Study finds hospital quality report cards and readmission penalties may not tell whole story

March 26, 2018, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
New research finds significant differences in hospitals' performance when readmissions were assessed for non-Medicare patients and for conditions other than those currently reported, showing that when these additional factors are taken into account, half of hospitals would be subject to a change in their financial penalty status. Credit: Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center

Over the past several years, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) have reported hospital quality measures on the Hospital Compare website, providing the public with a way to compare hospital performance. Hospital readmission rates in particular have gained substantial attention from policymakers and health care providers because of their high frequency and significant costs. Among the most prominent of these are 30-day hospital readmission rates for specific conditions, including heart failure (HF), pneumonia and myocardial infarction (MI or heart attack) which are risk-adjusted to account for differences in patients' health status. Higher-than-average 30-day readmission rates not only result in poor report cards for low-performing hospitals, but can also result in substantial financial penalties.

Now new research finds that these condition-specific readmissions measures may not accurately or fairly reflect . Led by researchers at the Smith Center for Outcomes Research in Cardiology at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (BIDMC) and publishing online today in the Annals of Internal Medicine, the study found significant differences in hospitals' performance when readmissions were assessed for non-Medicare patients and for other than those currently reported, showing that when these additional factors are taken into account, half of hospitals would be subject to a change in their financial penalty status.

"As it currently exists, the Medicare public reporting system offers an incomplete picture," said senior author Robert W. Yeh, MD, MSc, Director of the Smith Center for Outcomes Research in Cardiology at BIDMC. "Significant attention has been given to hospitals' overall performance as determined by the public reporting of a small number of specific conditions and patient populations. It's a little bit like issuing a final grade based on a few homework assignments and not a full semester's worth of work."

Calculations known as excess readmission ratios (ERRs) examine hospitals' readmissions for , and pneumonia among Medicare beneficiaries. These ERRs are currently used to assess care quality and determine hospital payments.

"We wanted to know if hospitals that reported high readmission rates for fee-for-service Medicare patients would also have high readmission rates for patients with other payers, including Medicaid and private insurance," said first author Neel Butala, MD, MBA, an investigator at the Smith Center at BIDMC and cardiology fellow at Massachusetts General Hospital. "We also wanted to find out if hospitals with high readmission rates for the three specified conditions - failure, pneumonia and heart attack - had similarly high readmission rates for other unreported conditions."

To answer these questions, they reviewed data from the Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project's Nationwide Readmission Database. The researchers focused on more than 2,100 hospital observations in 2013 and 2014 to investigate whether 30-day readmission measures for publicly reported conditions (HF, MI, and pneumonia) among Medicare patients reflect hospital performance on readmissions more broadly in an all-payer national sample. They found that 29 percent of hospitals currently being penalized for readmissions would no longer incur a penalty if unreported conditions were used as the basis of the calculations. The findings revealed that the difference was even greater when examining non-Medicare readmission rates: 40 percent of penalized hospitals would no longer be issued penalties if - instead of Medicare patients - performance was based on for non-Medicare hospitalized for heart failure, pneumonia or heart attack.

"This tells us that similar hospital or patient characteristics may influence readmissions more than similar disease conditions and suggests that efforts to prevent readmissions may be more successful by targeting hospital-wide processes rather than condition-specific processes," said Butala.

"Our results suggest that although performance on may reflect broader institutional characteristics, the concordance of each hospital's performance across different conditions varies substantially," said Yeh, who is also an Associate Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School. "It goes to show that Medicare metrics alone may not be the final word on quality for readmissions."

Explore further: Hospital readmission rates decrease after passage of ACA financial penalties

More information: Annals of Internal Medicine (2018). DOI: 10.7326/M17-1492

Related Stories

Hospital readmission rates decrease after passage of ACA financial penalties

December 26, 2016
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) instituted financial penalties against hospitals with high rates of readmissions for Medicare patients with certain health conditions. A new analysis led by researchers at Beth Israel Deaconess ...

Study: Reducing hospital readmissions does not increase mortality rates

July 18, 2017
Recent advances in reducing hospital readmission rates for three key medical conditions occurred without causing an increase in death rates, according to a new Yale-led study.

Readmission penalties don't correlate to heart attack outcomes

April 26, 2017
A program that penalizes hospitals for high early readmission rates of heart attack patients may be unfairly penalizing hospitals that serve a large proportion of African-Americans and those with more severe illness, a study ...

Public reporting of hospital readmissions hasn't cut rates

February 25, 2016
(HealthDay)—For patients with myocardial infarction (MI), heart failure, and pneumonia, the release of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) public reporting of hospital readmission rates has had no impact ...

When it comes to reducing hospital readmissions, financial penalties work

December 27, 2016
Hospitals that were financially penalized for too many readmissions were more likely than non-penalized institutions to subsequently reduce readmissions for all conditions, according to a new study by Yale School of Medicine ...

Hospital quality linked to readmission rates for COPD and other diseases

March 21, 2017
Nearly one in five patients admitted to hospitals in the United States are readmitted within 30 days, at a cost of $17 billion annually. To reduce readmission rates, the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) ...

Recommended for you

India launches 'Modicare', world's biggest health scheme

September 23, 2018
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday launched the world's biggest health insurance scheme, promising free coverage for half a billion of India's poorest citizens ahead of national elections next year.

Patient-centered visual aid helps physicians discuss risks, treatments with parents

September 21, 2018
A series of illustrations and charts designed as decision aids for parents of children with minor head injuries helped them communicate with emergency medicine physicians and make informed decisions about their child's care, ...

Alcohol responsible for one in 20 deaths worldwide: WHO

September 21, 2018
Alcohol kills three million people worldwide each year—more than AIDS, violence and road accidents combined, the World Health Organization said Friday, adding that men are particularly at risk.

Smart pills dumb down medical care, experts warn

September 21, 2018
Enthusiasm for an emerging digital health tool, the smart pill, is on the rise but researchers at the University of Illinois at Chicago have published a paper in the American Journal of Bioethics that cautions health care ...

Crunched for time? High-intensity exercise = same cell benefits in fewer minutes

September 20, 2018
A few minutes of high-intensity interval or sprinting exercise may be as effective as much longer exercise sessions in spurring beneficial improvements in mitochondrial function, according to new research. The small study ...

China's doctor shortage prompts rush for AI health care

September 20, 2018
Qu Jianguo, 64, had a futuristic medical visit in Shanghai as he put his wrist through an automated pulse-taking machine and received the result within two minutes on a mobile phone—without a doctor present.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.