The art of building bone

August 27, 2018 by Thamarasee Jeewandara, Medical Xpress feature
The preprogrammed mechanism of bone formation a) primary ossification (embryonic) b) secondary ossification (postnatal). Credit: Bone Research, doi: 10.1038/s41413-018-0021-z

Cell differentiation is a widely studied phenomenon forming the basis of all developmental processes including fetal growth and bone fracture healing. A series of recent studies indicates the emerging role of chondrocyte-to-osteoblast transdifferentiation during bone tissue formation, known as endochondral ossification (replacing cartilage with bone).

While transdifferentiation is not a new phenomenon and occurs when mature switch from one differentiated phenotype to another, new data have identified three models for chondrocyte (cartilage) to osteoblast (bone) transdifferentiation during fracture healing. Now writing in Bone Research, Patrick Aghajanian and Subburaman Mohan have dissected the three emerging models and categorized them to better understand the process of bone building. The new knowledge will allow bioengineers in regenerative medicine to advance the molecular basis of bone repair.

During typical cell differentiation, programmed cells progress along a specific lineage until they reach an endpoint of terminal differentiation and apoptosis. Transdifferentiation does not follow the preprogrammed path, switching instead from one mature phenotype to another. Prior to assessing the newly discovered mechanisms of chondrocyte-to-osteoblast transdifferentiation, the authors first reviewed the traditional mechanism of endochondral ossification.

The typical process of replacing cartilage with bone is divided into primary and secondary pathways, beginning with a template of rapidly proliferating immature chondrocytes that secrete a collagen matrix. In the primary process, chondrocytes undergo differentiation to form the bone matrix, facilitate bone forming cells (mesenchymal stromal cells) to enter the process and differentiate into osteoblasts/osteocytes during embryogenesis, while the chondrocytes themselves become hypertrophic to undergo apoptosis. The secondary process occurs similarly but post-natally, during which immature chondrocytes become hypertrophic and undergo apoptosis, and the vasculature invades to transport marrow, and osteoclast precursors to initiate at the center and extend peripherally.

Models of bone formation a) endochondral ossification – mesenchymal stem cells develop into two different lineages; chondrogenic or osteogenic without intermediates, b) intramembranous ossification – osteoblast development without the formation of a chondrocyte template: mesenchymal stem cells directly differentiate into an osteogenic lineage, c) chondrocyte to osteogenic precursor – immature chondrocytes differentiate into an osteogenic precursor population that differentiate into pre-osteoblasts and osteoblasts, d) de-differentiation to redifferentiation – hypertrophic chondrocytes dedifferentiate into immature chondrocytes that directly differentiate into an osteogenic fate, e) direct transdifferentiation – hypertrophic chondrocytes directly differentiate into osteoblasts. The starred mechanisms indicate the three pathways of transdifferentiation. Credit: Bone Research, doi: 10.1038/s41413-018-0021-z.

The process of endochondral ossification is also involved during natural bone fracture healing. The authors categorized the models of bone formation, including the canonical and transdifferentiation pathways:

  1. Endochondral ossification – a canonical pathway; mesenchymal stem cells differentiate to chondrogenic, adipogenic or osteogenic cells for subsequent terminal differentiation during bone formation.
  2. Intramembranous ossification—also plays an important role during canonical bone formation (forming flat bones in the skull, mandible and clavicle), the differentiating mesenchymal stem cells directly form the periosteum.
  3. Chondrocyte to osteogenic precursor model – a mechanism that generates both stem cells and osteoblasts during rapid . The model appears to be specific to metaphyseal (narrow portion of a long bone) growth, which occurs embryonically during primary ossification for most parts, but can extend into post-natal growth.
  4. Dedifferentiation to redifferentiation—an alternative view of chondro-osteogenic transdifferentiation, where chondrocytes undergo hypertrophy to either enter apoptosis or dedifferentiate into osteoblasts and further into osteocytes. The model occurs during embryonic and postnatal development, as well as during fracture healing, supported by studies, while open for further experimental interpretation to validate the mechanism.
  5. Direct transdifferentiation – a method by which postnatal secondary ossification occurs: chondrocytes mature and become hypertrophic, but do not enter apoptosis, instead differentiate directly into osteoblasts and osteocytes. The models are supported by experimental studies both in vitro and in vivo.

While the exact cause for chondrocyte to osteoblast transdifferentiation is unknown, regulatory factors are necessary for that transition. Runx2 gene, for instance, is a master regulator of osteogenic fate, capable of transdifferentiating adipocytes, primary skeletal myoblasts, odontoblasts and vascular smooth muscle cells to osteogenic cell types. Studies with animal models are required to validate the contribution of various signaling pathways identified in in vitro studies during chondrocyte-to-osteoblast transdifferentiation.

The researchers note that understanding the molecular basis of chondrocyte-to-osteoblast transdifferentiation during endochondral ossification is clinically relevant since:

  1. Current therapies for non-union fraction involve mesenchymal stem cells derived from patients to promote direct bone formation at the site of fracture, but these strategies are not effective and may be cost-prohibitive. Molecular events that directly convert chondrocytes to osteoblasts can potentially lead to novel therapeutic strategies to heal non-union fractures.
  2. New strategies can be developed to manipulate signals that control chondrocytes to osteoblast transdifferentiation during osteochondral ossification for therapeutic benefit in the treatment of joint injury and disease.
  3. If, as predicted, chondrocytes contribute an important source of osteoblasts and other bone formation processes during bone growth, then studying the mechanisms of transdifferentiation will provide exciting new strategies to develop anabolic therapies for bone wasting diseases such as osteoporosis.

Innovative experimental studies in the future could probe the contribution of chondrogenic tissue to new bone, with significant potential for new avenues of therapeutics in bone tissue engineering, to promote and decline the progress of various osteogenic diseases. Research on -to-osteoblast is still at an early stage and could potentially resolve several unresolved and conflicting questions in research.

Explore further: Engineered cartilage template to heal broken bones

More information: Apoptosis the sculptor of development Andrea Doseff, 2004, Stem Cells and Development.

Transdifferentiation of myoblasts into osteoblasts – possible use for bone therapy Lin et al, 2017, J Pharm Pharmacol

Epiphyseal bone formation occurs via thyroid hormone regulation of chondrocyte to osteoblast transdifferentiation Aghajanian et al, Sept 2017, Scientific Reports

Dedifferentiation, redifferentiation, and transdifferentiation of striated muscles during regeneration and development Manfred Frasch, 2016 Curr Top Dev Biol.

TNAP stimulates vascular smooth muscle cell trans-differentiation into chondrocytes through calcium deposition and BMP-2 activation: possible implication in atherosclerotic plaque stability Fakhry et al, 2017, Biochim. Biophys. Acta

Development of the endochondral skeleton Long F., and Ornitz DM, 2013, Cold Spring Harb Perspect Biol

Developmental regulation of the growth plate Henry Kronenberg, 2003, Nature.

Bone development and its relation to fracture repair. The role of mesenchymal osteoblasts and surface osteoblasts Shapiro F, 2008, Eur Cell Mater

9. Fate of growth plate hypertrophic chondrocytes: death or lineage extension? Tsang et al, 2015, Dev Growth Differ.

Chondrocytes transdifferentiate into osteoblasts in endochondral bone during development, postnatal growth and fracture healing in mice. Zhou et al, 2014, PLoS Genet

WNT/beta-catenin signaling promotes VSMCs to osteogenic transdifferentiation and calcification through directly modulating Runx2 gene expression. Cai et al, 2016 Exp. Cell Res.

Ihh and Runx2/Runx3 signaling interact to coordinate early chondrogenesis: a mouse model. Kim et al, 2013, PLoS One.

Related Stories

Engineered cartilage template to heal broken bones

March 8, 2018
A team of UConn Health researchers has designed a novel, hybrid hydrogel system to help address some of the challenges in repairing bone in the event of injury. The UConn Health team, led by associate professor of orthopedic ...

Researchers describe mechanism that underlies age-associated bone loss

September 22, 2017
A major health problem in older people is age-associated osteoporosis—the thinning of bone and the loss of bone density that increases the risk of fractures. Often this is accompanied by an increase in fat cells in the ...

Decellularized cartilage-based scaffold promotes bone regeneration at fracture site

June 22, 2018
To help prevent possible complications such as nonunion at large fracture sites, researchers have developed a cartilage matrix that mimics the early stages of repair and provides the essential structural and biological properties ...

Platelet-rich plasma does not promote stem cell-mediated cartilage repair

August 13, 2018
Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) is believed to provide pain relief and help improve joint function in degenerative joint disease, but a new study has shown that it does not act by promoting stem cell proliferation or enhance the ...

Recommended for you

Separated entry and exit doors for calcium keep energy production smooth in the powerhouses of heart cells

September 18, 2018
Stress demands the heart to work harder and faster. To keep pace, the muscle must make its fuel at an accelerated rate. Bursts of calcium entering mitochondria—the cell's powerhouses—normally help control energy output, ...

First gut bacteria may have lasting effect on ability to fight chronic diseases

September 18, 2018
New research showing that the first bacteria introduced into the gut have a lasting impact may one day allow science to adjust microbiomes—the one-of-a-kind microbial communities that live in our gastrointestinal tracts—to ...

A new defender for your sense of smell

September 18, 2018
New research from the Monell Center increases understanding of a mysterious sensory cell located in the olfactory epithelium, the patch of nasal tissue that contains odor-detecting olfactory receptor cells. The findings suggest ...

Small molecule plays big role in weaker bones as we age

September 18, 2018
With age, expression of a small molecule that can silence others goes way up while a key signaling molecule that helps stem cells make healthy bone goes down, scientists report.

Sperm quality study updates advice for couples trying to conceive

September 17, 2018
Could doctors at fertility clinics be giving men bad advice? Dr. Da Li and Dr. XiuXia Wang, who are clinician-researchers at the Center for Reproductive Medicine of Shengjing Hospital in Shenyang in northeast China, think ...

Antioxidant found to be effective in treating mice with osteoarthritis

September 14, 2018
A team of researchers in Belgium and the Netherlands has found that feeding a common antioxidant to test mice was effective in treating osteoarthritis. In their paper published in Science Translational Medicine, the group ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.