin 1 and SNAP-25 have been implicated in neurodegenerative diseases, and our data suggest that disruption of plasma membrane recycling might be a contributing factor."

As for clinical uses, caution is advised.

"We have to be careful about which type of botulinum we can use in patients," Dong said. "Based on our findings, type C and type E toxins should not be used in humans."

Explore further: Botox injections associated with only modest benefit for chronic migraine and daily headaches

More information: Peng, L. et al. Cytotoxicity of botulinum neurotoxins reveals a direct role of syntaxin 1 and SNAP-25 in neuron survival, Nat Commun. 2013 Feb 12;4:1472. doi: 10.1038/ncomms2462.

Related Stories

Botox injections associated with only modest benefit for chronic migraine and daily headaches

April 24, 2012
Although botulinum toxin A ("Botox") injections are U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved for preventive treatment for chronic migraines, a review and analysis of previous studies finds a small to modest benefit for ...

Don't let botox go to your head…or should you?

January 8, 2013
Injecting botox into the arm muscles of stroke survivors, with severe spasticity, changes electrical activity in the brain and may assist with longer-term recovery, according to new research.

Neurons from stem cells could replace mice in botulinum test

February 6, 2012
(PhysOrg.com) -- Using lab-grown human neurons, researchers from the University of Wisconsin-Madison have devised an effective assay for detecting botulinum neurotoxin, the agent widely used to cosmetically smooth the wrinkles ...

Recommended for you

Researchers illustrate how muscle growth inhibitor is activated, could aid in treating ALS

January 19, 2018
Researchers at the University of Cincinnati (UC) College of Medicine are part of an international team that has identified how the inactive or latent form of GDF8, a signaling protein also known as myostatin responsible for ...

Bioengineered soft microfibers improve T-cell production

January 18, 2018
T cells play a key role in the body's immune response against pathogens. As a new class of therapeutic approaches, T cells are being harnessed to fight cancer, promising more precise, longer-lasting mitigation than traditional, ...

Weight flux alters molecular profile, study finds

January 17, 2018
The human body undergoes dramatic changes during even short periods of weight gain and loss, according to a study led by researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine.

Secrets of longevity protein revealed in new study

January 17, 2018
Named after the Greek goddess who spun the thread of life, Klotho proteins play an important role in the regulation of longevity and metabolism. In a recent Yale-led study, researchers revealed the three-dimensional structure ...

The HLF gene protects blood stem cells by maintaining them in a resting state

January 17, 2018
The HLF gene is necessary for maintaining blood stem cells in a resting state, which is crucial for ensuring normal blood production. This has been shown by a new research study from Lund University in Sweden published in ...

Magnetically applied MicroRNAs could one day help relieve constipation

January 17, 2018
Constipation is an underestimated and debilitating medical issue related to the opioid epidemic. As a growing concern, researchers look to new tools to help patients with this side effect of opioid use and aging.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 28, 2013
Fascinating information and photograph. Different types of botulinum toxins is just one more reason for cosmetic surgeons to be sure they only buy from authorized distributers or the company itself. There had been counterfeit Botox going around the United States last year. Scary stuff.

Dr Rhys Branman
Little Rock Cosmetic Surgery Center

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.