Two combination therapies shrink melanoma brain metastases in more than half of patients

June 5, 2017

High response rates to a pair of combination therapies point to potentially new options for a group of metastatic melanoma patients who have been largely left out of recent treatment progress - those whose disease has spread to the brain.

A combination regimen of two immunotherapies and another of two targeted therapies each significantly shrank metastatic in at least 50 percent of patients in separate multi-center clinical trials presented today at the 2017 ASCO Annual Meeting by principal investigators from The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center.

"These encouraging results highlight the possibility of new treatment options, and new hope, for our patients with metastases to the brain, which are a leading cause of death from the disease," said Hussein Tawbi, M.D., Ph.D., associate professor of Melanoma Medical Oncology and leader of the immunotherapy trial.

Very often clinical trial protocols either exclude these patients or require them to first receive radiation treatment for their brain tumors before they can take experimental drugs, Tawbi said. The practical effect is virtual exclusion from participation in many promising investigational studies.

"The goal is to accelerate systemic treatments for these patients," Tawbi said. "These trials show you can have response in the brain without radiation first." About 70 percent of patients with stage IV, or metastatic, melanoma eventually develop brain metastases.

"In addition to showing that these combinations are safe and effective, these results demonstrate the overall feasibility of conducting clinical trials for melanoma patients with brain metastases, which ultimately will make more treatments available to these patients," said Michael Davies, M.D., Ph.D., associate professor of Melanoma Medical Oncology and co-leader of MD Anderson's Melanoma Moon Shot.

Davies and Tawbi are part of a team at MD Anderson intensely focused on improving treatment of melanoma brain metastases. They designed and led these clinical trials.

In the past six years, a wave of new drugs - including both immunotherapies and targeted therapies - have extended the lives of patients with . However, concerns about whether the drugs could reach tumors in the brain, coupled with the historically poor prognosis of these patients, led drug developers to exclude patients with untreated brain metastases from all of the clinical trials that resulted in U.S. Food and Drug Administration approval of these agents.

While overall median survival is climbing from a base of nine months for other patients, progress has been slower for patients with tumors that have spread to the brain, who historically have a median survival of 4-5 months.

Checkpoint inhibitors, durable responses

Tawbi reported the initial efficacy outcomes from the CHECKMATE-204 study. All patients were treated with ipilimumab, which blocks the CTLA-4 checkpoint on T cells, in combination with nivolumab, which inhibits activation of the PD1 checkpoint. Both checkpoints otherwise shut down T cells and thus block the anti-tumor immune response. Both drugs are infusions of targeted antibodies.

Tawbi reported the unprecedented result that 41 of 75 patients (54 percent) of the patients treated to date in the trial had their brain tumors significantly shrink. Sixteen patients had a complete response—disappearance of all tumors. Importantly, at nine months of follow up, only one of the 41 responders developed disease progression, Tawbi noted, a strong sign of durable response, a hallmark of these drugs when they are effective in patients with metastatic melanoma.

A challenge to treating tumors in the brain has been getting drugs past the blood-brain barrier, a tight seal on blood vessels that protects the brain from leakage of blood-borne toxins. It appears that this treatment may work because immune checkpoint drugs treat T cells, which can get through the barrier, rather than the hit tumor directly.

Immunotherapy poses another potential risk in patients with brain tumors, Tawbi said. When checkpoint blockade works, tumors get inflamed by the immune response, and often swell up before shrinking.

"In the closed space of the brain, inflammation and swelling could cause additional neurological side effects," Tawbi said. "We saw no increase in neurological events in the combination trial, just the range of toxicities that we find in patients with no brain metastases."

Serious treatment-related side effects, grade 3 or 4 adverse events, occurred in 52 percent of patients and were safely managed, typical of melanoma patients receiving the combination. One patient died of cardiac inflammation related to treatment.

Targeted therapy 1-2 punch

Davies presented the results of the COMBI-MB clinical trial. All of the patients in the trial had metastatic melanoma with a BRAF V600 mutation, which is the most common oncogenic mutation in this cancer, occurring in about half of patients. Patients received dabrafenib, which targets the BRAF600 mutations, and trametinib, which binds to and inhibits MEK 1 and 2. Both BRAF and MEK are protein kinases in the RAS/RAF/MEK/ERK signaling pathway, which regulates cell growth. They are approved as oral single agents and in combination against metastatic or inoperable melanoma.

The trial included four different groups of patients, who varied in the specific types of BRAF mutations they had; whether or not they had received previous treatments for brain metastases; and whether the symptoms from the brain metastases were controlled or not. The largest group of patients in the trial had a BRAF V600E mutation, no prior treatments to their brain tumors, and symptoms caused by the brain metastases were under control.

Davies reported 44 of the 76 patients (58 percent) in that group had their brain tumors significantly shrink, and four had a complete response. Similar results were observed in the other three groups in the trials, although those groups were much smaller (16-17 patients per group).

While this response rate approached those previously observed in patients without brain metastases, the duration of brain tumor control was shorter. On average, responses lasted 6-7 months, in contrast to the average duration of about one year in previous of patients without brain metastases, and in contrast to the results with ipilimumab and nivolumab.

"Treatment with dabrafenib and trametinib had impressive initial activity in the patients. The important question is how do we make the responses last longer," Davies said. Combining these drugs with other treatments, including radiation or drugs that block other pathways that have been identified specifically in metastases, is one potential approach. Higher doses of dabrafenib and trametinib could also be explored as a strategy to improve outcomes, Davies added.

The COMBI-MB trial results are published in Lancet Oncology online as of June 4.

Next Steps

Davies and Tawbi note additional follow up is necessary to more fully gauge the impact of these combinations on melanoma with . However, these initial results strongly support the feasibility of conducting prospective in this under-studied population- and reinforce the need for continued research to improve outcomes further.

The immunotherapy trial was sponsored by Bristol-Myers Squibb, which markets ipilimumab (Yervoy) and nivolumab (Opdivo). The targeted therapy trial was sponsored by Novartis Pharmaceuticals, which markets dabrafenib (Tafinlar) and trametinib (Mekinist).

Explore further: Combined immunotherapy could help control melanoma that has spread to the brain

Related Stories

Combined immunotherapy could help control melanoma that has spread to the brain

June 5, 2017
A combination of two immunotherapy drugs is safe to give to patients with melanoma, a type of skin cancer, that has spread to the brain, and could help control the disease.

Immune and targeted therapies with radiation therapy improves outcomes for melanoma brain metastases patients

September 21, 2016
Brain metastases are one of the most common complications of advanced melanoma, requiring multidisciplinary management. Patients who are diagnosed with these metastases have an expected median survival of only 4 to 5 months. ...

New immunotherapy combination shows promise for patients with advanced melanoma

April 5, 2017
Treatment with a combination of ipilimumab (Yervoy) and Coxsackievirus A21 (CVA21; Cavatak) led to durable responses in a number of patients with advanced melanoma, including some whose melanoma had progressed despite prior ...

New drug shrinks brain tumours in melanoma patients

May 21, 2012
(Medical Xpress) -- Australian researchers have reported promising results with a new drug that shrinks brain tumours in melanoma patients. Their findings are published in The Lancet medical journal today.

Dabrafenib shrinks melanoma brain metastases in phase I clinical trial

May 17, 2012
An experimental drug targeting a common mutation in melanoma successfully shrank tumors that spread to the brain in nine out of 10 patients in part of an international phase I clinical trial report in the May 18 issue of ...

Adding the IDO-pathway inhibitor indoximod to pembrolizumab improved the melanoma response rate

April 5, 2017
Adding the investigational immunotherapy indoximod to the FDA-approved immunotherapy pembrolizumab (Keytruda) increased the proportion of patients with advanced melanoma who responded to treatment compared with previously ...

Recommended for you

Researchers discover specific tumor environment that triggers cells to metastasize

November 21, 2017
A team of bioengineers and bioinformaticians at the University of California San Diego have discovered how the environment surrounding a tumor can trigger metastatic behavior in cancer cells. Specifically, when tumor cells ...

New study points the way to therapy for rare cancer that targets the young

November 21, 2017
After years of rigorous research, a team of scientists has identified the genetic engine that drives a rare form of liver cancer. The findings offer prime targets for drugs to treat the usually lethal disease, fibrolamellar ...

Clinical trial suggests new cell therapy for relapsed leukemia patients

November 20, 2017
A significant proportion of children and young adults with treatment-resistant B-cell leukemia who participated in a small study achieved remission with the help of a new form of gene therapy, according to researchers at ...

Cell-weighing method could help doctors choose cancer drugs

November 20, 2017
Doctors have many drugs available to treat multiple myeloma, a type of blood cancer. However, there is no way to predict, by genetic markers or other means, how a patient will respond to a particular drug. This can lead to ...

Researchers discover a new target for 'triple-negative' breast cancer

November 20, 2017
So-called "triple-negative" breast cancer is a particularly aggressive and difficult-to-treat form. It accounts for only about 10 percent of breast cancer cases, but is responsible for about 25 percent of breast cancer fatalities.

Study reveals new mechanism used by cancer cells to disarm attacking immune cells

November 20, 2017
A new study by researchers at The Ohio State University Comprehensive Cancer Center - James Cancer Hospital and Solove Research Institute (OSUCCC - James) identifies a substance released by pancreatic cancer cells that protects ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.