Where language pionieer Paul Broca and alien music meet

March 13, 2018, Max Planck Society
Broca's area, restricted to the left hemisphere, is centrally involved in language processing. The equivalent area, in the right hemisphere (red), plays a similar role but for the processing of music. More specifically, it's activated when we notice violations of musical grammar. The areas in blue are typically associated with working memory and show increased brain activity when the grammar gets longer and more complicated. Credit: Nature Scientific Reports

What might alien music sound like? Would it be structured hierarchically as our music is with verses and a chorus? Would we even be able to appreciate it? Vincent Cheung from Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences, thinks the answer would be yes, assuming it was predicated on local and non-local dependencies. His research published this week in Scientific Reports explains what exactly that means.

Vincent Cheung, along with Angela Friederici, has been investigating non-local dependencies in music and trying to determine how the human processes them. In language and music, dependencies are conceptual threads that bind two things together. Non-local dependencies bind non-adjacent items. For example, in pop music, the second instance of a verse, following a chorus, would have a non-local dependency with the first instance of the verse. Experientially, it is clear to us that we are hearing a sequence that we have heard before. According to Cheung, composers use such devices to build up our expectations and elicit strong emotional responses to the music. But how does the brain recognize these patterns and what does this have to do with Paul Broca?

Paul Broca was a famous French physician and anatomist whose work with aphasic patients in the 1800s led to the discovery of Broca's area; a small patch of the cerebral cortex just above the temple, specifically on the left side of the brain. Broca's area is critical for speech production and for the processing of, you guessed it, dependencies in language. For example, Broca's area is active when we detect violations to our well-learned grammatical rules. Surprisingly, despite Broca's area being one of the most studied regions, neuroscientists are still not exactly sure what the same region does, on the other side of the brain.

Theory suggests the right hemisphere equivalent, or homologue, of Broca's area plays a similar role but for the processing of music instead of language. However, researchers have had difficulty demonstrating this, partly due to an inability to tease apart contributions of local and non-local dependencies to the structural hierarchy of the music. Enter Vincent Cheung's alien music.

Of course, Mr. Cheung doesn't really have authentic music from a distant world but that is how he referred to the music he developed for his study. He created a novel 'genre' of music described as, "randomly generated combinations of tone-triplets that were combined in a palindrome-like manner". While that may not sound very pleasant, the short stimuli were actually quite pleasing to the ear. Vincent's stimuli allowed the team to overcome the confounding hurtle of local dependencies. Importantly, there were sequences that conformed to a fabricated musical grammar as well as sequences that did not. This opened the door to determining where in the brain musical, non-local, dependencies are processed.

Musicians of varying expertise were invited to the laboratory to listen to Cheung's short compositions. Their task was to guess whether individual sequences were grammatical, or not, and through their correct and incorrect responses, determine the underlying grammatical rule. Once the rule was learned participants were invited to perform the task in an MRI scanner, allowing the researchers to see which brain areas were recruited. The researchers hypothesized bilateral activation of the , the anatomical structure housing Broca's area, during ungrammatical sequences compared to grammatical sequences. A clever manipulation also allowed them to dissociate between the processing of the non-local dependencies and the sheer demand on working memory. The complexity of the sequences was systematically varied such that more information would need to be held in memory in certain conditions.

The results, published in Scientific Reports this week, were consistent with their predictions, plus one surprise. The so-called Inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) was activated more during sequences which were ungrammatical than grammatical, although brain activity was more weighted towards the right hemisphere. That is, the brain became more active in the IFG during grammatical violations of the learned rule, but that tended to be more on the right than in Broca's area on the left. Frontal and parietal regions with known roles in working memory were also found to underlie the complexity dimension of the task. Interestingly, the researchers found that the degree of functional connectivity, between brain regions involved in detecting grammatical violations and those related to working memory, predicted the performance accuracy of the participants in determining whether a sequence was grammatical or not. This suggests the task is accomplished through the integration of information in memory with some form of neural computation of the musical grammar in the right homologue of Broca's area.

Vincent Cheung, first author of the underlying study, suggests the importance of the work lies in demonstrating that neurons capable of encoding non-local dependencies are not 'supra-modal'. Rather, subpopulations seem to be geared for different stimulus types, now including .

Explore further: 'Broca's area' processes both language and music at the same time

More information: Vincent K. M. Cheung et al, The right inferior frontal gyrus processes nested non-local dependencies in music, Scientific Reports (2018). DOI: 10.1038/s41598-018-22144-9

Related Stories

'Broca's area' processes both language and music at the same time

November 10, 2015
When you read a book and listen to music, the brain doesn't keep these two tasks nicely separated. A new study shows there is an area in the brain which is busy with both at the same time: Broca's area. This area has been ...

Right brain also important for learning a new language

October 17, 2017
Novel language learning activates different neural processes than was previously thought. A Leiden research team has discovered parallel but separate contributions from the hippocampus and Broca's area, the learning centre ...

Neuroscientists find Broca's area is really two subunits, each with its own function

October 16, 2012
A century and a half ago, French physician Pierre Paul Broca found that patients with damage to part of the brain's frontal lobe were unable to speak more than a few words. Later dubbed Broca's area, this region is believed ...

Your brain responses to music reveal if you're a musician or not

January 23, 2018
How your brain responds to music listening can reveal whether you have received musical training, according to new Nordic research conducted in Finland (University of Jyväskylä and AMI Center) and Denmark (Aarhus University).

Brain's iconic seat of speech goes silent when we actually talk

February 17, 2015
For 150 years, the iconic Broca's area of the brain has been recognized as the command center for human speech, including vocalization. Now, scientists at UC Berkeley and Johns Hopkins University in Maryland are challenging ...

Learning with music can change brain structure, study shows

July 6, 2017
Using musical cues to learn a physical task significantly develops an important part of the brain, according to a new study.

Recommended for you

Focus on early stage of illness may be key to treating ALS, study suggests

March 22, 2018
A new kind of genetically engineered mouse and an innovation in how to monitor those mice during research have shed new light on the early development of an inherited form of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS).

Flow of spinal fluid disrupted in inherited developmental disorder

March 22, 2018
Scientists have pinpointed the mechanism behind hydrocephalus, an accumulation of cerebrospinal fluid around the brain, in an inherited developmental disorder called Noonan syndrome.

Obesity trigger identified within the human gut

March 22, 2018
The key chemical for happiness and sadness, serotonin, is also a force in our body's weight gain and calorie control, and scientists say more research could reduce obesity rates.

New wearable brain scanner allows patients to move freely for the first time

March 21, 2018
A new generation of brain scanner, that can be worn like a helmet allowing patients to move naturally whilst being scanned, has been developed by researchers at the Sir Peter Mansfield Imaging Centre, University of Nottingham ...

International team confirms new genetic mutation link to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

March 21, 2018
Kinesin family member 5A (KIF5A), a gene previously linked to two rare neurodegenerative disorders, has been definitively connected to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) by an international team from several of the world's ...

New ALS gene points to common role of cytoskeleton in disease

March 21, 2018
An international team of researchers led by John Landers, PhD, at UMass Medical School, and Bryan Traynor, MD, PhD, at the National Institute on Aging at the National Institutes of Health (NIH), has identified KIF5A as a ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 13, 2018
Music demonstrates that we're solving problems - and processing information generally - via a process of entropy reduction. The phenomenon that is key to all this is the solution to the paradox of octave equivalence.

Spatial and temporal frequencies (ie. in harmonic and rhythmic domains) in a factor-of-two relationship are the simplest possible freq. relationships, and these entropic minima correlate with connective and impulse rate entropic minima.

Thus all the information we model and process internally is constituted in the form of spatiotemporal modulation of factor-of-two symmetries; borne of the inherent thermodynamics of multicellular information processing.

Thus all complex animals must be subject to the equivalence paradox, not least aliens! They will therefore derive tonal systems by dividing octaves, likely aligned to the harmonic series, and share a similar affinity for rhythm.

Obviously, this principle applies to all higher processing, including language.
not rated yet Mar 13, 2018
There seems to always be unwarranted assumptions about what music actually is when researchers study music and so the results are analysis of their definition of music and not of music itself.

For instance the assumption that music must have a beat, melody, rhythm or even that it must be 'pleasant to the ear' would require us to rename half of what was previously called music to something else.

Firstly, movie, documentary and dramatic background music often consists of a single chord (no melody, no beat, no rhythm) and can be painful to the ear (to evoke negative emotion, conger discord, pain, other negative emotions and feelings).

People who hate some particular form of music, say a classical fan listening to punk, grunge or the like or visa versa, can still identify the offensive-to-the-ear sound as music.

But researchers tend to think of pleasant, melodic tunes enjoyed by the listener as the default form of music…wrong!!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.