Physical principles for scalable neural recording

July 2, 2013 by John Hewitt report

(Medical Xpress)—It took nearly two months, but the videos from the May 6th-7th national BRAIN Initiative meeting are now available online. Although the title of that workshop made central mention of the idea Physical and Mathematical Principles there really wasn't too much of all that. We did cover some thoughts from one of the speakers, Terry Sejnowski, regarding temporal coding in olfaction, but the real neural engineering detail many want to hear about from the BRAINI explorers was recently slipped in with much less fanfare. A draft that appeared on the Arxiv preprint server entitled "Physical Principles for Scalable Neural Recording," gets right to the heart of the matter with a theoretical exploration of limits to introducing hardware into the brain. In particular, the authors assess four major methods of neural recording - electrical, optical, NMR, and molecular recording - and attempt to define the energetic and volumetric constraints that each must operate within.

Three names on the Arxiv paper, Ed Boyden, George Church, and Konrad Kording serve as suitable summary for many of the innovative ideas for recording large scale maps. They note that the current state-of-the-art in is recording 100,000 neurons at 1.25 second resolution in transparent zebrafish brains using light sheet microscopy, or alternatively, recording perhaps 1000 neurons at 100 millisecond timescale with a 1-photon fiberscope in behaving mice. Not bad, but still a way off from large scale recording at the scale of a human level. What is a little concerning however, is that they go on to say that the , consuming about 15 watts of power, performs the equivalent of 10^17 FLOPs, at least according to one definition. These guys know that the brain has no decimal point, and that it does not in any shape or form produce floating point computational ops, so let us hope that this is the last time we hear such talk. The same should be said for attempts to calculate entropy-per-spike train for flies, or extrapolating up orders of magnitude in brain size to create an entropy-per-firing rate function for a mouse brain.

Where the paper becomes invaluable is when it turns to the topic of energy dissipation inside a brain that is receiving a constant power influx. Implanted devices may be powered from without, and also may generate power from within to record, stimulate, communicate, and move. The heat generated needs to be dumped somewhere by the brain, and temperature increases of just a couple of degrees must be considered prohibitive. Similarly, hardware added to the brain takes up non negligible space, whether it is intracortical, intraventricular or the intracapillary space.

In highlighting the importance of not disrupting the natural blood circulation, the authors point to recent work in whole brain functional imaging. I am not sure here, but I think the intended reference was to be to the recent work in defining a cortical angiome, the fine scale geometry of the interconnected vascular network. The term angiome has been suggested before, and it is good to see that it is becoming more widespread in use as it will no doubt be of increasing importance. More critical to the problem of heat dissipation, recent studies on the brain's glymphatic system (coined from glia + lymph)give us some hint as to how to proceed.

Like any natural river system, several times the total flow through the river itself actually occurs through the surrounding soil and bedrock. Similarly in the brain, there is significant parallel extravascular flow that is carried in part through concentric lymph channels, and then intracellularly transduced through astrocytic endfeet. It will be important to work with the natural flow of blood, glymph, and CSF in exhausting excess heat generated by hardware. If one is itching to apply engineering terms to the brain, perhaps this is the proper place. One consideration in this vein would be to define a Peclet number for various brain microstructures. Generally, the Peclet number is a dimensionless description of flow as the ration of advection to diffusion. The microscale temperature profile of the brain is undoubtedly quite rich, and probably enjoys rapid natural dissipation, at least at the scale of mitochondrial movements. In the , mass flow is undoubtedly much different from heat flow. Peclet numbers for heat flow would be defined by the thermal diffusivity of different natural tissues, and perhaps also by artificial heat sinks strategically deployed.

The arxiv paper does a nice job of describing molecular tickertapes in light of the energy requirement in the form of ATP to build them. The authors feel that while significant, the energy needed to write redundant tapes to give significant accuracy would not be prohibitive to a cell. However, it is far from clear that tickertapes will even be necessary, particularly if real-time spike data is desired. In fact, there may be far more interesting things that could be done at the real-time genetic level within the high-priced real estate of the nucleus.

The fantastic explorations of the paper only begin at tickertapes. Combination with virus-enabled barcodes may permit new ways of targeting machinery to specific neural circuits. High resolution MRI that is not limited by the diffusion of water could make use of non-diffusable spins. X-ray imaging of live cells may be possible if suitable contrast agents are devised. There is much to be discovered in this paper, and hopefully it will be the starting point for many new neural-recording technologies.

Explore further: 3-D map of blood vessels in cerebral cortex holds suprises

More information: Physical Principles for Scalable Neural Recording, arXiv:1306.5709 [q-bio.NC]

Simultaneously measuring the activities of all neurons in a mammalian brain at millisecond resolution is a challenge beyond the limits of existing techniques in neuroscience. Entirely new approaches may be required, motivating an analysis of the fundamental physical constraints on the problem. We outline the physical principles governing brain activity mapping using optical, electrical,magnetic resonance, and molecular modalities of neural recording. Focusing on the mouse brain, we analyze the scalability of each method, concentrating on the limitations imposed by spatiotemporal resolution, energy dissipation, and volume displacement. We also study the physics of powering and communicating with microscale devices embedded in brain tissue.

Related Stories

3-D map of blood vessels in cerebral cortex holds suprises

June 9, 2013
Blood vessels within a sensory area of the mammalian brain loop and connect in unexpected ways, a new map has revealed.

New non-invasive method for brain research

June 24, 2013
Neuroscientists at the University of Tübingen have become the first to record neuromagnetic activity in the millisecond-by-millisecond range while the brain of a human subject was under stimulation by electric current. Electric ...

'Should I stay or should I go?' Neuroscientists link brain cell types to behavior

May 26, 2013
Neuroscientists from Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, led by Assistant Professor Adam Kepecs, have linked the activity of two types of brain nerve cells, neurons, to decisions made during particular type of behavior. The team ...

New methods to explore astrocyte effects on brain function

April 29, 2013
A study in The Journal of General Physiology presents new methods to evaluate how astrocytes contribute to brain function, paving the way for future exploration of these important brain cells at unprecedented levels of detail.

Researchers image most of vertebrae brain at single cell level (w/ video)

March 20, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—Misha Ahrens and Philipp Keller, researchers with the Howard Hughes Medical Institute have succeeded in making a near real-time video of most of a zebrafish's brain showing individual neuron cells firing. ...

Brain's 'garbage truck' may hold key to treating Alzheimer's and other disorders

June 27, 2013
In a perspective piece appearing today in the journal Science, researchers at University of Rochester Medical Center (URMC) point to a newly discovered system by which the brain removes waste as a potentially powerful new ...

Recommended for you

Brain guides body much sooner than previously believed

September 25, 2017
The brain plays an active and essential role much earlier than previously thought, according to new research from Tufts University scientists which shows that long before movement or other behaviors occur, the brain of an ...

A brain system that builds confidence in what we see, hear and touch

September 25, 2017
A series of experiments at EPFL provide conclusive evidence that the brain uses a single mechanism (supramodality) to estimate confidence in different senses such as audition, touch, or vision. The study is published in the ...

Touching helps build the sexual brain

September 21, 2017
Hormones or sexual experience? Which of these is crucial for the onset of puberty? It seems that when rats are touched on their genitals, their brain changes and puberty accelerates. In a new study publishing September 21 ...

Gene immunotherapy protects against multiple sclerosis in mice

September 21, 2017
A potent and long-lasting gene immunotherapy approach prevents and reverses symptoms of multiple sclerosis in mice, according to a study published September 21st in the journal Molecular Therapy. Multiple sclerosis is an ...

Neuron types in brain are defined by gene activity shaping their communication patterns

September 21, 2017
In a major step forward in research, scientists at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL) today publish in Cell a discovery about the molecular-genetic basis of neuronal cell types. Neurons are the basic building blocks that ...

Highly precise wiring in the cerebral cortex

September 21, 2017
Our brains house extremely complex neuronal circuits whose detailed structures are still largely unknown. This is especially true for the cerebral cortex of mammals, where, among other things, vision, thoughts or spatial ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jul 02, 2013
Nice work, John! Thanks for taking time to understand what the paper is really about and for sharing your insights.
1 / 5 (1) Jul 03, 2013
Why Not attempt 3-D Printing Brains of Dead?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.