Trio of evolutionary biologists caution against rushing mitochondrial replacement trials

September 20, 2013 by Bob Yirka, Medical Xpress report
Trio of evolutionary biologists caution against rushing mitochondrial replacement trials
A human ovum is fertilised using IVF techniques

(Medical Xpress)—Three evolutionary biologists with ties to research facilities in the U.K., Germany and Australia have published a Policy Forum piece in the journal Science suggesting that governmental agencies slow the rush to allow mitochondrial replacement (MR) therapy to undergo clinical trials. A trial is currently on track in the U.K. that could lead to the in vitro fertilization (IVF) technique being made available to the British public as early as 2015.

MR has been developed as a means of helping people with mitochondrial have healthy babies. Women with such mutations tend to have babies with a wide variety of which quite often prevent them from surviving into . MR involves removing the pronuclei from a fertilized embryo and inserting it into an embryo that has been donated by another woman—the pronuclei from the donor embryo is discarded. The end result is a single embryo with the original mother's pronuclei and the donor's mitochondria—placed into the of the original mother leading to the birth of a child. Thus far the technique has led to the birth of four offspring by a macaque mother—who are now three years old. Testing in humans has only gone so far as the blastocyst stage, approximately 5 days after fertilization. Because results so far have shown such promise, the U.K.'s IVF governing body, Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, wants to start clinical trials of the technique using volunteer women, as soon as possible.

Klaus Reinhardt, Damian Dowling and Edward Morrow write in Science, that they are concerned that the rush to clinical testing might be premature. They suggest the government wait for more research to be conducted before running trials that could conceivably result in babies being born with . At issue is the DNA present in mitochondria—though there is just a very small amount of it, the researchers are worried that not enough testing has been conducted regarding its interaction with the DNA found in the pronuclei. They point out that some research has suggested there may be problems with matching in some circumstances leading to birth defects. They note also that the macaque offspring haven't even reached adulthood yet, which means no one yet knows if they will develop defects, such as problems with fertility.

The trio is not suggesting work be stopped on the technique or that it's dangerous, immoral or wrong (as others have claimed), they simply believe that more time should be devoted to testing before taking a leap of faith that the technique will work as hoped in humans, resulting in a human being who had no say in the decision making process.

Explore further: Researchers develop new tool to find molecular changes in embryos

More information: Mitochondrial Replacement, Evolution, and the Clinic, Science 20 September 2013: Vol. 341 no. 6152 pp. 1345-1346 DOI: 10.1126/science.1237146

Mitochondrial diseases [often caused by mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)] can manifest in a range of severe symptoms, for which there are currently no cures (1). The diseases are passed from mothers to offspring. Intense research efforts have recently focused on a germline therapeutic strategy to prevent the inheritance of disease-causing mitochondria. However, although there has been increased government interest, especially in the United Kingdom, for using this approach to treat patients, there are reasons to believe that it is premature to move this technology into the clinic at this stage.

Press release

Related Stories

Researchers develop new tool to find molecular changes in embryos

September 6, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—A combined team of researchers from the U.S. and Singapore has developed a new tool to help spot molecular changes in embryos. As the team describes in their paper published in the journal Science, the ...

UK may OK creating babies with DNA from 3 people

June 27, 2013
(AP)—Britain may allow a controversial technique to create babies using DNA from three people, a move that would help couples avoid passing on rare genetic diseases, the country's top medical officer says.

UK: Public OK with creating babies from three people

March 20, 2013
Britain's fertility regulator says it has found broad public support for in vitro fertilization techniques that allow babies to be created with DNA from three people for couples at risk of passing on potentially fatal genetic ...

UK health regulators apply brakes to 'three-parent' IVF procedure

April 20, 2011
( -- In what is rapidly turning into a political debate in the United Kingdom, members of the Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority (HFEA) have, after careful review, declined to allow legislation to be ...

'Three-parent babies' public consultation launched

September 17, 2012
The British public are being consulted on the ethics of a fertility treatment that uses DNA from a third parent to help eliminate genetic diseases, the government announced on Monday.

Recommended for you

Rise in preterm births linked to clinical intervention

January 18, 2018
Research at the University of Adelaide shows preterm births in South Australia have increased by 40 percent over 28 years and early intervention by medical professionals has resulted in the majority of the increase.

New report calls into question effectiveness of pregnancy anti-nausea drug

January 17, 2018
Previously unpublished information from the clinical trial that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration relied on to approve the most commonly prescribed medicine for nausea in pregnancy indicates the drug is not effective, ...

New study finds 'baby brain' is real, but the cause remains mysterious

January 15, 2018
So-called "baby brain" refers to increased forgetfulness, inattention, and mental "fogginess" reported by four out of five pregnant women. These changes in brain function during pregnancy have long been recognised in midwifery ...

Sleep quality improves with help of incontinence drug

January 12, 2018
A drug used to curtail episodes of urinary incontinence in women also improves quality of sleep, a researcher at the Stanford University School of Medicine reports.

Frozen embryos result in just as many live births in IVF

January 10, 2018
Freezing and subsequent transfer of embryos gives infertile couples just as much of a chance of having a child as using fresh embryos for in vitro fertilization (IVF), research from Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, and Adelaide, ...

Study suggests air pollution breathed in the months before and after conception increases chance of birth defects

January 8, 2018
A team of researchers with the University of Cincinnati and Cincinnati Children's Hospital has found evidence that indicates that pre-and post-pregnant women living in an area with air pollution are at an increased risk of ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 20, 2013
Cancer is a mitochondrial disease, therefore repairs to the mitochondria may have benefit.
Due to the large number of cells one would have to favour a vector of some sort.
not rated yet Sep 22, 2013
One assumes that similar experiments were carried out on shorter lived models such as mice - before primate models. If there was no indication of birth defects in mice, there is a high probability there will not be in primates, but not absolute certainty. Also, most developmental defects are likely to be apparent in in the first three years of development in clinically well monitored primates. All things considered, human trials using patients with greater risk levels to their disease particulars, than those risk levels possible but not probable in the this research should make their own decisions.

We have to remember that there will always be risks to clinical research trials, what is important is that those risks are in context and perspective to the absolute risks without the research. That and that there will always be those that object, because it is an easy way to be notable if they are correct, and more than likely forgotten if they are wrong. That's the world we live in.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.