Kids' learning and health is shaped by genes they don't inherit, as well as genes they do

February 1, 2018 by Jenny Graves, The Conversation
There’s fresh evidence to inject into the old ‘nature versus nurture’ debate. Credit: dannywilson/flickr , CC BY-NC-ND

It's a hoary old debate: how much do our genes define how we grow and learn, and how much is due to the environment? A new study by Kong and colleagues shows that parents' genes, even those not passed on to children, have major effects on kids' health and educational attainment.

Although this discovery has been reported by some as "headspinning", to me it is not too surprising.

We already know parents contribute genes that directly influence development, and that the child's environment determines how these genes have an effect.

But a crucial part of this environment is the parents. To me, this new study highlights the importance of parental genes in shaping how we are raised.

Genes and human development

We know from many studies that most aspects of human growth and development are strongly influenced by the genetic make-up of the child. For instance, comparing identical and non-identical twins shows big genetic components for such physical differences as height and weight, as well as for many behaviours, including learning ability.

But we also know all of these traits are strongly influenced by the environment. For instance, height can be stunted by poor nutrition, and learning ability limited by poverty.

Hundreds – probably thousands – of our 20,000 genes contribute to these qualities. For each gene, different variants (called "alleles") may produce differences – large or small – in how children develop.

The way to identify these genes is to compare the genetic make-up of many people and see what alleles correlate – that is, show a statistically relevant match-up – with particular traits. This used to be tough when we were working one gene at a time, using clumsy ways to identify alleles by their DNA sequence or by the proteins they make.

Now that DNA sequencing is cheap, scientists can look at the whole genome of thousands of children, and their parents, and identify sequence differences all over the genome. This technique, called genome-wide association study (GWAS), has identified many involved in normal development and human diseases.

For example, we know from a study of 100,000 people that 74 regions of the genome are associated with "educational attainment" (the number of years spent studying).

Gene effects at a distance

A child receives one copy (allele) of each gene via an egg from the mother, and another allele of each gene via a sperm from the father. Because mothers and fathers are likely to have slight sequence differences in most of their genes, it is easy (for a computer, that is) to identify for each gene which allele came from mum and which from dad.

It is also easy to do the opposite: tell which of the mother's or father's two alleles was transmitted to the child, and which allele did not make it into that particular contributing egg or sperm.

Most GWAS studies analyse only those parental alleles that were transmitted to the child. The new study deliberately looks at the parental alleles that were not transmitted.

The study traced genes in 21,637 men and women in Iceland, where genome data are available for the whole population. They looked in one or both parents to figure out which alleles of genes were transmitted to each subject, and discover which weren't.

Then they correlated the non-transmitted parental alleles to aspects of education and health in their children. They found, overall, that non-transmitted alleles added up to major effect on the of the child, nearly a third of the direct effect of the children's own genes. Non-transmitted alleles had the same effect won educational attainment whether they were in mothers or fathers.

It was similar for components of growth and health: height, weight, body mass index, use of glucose and fat metabolism in the body, and even the number of cigarettes smoked. Again, the non-transmitted parental alleles (especially the mother's) were found to have a major effect, even though they didn't end up in the children.

The nature of nurture

So why am I not surprised by this new finding?

We have known for a long time that the genetic make-up of the mother may have a strong effect on the development of her offspring. "Maternal effect genes" have been studied for decades in domestic animals, even fish and fruit flies.

In humans and other mammals, such genes influence health and nutritional status of the mother during pregnancy, and the supply and make-up of her milk. This has big effects on the growth and development of the fetus and the infant. So it is not surprising that, in this study, the mothers' non-transmitted alleles have a greater effect on their children's health than those from the father.

But how would the father's non-transmitted genes work? And how would affect the ultimate education attainment of their child?

The transmission of influence must be via the parents' parenting behaviour, which is itself partly genetically determined. The priorities that parents place on reading, sport, use of alcohol and cigarettes are all shaped by genes, and create a home environment that influences children for better or for worse.

This work emphasises that parents are critical components of their 's environment. Their contribution to their children's welfare is not only directly through the alleles they pass on, but also indirectly through their own genetic make-up that influences who they are and how they raise their .

Kong calls this "genetic nurture." But I wonder if his work has inadvertently started to identify that contribute to "good parenting"?

Explore further: deCODE study highlights the important role of genes in nurture

Related Stories

deCODE study highlights the important role of genes in nurture

January 26, 2018
In a study published tomorrow, researchers at deCODE genetics demonstrate that parental genes, both those that are transmitted to the child and those not transmitted, can affect the child's fate through their impact on the ...

Pregnant mothers influence fetal growth through genetics rather than maternal height

August 18, 2015
Transmitted genes, rather than growth limitations caused by actual differences in maternal height, are the key means by which a mother's height influences her baby's birth weight and length, according to a new study published ...

Parental weight strongly influences thinness in children

October 3, 2011
Children with thinner parents are three times more likely to be thin than children whose parents are overweight, according to a new study by UCL researchers.

How our cells use mother's and father's genes

September 28, 2016
Researchers at Karolinska Institutet and Ludwig Institute for Cancer Research have characterized how and to what degree our cells utilize the gene copies inherited from our mother and father differently. At a basic level ...

Stepping up the hunt for genetic diseases

February 16, 2017
When a child is conceived, he or she receives DNA from both parents. The child's own genome thus consists of a maternal and a paternal genome. However, some genes—about 100 out of the 20,000 encoded genes— are exclusively ...

Recommended for you

Identifying Crohn's disease risk factors in the Ashkenazi Jewish population

May 25, 2018
It is estimated that one in three individuals of Ashkenazi Jewish (AJ) descent carry mutations that increase their risk for certain genetic diseases. For instance, Crohn's, a highly heritable inflammatory bowel disease, is ...

How do insects survive on a sugary diet?

May 25, 2018
There's a reason parents tell their kids to lay off the sugar: too much isn't good for you.

Regulatory mutations missed in standard genetic screening lead to congenital diseases

May 25, 2018
Researchers have identified a type of genetic aberration to be the cause of certain neurodevelopmental disorders and congenital diseases, such as autism and congenital heart disease, which are undetectable by conventional ...

New chromosome study can lead to personalised counselling of pregnant women

May 25, 2018
Foetuses with a so-called new balanced chromosomal aberration have a higher risk of developing brain disorders such as autism and mental retardation than previously anticipated. The risk is 20 per cent for foetuses with these ...

New findings on autism-related disorder

May 24, 2018
In a study published today in Nature, Marc Bühler and his group at the Friedrich Miescher Institute for Biomedical Research (FMI) have taken a major step forward in elucidating the mechanisms underlying a disorder known ...

Genome study presents new way to track historical demographics of US populations

May 24, 2018
Sharon Browning of the University of Washington and colleagues developed a method to estimate historical effective population size, which is the number of individuals who pass on their genes to the next generation, to reveal ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.