New model can predict best drug combinations for osteoporosis

New model can predict best drug combinations for osteoporosis
The equation symbolizing the mathematical model of osteoporosis overlaid on an image showing osteoporotic fractures (red) in the thoracic spine. Credit: Spine X-ray Friederike Thomasius; collage created by David Jörg

A new model, described today in eLife, may help improve outcomes for patients with postmenopausal osteoporosis and reduce the risks of side effects by helping physicians build more personalized treatment regimes.

The sudden loss of the hormone estrogen during menopause can interfere with the body's natural processes for repairing natural wear and tear on bones, leading to more weakened bones and possible fractures. Several drugs are available to treat this type of postmenopausal loss. While these treatments can be combined, there is little evidence to suggest what the most effective combinations might be.

"We wanted to know if there are treatment combinations that would work considerably better than those tested and currently used in ," says first author David Jörg, Senior Scientist in the Biomedical Modeling and Simulation Group, Fresenius Medical Care Germany, Bad Homburg, Germany. "If so, then this could be beneficial for treating a large number of patients by increasing their bone strength and reducing their risk of bone fracture risk more than standard therapies currently allow."

To explore this further, Jörg and colleagues built a mathematical model of bone renewal that predicts the effects of various osteoporosis medications in postmenopausal women. They based the model on the latest evidence of how old bone breaks down and new bone is created, as well as how different classes of osteoporosis medications work. They then verified the accuracy of the model by testing its predictions on data from clinical trials.

Next, the team tested the effects of reshuffling the order of different osteoporosis medications. Their model showed that some combinations in a particular order would perform significantly better than others. They also found that combinations that cause the most rapid increases in bone density do not always strengthen bone in the long term and can instead cause a rebound of accelerated bone loss after the treatment stops. "These results show us why the order in which osteoporosis medications are taken is important for short and long-term treatment success in patients," says co-author Doris Fürtinger, Director of the Biomedical Modeling and Simulation Group, Fresenius Medical Care Germany.

While the model was specific to , the authors say it could be adapted to help design treatment combinations for patients with bone loss caused by other medications or medical conditions. For example, it could be beneficial for those who take corticosteroid medications or who have hyperparathyroidism and gastrointestinal diseases.

"As our model could potentially predict the effects of a broad range of complex drug combination therapies beyond those used for its development, it could be used for the design of future ," says senior author Peter Kotanko, Research Director at the Renal Research Institute, New York, US, and Adjunct Professor of Medicine and Nephrology at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York.

Kotanko adds that general limitations of the model need to be considered when using it as a predictive tool, especially when applying the data to extreme dosing regimens, dosing frequencies or age regions beyond those validated in the study. "However, we've shown that not only can the model be used as a starting point for forecasting osteoporosis therapy success, but it also highlights the role of mathematical descriptions in helping us understand the biological principles of how drugs work," he concludes.

More information: David J Jörg et al, Modeling osteoporosis to design and optimize pharmacological therapies comprising multiple drug types, eLife (2022). DOI: 10.7554/eLife.76228

Journal information: eLife

Provided by eLife
Citation: New model can predict best drug combinations for osteoporosis (2022, August 9) retrieved 22 September 2023 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

North American Menopause Society updates position statement on osteoporosis management


Feedback to editors