Major clinical trial led to steep declines in use of an ineffective breast cancer treatment

Many common medical treatments have never been tested in a clinical trial. A new study published in the July issue of Health Affairs highlights how evidence from trials of untested but widely used treatments can change medical practice and help patients.

A clinical trial with results published in 2011 found that certain women with early stage breast cancer do not benefit from surgery, called axillary dissection, to remove . The procedure can lead to arm swelling and other painful side effects.

Experts were unsure whether the study results would cause physicians to change how they treat . David Howard, PhD, associate professor of health policy and management at Emory's Rollins School of Public Health, led a subsequent study that showed use of the axillary dissection declined immediately after the results of the clinical trial were released. The proportion of women who met the trial inclusion criteria and underwent axillary dissection dropped roughly in half, from 60 percent before the trial to 30 percent after the trial.

The results challenge the conventional wisdom that physicians are slow to react to new evidence. "The trial had a large and rapid effect on how patients are treated," explains Howard. "This potentially spared many women from arm swelling and other painful side effects." The study highlights the value  to patients and the health system of conducting of established medical practices.

"This is another example of how trials of widely used but untested medical practices, of which there are many, can change the way that physicians treat patients, thereby improving patient and reducing costs," says Howard.

Explore further

Breast cancer patients with positive ultrasound guided axillary node biopsy need dissection

More information: D. H. Howard et al. Contrary To Conventional Wisdom, Physicians Abandoned A Breast Cancer Treatment After A Trial Concluded It Was Ineffective, Health Affairs (2016). DOI: 10.1377/hlthaff.2015.1490
Journal information: Health Affairs

Provided by Emory University
Citation: Major clinical trial led to steep declines in use of an ineffective breast cancer treatment (2016, July 7) retrieved 24 November 2020 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments